Tell-Tale Heart Argumentative Essay

Words: 440
Pages: 2
Open Document
Introduction: Blood, gore, monsters, and thrills are just a few things you can find in the “Horror” genre of literature. There are many well-known stories coming from this genre, but the “Tell-Tale Heart” takes the cake. One of the only problems the novel faces is an accusation is it is not appropriate for middle schoolers. The Tell-Tale Heart is appropriate for middle schoolers because Modern day entertainment is much more violent, middle schoolers are mature enough to read the Horror genre, and presses students to use their imagination and learn new skills throughout the story.

Body Paragraph 1: To begin with, middle schoolers are mature enough to read the Horror genre.

Body Paragraph 2: In addition, 'The Tell-Tale Heart' challenges seventh and eighth graders to understand the story of a mentally ill man. The story challenges readers to translate old English into modern speech. By having to translate olden speech to modern English, it enhances the reader’s vocabulary. By deeming ‘The Tell-Tale Heart’ as inappropriate for seventh and eighth graders, it takes away the student’s opportunities to increase their …show more content…
The Tell-Tale Heart is a short horror story about a deranged man who unremorsefully kills an old man for having an evil looking eye. Some people may argue that ‘The Tell-Tale Heart’ contains very vivid and bloody events within the story. However, the few bloody events in the story do not compare to the amount of gore in modern day entertainment. In many video games, movies, and television shows, tens of dozens of people and characters die and are instantly forgotten about. This story is the most appropriate out of any media a middle schooler can access, because, the kill count is not a three digit number, it is not as graphically described, and the way the student perceives the story can change how gory the story
Show More

Related Documents: Tell-Tale Heart Argumentative Essay

Tell-Tale Heart Argumentative Essay

in a few swift moves. What is the man’s mental state? The narrator committed one of the worst yet unfortunately common crimes which is, murder. “I dragged him to the floor, and pulled the heavy bed over him.” This quote from the short story “Tell-Tale Heart” proves the actions he did to stop the heartbeat of the old man and so he wouldn’t have to see that pale blue eye, which vexed the narrator. Everyone has a motive for their actions. The narrator’s motive to killing the man was his, “he had the…

Words 421 - Pages 2

English Language and le ha Essay

experienced by Arianto and his thesis supervisor, myself. It shows how critical EAP was the on-going conversation between us about how to negotiate norms, voice and creativity in our writing and in the negotiations Arianto had to make when writing his own essays and thesis in English and assessing his students’ written works. The article also discusses how my positioning as a writer of two languages and having a passion for my own voice and identity in writing has influenced the ways I have analysed and…

Words 9247 - Pages 37