Super-stable Matching Essay

Submitted By portevy
Words: 9010
Pages: 37
Open Document
Irving, R. W. and Manlove, D. F. (2002) The stable roommates problem with ties. Journal of Algorithms 43(1):85-105. http://eprints.gla.ac.uk/archive/00000011 Glasgow ePrints Service http://eprints.gla.ac.uk The Stable Roommates Problem with Ties∗
Robert W. Irving and David F. Manlove
Department of Computing Science, University of Glasgow, Glasgow G12 8QQ, UK.
Email: {rwi,davidm}@dcs.gla.ac.uk.

Abstract
We study the variant of the well-known Stable Roommates problem in which participants are permitted to express ties in their preference lists. In this setting, more than one definition of stability is possible. Here we consider two of these stability criteria, so-called super-stability and weak stability. We present a linear-time algorithm for finding a super-stable matching if one exists, given a Stable Roommates instance with ties. This contrasts with the known NP-hardness of the analogous problem under weak stability. We also extend our algorithm to cope with preference lists that are incomplete and/or partially ordered. On the other hand, for a given Stable Roommates instance with ties and incomplete lists, we show that the weakly stable matchings may be of different sizes, and the problem of finding a maximum cardinality weakly stable matching is NP-hard, though approximable within a factor of 2.
Keywords: stable matching problem; indifference; super-stability; weak stability; linear-time algorithm; NP-completeness; approximation algorithm

1

Introduction

In a given instance of the Stable Roommates problem (SR), each of 2n participants ranks the others in strict order of preference. A matching is a set of n disjoint (unordered) pairs of participants. A matching M in an instance of SR is stable if there are no two participants x and y, each of whom prefers the other to his partner in M . Such a pair is said to block M , or to be a blocking pair with respect to M . Gale and Shapley [2] were the first to study
SR, and gave an example instance which does not admit a stable matching. Irving [7] solved a problem posed by Knuth [12] when he described an O(n2 ) algorithm (henceforth
Algorithm SR) – linear in the input size – to find a stable matching if one exists, for a given instance of SR. Subsequently, Gusfield [4] and Irving [8] explored structural aspects of SR, and a comprehensive discussion of the problem is given by Gusfield and Irving [5].
In addition, Tan [18] introduced the concept of a stable partition in an instance I of SR, which provides a ‘succinct certificate’ in the case that I does not admit a stable matching.
More recently, Feder et al. [1] presented an O(n log 3 n) parallel algorithm for finding a stable matching if one exists, for a given instance of SR.
Note that SR is a non-bipartite extension of the classical Stable Marriage problem
(SM) [5]. In an instance of SM, the set of participants is partitioned into two disjoint sets, the men and women, and each person ranks all members of the opposite sex in strict order of preference. An analogous stability definition holds in this context. It is known that every instance of SM admits at least one stable matching, and such a matching may be found in linear time using the Gale/Shapley algorithm [2].
∗

This work was supported by Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council grant number
GR/M13329.

1

1.1

Incomplete preference lists

SR may be generalised by allowing the preference lists of those involved to be incomplete
(we refer to this problem as SRI). In this case, we say that participant p is acceptable to participant q if p appears on the preference list of q, and unacceptable otherwise. A matching M in an instance of SRI must satisfy the property that {x, y} ∈ M implies that x, y find each other acceptable. The revised notion of stability may be defined as follows: given an instance of SRI, a matching M is stable if there are no two participants x and y, each of whom either is
Show More

Related Documents: Super-stable Matching Essay

Theoretical Models in Careers Guidance Practice Essay

too much on what occupation/type to enter, at the expense of returning to employment or making career development decisions for instance, for my clientele this ‘matching’ approach may be helpful to identify possible future career choices or to help with decisions such as what route to take after statutory education. ‘Personality matching theories, suggest that individuals select work environments which represent a ‘way of life’ and are consistent with their personalities. In this way a choice of…

Words 3239 - Pages 13

Samsung Marketing Strategy

loyal and appreciating the brand. Samsung is enjoying very good position against its competitors. The company is maintaining very good relationship with its suppliers. The company is also maintaining with laborers. Samsung is a financial strong and Stable. The production processes and procedures of inventory management are consistent with industrial standards. WEAKNESSES Samsung is facing hard competition. South Korea’s labor unions are strategically linked for collective bargaining and negotiation…

