Supreme Court Case: US V. Nixon

Words: 672

Pages: 3

Open Document

n United States v. Nixon, the question before the Supreme Court was the following:

"Is the President's right to safeguard certain information, using his 'executive privilege' confidentiality power, entirely immune from judicial review?"

The Court held unanimously that neither the doctrine of separation of powers, not the generalized need for confidentiality of high-level communications could sustain an absolute, unqualified, presidential privilege. The court further held that there is a limitation on executive privilege in areas of military or diplomatic affairs, but "gave preference to the fundamental demands of due process of law in the fair administration of justice." (US v. Nixon). Therefore, according to the court's ruling, President Nixon had to …show more content…
Consequently, the Court reasoned that it had the power to interpret and consider claims brought under the express powers and that in this case, it had the authority to clarify all claims with respect to all powers that derived from the enumerated powers.
President Nixon claimed that there was a need for protection of such information and communication and that there was a clear separation of powers protecting the President from a subpoena.
In this case, there was no argument claiming that the privilege was necessary for the protection of diplomatic, military, or national security secrets. Nixon's position was based on the argument that as President, and as head of the Executive Branch, he was entitled to confidentiality because of the separation of powers. Thus the Court did not accept or found difficult to accept the rhetoric that there would be a significant reduction in the confidentiality of Presidential communications by the production of the material for in camera

Supreme Court Case: US V. Nixon

The Supreme Court case, United States v. Nixon, was during the Watergate Scandal where it was discovered that Nixon had installed a tape-recording device in the Oval Office. There was a special prosecutor who was in charge of the case who wanted access to the tapes to prove that President Nixon and his aides had abused their power and broken the law. Nixon refused to comply with the demands of the prosecutor so the case was taken up to the Supreme Court to be decided as to whether Nixon could…

Words 595 - Pages 3

A Political Scandal: The Watergate

often illegal, activities that were constructed by the people of the Nixon Administration. Some activities include ordering investigations on political groups and people by using the FBI and CIA as weapons. The Watergate scandal was a political scandal that happened in the 1970’s, involving five men who broke into the Democratic National Committee, or DNC, at the Watergate Office Complex in Washington, D.C. At the time, Richard Nixon was still president of the United States, and he was believed to…

Words 939 - Pages 4

Chief Justice Earl Warren

Board of Education was a breakthrough decision of the United States Supreme Court that declared state laws establishing segregated schools were unconstitutional. No longer were blacks and whites going to have to attend separate classes or even separate schools. This was the beginning of a transformation of our entire society. The decision overturned the Plessey v. Ferguson decision of 1896 which allowed state-sponsored segregation. Handed down on May 17th, 1954…

Words 2184 - Pages 9

Essay on History: Cold War and ho Chi Minh

Cold war 1. President Eisenhower 1952-60 a. US strong in cold war i. Arms race-missiles ii. NATO iii. Economics b. Sputnik i. First satellite in space 1. Soviets begin launching other things into space 2. Public opinion, fear, space weapons a. Eisenhower tries to calm public, popularity falls c. U2-secret spy plane, flies over soviet union i. Soviet military base photographs ii. One gets shot down, pilot is captured d. Third world-group of neutral countries, former colonies i. New…

Words 2267 - Pages 10

What Is Earl Warren's Legacy

The more he served on the court, the more Warren came to realize the importance the court’s duty to protect the people and provide checks on the often unethical legislative policy making of the time. At the time of his appointment the court, although consistently democratic was divided over the issues of judicial activism and judicial restraint. These personal divisions amongst the justices played important roles in the interpretation and decision making of the court. After Warrens addition the…

Words 1074 - Pages 5

US Government Censorship During The Vietnam War

for many public rallies to encourage and support the effort. Despite the high approval rating the US government still released crucial propaganda that displayed communist as the evil of the world. It wasn't until Nixon invaded Cambodia that many protests occurred, mostly by democratic college students that led to the US government censoring American media. During hostile times in the Vietnam War the US government fell to censoring the media in order to lower the amount of opposing riots against the…

Words 2189 - Pages 9

Single: United States Constitution Essay examples

The same principles of a separation of powers, checks and balances, federalism and entrenched rights which dominated the constitution 200 years ago dominate it still. However it could be argued that in crucial ways the constitution tells us little about how US politics actually operates. The three branches of the Federal Government of the USA - the legislature, the executive and the judiciary are totally separate. No one is allowed to be a member of more than one branch. Thus when Obama offered…

Words 1736 - Pages 7

Mr Archie Sparks Essay

that one person is part of more than one branch of government. They can recall Congress into a special session. The checks by the executive on the Judiciary is that they can nominate the Supreme Court Justices, which is nine in total, one chief justice and eight associates. They don’t have to listen to the court decisions they can override it. The President can pardon a convicted criminal. The checks by the legislature on the executive are that they can override the President veto with two thirds…

Words 1249 - Pages 5

Lyndon Johnson Powerpoint Essay

however, acknowledge that the crime did take place.The president maintains the Office of the Pardon Attorney in the U.S. Department of Justice to review all requests for pardons. Most pardons are issued as oversight of the judicial branch, especially in cases where the Federal Sentencing Guidelines are considered too severe. Pardons are controversial when they appear to be politically motivated. Under the Constitution, the president is the federal official that is primarily responsible for the relations…

Words 1101 - Pages 5

U. s. Supreme Court Essay

there was much controversy over the White House's attempts to coverup the allegations and ignore them. Led to Nixon's eventual resignation. Election of 1972 Nixon against Dem. George McGovern, with the former being the embodiment of the radical movements Nixon's "silent majority" of middleclass Americans opposed, resulting in a landslide victory for Nixon OPEC Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries: started as an informal bargaining unit but rapidly expanded and gained power. It meant to regulate the sale of oil by Third World…

Words 1254 - Pages 6