Tell Tale Heart Comparison

Words: 511

Pages: 3

Open Document

“Tell-Tale Heart” is about man that despises an old man’s eye. Throughout the story he says, he was not mad but the action he takes in the story makes him seem mad. It was a slow paced story; it also was very descriptive and gave off a lot of details. The new version of the story was very fast paced. The original story gave off a very creepy tone. The version that had a greater impact was the original story because it gave off a better tone, it had a very slow pace and was very descriptive, and you could tell what type of mood it was supposed to be.
The first aspect of the story that was different was how the stories ended. In the student version, it ends with the narrator being arrested for murder. “There was no heartbeat but there was the body of the old man we had been looking for. He was cut up inside of the floorboard. We had all the evidence we needed to arrest him for murder”(Student, 1).We didn't’ get to see the conclusion in the original version of the story but in the original it ends it better because it leaves the reader to wonder what could happen after the narrator's dialogue. “Villains!” I shrieked, “dissemble no more! I admit the deed!—tear up the planks!—here, here!—it is the beating of his hideous heart” (Poe,5)! …show more content…
In the student version, it gives us background on why they are smiling and it is because that was what they were supposed to do with suspicious characters. “All we have to do is sit and smile and wait for them to calm. So all the while he was screaming and cursing we smiled and chatted and if nothing was going one”(Student.1). The original version displays this better because it uses very descriptive words to show the reader how exactly the police acted. “And still the men chatted pleasantly, and

Tell Tale Heart Comparison

All of the versions of “The Tell-Tale Heart” by Edgar Allan Poe profoundly expressed the theme of the story. The overall theme mentioned throughout the story was Guilt. The Three versions all focused on the same theme. The Black & White version of the story provided the best explanation of the theme because it went through details of the story and prolonged the scene of confession and guilt. In the other two versions, the scene/text used to explain the theme weren’t as long and detailed. The director…

Words 663 - Pages 3

Tell Tale Heart Comparison

What do you think about the original version of the tell tale heart and how it impact? There are two sides of The Tell Tale Heart the original and the rewritten version. The original version of the “Tell Tale Heart” is basically the same of the rewritten version. To begin with, they both sound the same but written in different point of views. The “Tell-Tale Heart" is a short story by American writer Edgar Allan Poe, first published in 1843. It is relayed by an unnamed narrator who endeavors to…

Words 342 - Pages 2

The Monkey's Paw And The Tell Tale Heart Comparison

Monkey’s Paw” and “The Tell-Tale Heart.” “The Tell-Tale Heart)” is writing by Edgar Allen Poe. (The Monkey’s Paw) is written by William Wymark Jacobs. Both of these stories are placed into the horror genre. These paragraphs will consist of the setting, characters, and plot of both of the stories. In the story (The Monkey’s Paw) and (The Tell-Tale-Heart) there are many differences. The characters in the Paw are Mr. and Mrs. white, Herbert, and Sergeant-Major Morris while in Heart, there is an old man…

Words 397 - Pages 2

The Raven And Tell Tale Heart Comparison Essay

Edgar Allan Poe and Ray Bradbury Have you ever heard of Edgar Allan Poe or Ray Bradbury? Or any of their stories Tell Tale Heart or There will come soft rains? If you haven’t you will in this essay. This essay talks about these two authors and their writing styles. It talks about their similarities, and their differences. Edgar Allan Poe had a very bad childhood. Both his parents died in 1811, leaving him an Orphan. He was only two years old when his parents died, he was later adopted by a man…

Words 510 - Pages 3

Comparing Poe's The Tell-Tale Heart And The Black Cat

part in his eminence writing style. The Tell-Tale Heart and “The Black Cat” are two perfect examples of Edgar Allan Poe’s classic horror stories. Each story is both unique in their own ways, although there are similarities that show the comparison between the two they give the reader an idea of the writer's style of writing. Edgar Allan Poe was a very enthusiastic person. His stories are told with a unique and dramatic tone to it. The Tell-Tale Heart and “The Black Cat.” ] Both of…

Words 203 - Pages 1

Tell Tale Heart Vs. W. Jacobs Analysis

Suspense is one of the most important elements in an eerie and frightening story or movie, and without it, there it wouldn’t be spine-chilling. In the story “Tell-Tale Heart” by Edgar Allen Poe, he creates a very suspenseful mood to entice readers into continuing to read the story. In the story, “The Monkey’s Paw” by W. W. Jacobs, he also creates a suspenseful mood to make readers interested and read until the end of the story. The authors of these stories, Edgar Allen Poe and W. W. Jacobs, also…

Words 727 - Pages 3

Comparing Poe's 'Hop Frog And Tell Tale Heart'

In Poe’s “Hop Frog” and “Tell Tale Heart,” Poe develops a unique style of writing specifically in narrative point of view. He does so by giving personality and depth in narrators from both stories by using imagery, syntax, and irony. Firstly, Poe develops the third person point of view in both “Hop Frog” and “Tell Tale Heart” by using imagery to characterize the narrator. For example, in “Tell Tale Heart,” the narrator says, “Above all the sense of hearing was acute. I heard all things in the heaven…

Words 576 - Pages 3

Essay about Edgar Allen Poe and Stephan King Suspense Analysis

readers with their suspenseful narrative styles. Both of King’s short stories “The Boogeyman” and “Quitters, Inc.,” follow a similarly terrified protagonist who progressively senses an antagonistic presence. In Edgar Allen Poe’s short stories “The Tell Tale Heart” and “The Cask of Amontillado”, Poe’s menacing villains lure victims with casks of wine and startle them in the middle of the night before murdering them. While King’s simple narration creates suspense, Poe’s narrative style most enhances the…

Words 773 - Pages 4

Polarity In Beaumont's Tale

Beaumont’s tale contains a prevalent dichotomy between the masculine and feminine. The tale is “endowed with ancient archetypes with a feminine power” (Ross 60), even the title of the tale is representing two polarising binaries. In both Beaumont and Disney’s telling, the Beast is very much a hyper-masculine figure especially in comparison to the Beauty character. Focusing on Beaumont, she seems to be suggesting that these concepts “belong to an economic and ideological order” (Korneeva 247). Throughout…

Words 1763 - Pages 8

Flannery O Connor's Character Analysis

The first comparison I made between Good Country People and The Life You Save May Be Your Own by Flannery O’Conner is how the elder women in the stories, Mrs.Crater also known as Lady, Mrs. Freeman and Mrs. Hopewell, are referred to as Mrs. even though their husbands play no significant role in the stories, one has passed away, another was divorced and the other is husband is mentioned with no explanation as to why he is not in the rest of the story. Which leads me to my second comparison Character…

Words 553 - Pages 3