Words 1974 - Pages 8

Essay on Garrett Metal Detectors

THANK YOU FOR CHOOSING GARRETT METAL DETECTORS! Congratulations on the purchase of your new Garrett AT Pro™ metal detector. This enhanced metal detector has been specifically designed for use in more challenging environments such as mineralized grounds and iron-cluttered relic and coin hunting areas. The AT Pro includes Garrett's exclusive Target ID technology and patented discrimination features. Two indicator scales allow you to see the detector’s discrimination setting (Lower Scale)…

Words 8485 - Pages 34

Representative: Mcdonald ' s and Company Essay

McDonalds A SWOT analysis is a look at a company’s strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats, and is an excellent way to gain a detailed and thorough perspective on a company and its future. Fresh of a disastrous third quarter earnings report, I would like to pinpoint on the golden arches, McDonald’s Corporation (NYSE: MCD). Strengths: * Stability and Predictability: McDonald’s has been serving burgers since 1940, and will continue this success into the future because of their innovative…

Words 4136 - Pages 17

Final Marketing Plan Paper

attract more of the same market. Advertisements Social Media will be creating a buzz on the product before it is released. What will create the biggest buzz is getting airtime during a big sporting event such as the super bowl. The reason why we want to start advertisements around the super bowl is because it is right before spring and that is the perfect time to release this watch. Spring is a warmer season and with a warmer season comes short sleeves and shirts. This will be perfect for our target…

Words 6534 - Pages 27

Module 5 Group Team Essay

group is two or more persons who are interacting with one another in such a manner that each person influences and is influenced by each other person." In other words, a group is refers to a collection of two or more interacting individuals with a stable pattern of relationships between them; who share common goals and who perceive themselves as being a group. E.H. Schein prescribes three conditions which any number of persons to be called a group should satisfy. The three conditions are: (i) People…

Words 6652 - Pages 27

Disney: Computer Security and Hard Security Company Essay

MBA 525: Applied Marketing Marketing Plan Student: Aleksey Biryukov Table of Content I. Executive Summary Hard Security Company will begin operations in January, 2009 and provide high security networked solutions to customers inside the United States and abroad, specifically targeting companies having more than 100 employees. The founders of the Hard Security Company are experienced Information Technology and Business professionals and passionate about the software…

Words 5367 - Pages 22

Essay on Dick's Sporting Goods, Equity Valuation and Analysis

Table of Contents Executive Summary 2 Company Overview 2 Economic Analysis GDP Growth 3 Inflation 3 Interest Rates 3 Housing 5 Consumer Spending 5 Sovereign Debt 6 Unemployment 6 US Dollar 7 Impact of Sporting Goods Stores Industry 7 Industry Analysis 8 Porter’s 5 Forces 8 Big Four Analysis 11 Industry Life Cycle 13 Dick’s Sporting Goods Analysis Review of Annual Report 16 Company SWOT Analysis 18 Trend Ratio Analysis 20 Cross Sectional Ratio Analysis…

Words 8837 - Pages 36

Solutions Manual Essay

Solutions Manual FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT Principles and Practice Fifth Edition Timothy J. Gallagher Colorado State University  2009 Freeload Press, Madison Wisconsin (Insert publication data on this page) i Solutions Manual to accompany Financial Management: Principles and Practice 5th Edition by Timothy J. Gallagher This solutions manual provides the answers to all the review questions and end-of-chapter problems in Financial Management: Principles and Practice, by Timothy…

Words 49126 - Pages 197

Managing Information Technology (7th Edition) Essay

CONTENTS: CASE STUDIES CASE STUDY 1 Midsouth Chamber of Commerce (A): The Role of the Operating Manager in Information Systems CASE STUDY I-1 IMT Custom Machine Company, Inc.: Selection of an Information Technology Platform CASE STUDY I-2 VoIP2.biz, Inc.: Deciding on the Next Steps for a VoIP Supplier CASE STUDY I-3 The VoIP Adoption at Butler University CASE STUDY I-4 Supporting Mobile Health Clinics: The Children’s Health Fund of New York City CASE STUDY I-5…

Words 239873 - Pages 960