The Possibility Of Digital Media Rights In The Digital Age

Submitted By zukkerman
Words: 1825
Pages: 8
Open Document
Yochai Benkler and Lawrence Lessig fight to free our culture from the grip of the past; their works complement one another as both have unique perspectives on the struggle for freedom in the digital age. Benkler focuses on how the propertization of the information environment is causing a loss of personal autonomy. Lessig argues that the balance between property protected by copyright and the rights of people to build on creative work is skewed. Lessing’s book Free Culture and Benkler’s article, “Siren Songs and Amish Children: Autonomy, Information, and Law.” both speak towards providing a legislative environment that promotes and expands personal autonomy and free access to content within the digital commons. It is the legal environment surrounding the digital media revolution that is in turmoil. The quick ascendancy of the digital age has brought the limitations of current copyright law into sharp relief. New technology such as Peer to Peer file sharing (P2P) has changed how a computer literate public can access, modify, and broadcast media content to each other. The pre-Internet media distribution system is fighting back against this new distribution system and its inherent creative capital, in an effort to reassert control over the media. Corporate influence over the legislative bodies has led to a grim tide of legal victories for the current media distributors and against free access to content in a digital commons. Legislation like the Digital Media Copyright Act, and near-perpetual extensions to the Copyright Act, threaten to smother the new freedom made available by the digital media revolution. The media corporations are influencing the law heavily in favour of their desire for an absolutist, perpetual copyright scheme. The forces opposing corporate media are fragmented and scarcely heard in the mainstream. The battle they fight is not for a copyright free anarchist interpretation, but rather a compromise that establishes both a relatively lawyer-free digital commons, and a formalized copyright structure to protect the rights of the authors and people who seek to use their work.
It is the intent of this paper to show that the normative social costs of a permission based culture are too great a burden for a society that values creativity and autonomy to bear. Culture, digital or otherwise, must be made available to everyone for the culture to grow. The paper will be divided into three sections.
Section one will start with the idea of what a permission based culture is and how the digital revolution is changing the way people interact with each other. Some of the key legal issues that currently dominate the debate and structural issues of the Internet will also be discussed. Section two will discuss how autonomy, creativity and democracy are interrelated how they interact with copyright within various modes of cultural expression. Section three will put forth the idea that the digital revolution is evolutionary in nature and will propose a compromise position in which the transition to a fully realized digital age might be realized.
Understanding the quiet struggle for freedom in the digital age begins with describing where we are now and how the existing legal structures and those of the Internet affect how we interact. A permission based culture is a fully copyrighted culture: there is no fair use, no commons; every idea is owned. A perfect iteration of permission based culture would follow the flawed assumption: “if value… then right”. That is to say that if I take creative work [which possesses inherent value] and use it in any way, I must have permission to do so, since it necessarily must be someone’s property. To use it without permission is piracy. Lawrence Lessig, an advocate for a rational copyright policy, skewers this notion with the example of a composer suing Girl Scouts for singing his song around a campfire. Lessig finishes curtly with the following rejoinder: “Instead [of a
Show More

Related Documents: The Possibility Of Digital Media Rights In The Digital Age

Term Paper

Correctional Health Care Increasing Staff Motivation and Satisfaction MGMT 591: Leadership and Organizational Behavior Professor Brett Gordon December 17, 2012 The organization that will be the topic of discussion in my final project paper is Georgia Health Sciences Universities (GHSU), Georgia Correctional Healthcare (GCHC) division. GHSU is both a hospital and teaching institution based in Augusta, Georgia. GHSU was founded in 1828. Georgia Health Sciences University is home to…

Words 2285 - Pages 10

Term Paper

companies use shady accounting practices to enflate revenue or hide losses, the public can’t get an accurate picture of what they are investing in. The public demanded that something be done, so in 2002 the U.S. govt passed the Sabex-Oxly act. For my term paper I will examine some the corporate scandals that led to the creation of the act. Deragulation was lobbied for hard on wall street during the Bush Presidency. The public was lead to believe that loosing the rules on corporate practices would lead…

Words 999 - Pages 4

Term Paper

Learning activity Term Paper Test for Hidden Bias The Implicit Association Test, tests for unconscious biases. I chose this learning activity to see if I have any hidden biases. I have always believed that I was a straight shooter never putting on a facade or giving a false presentation of myself. To prepare for taking this activity, I made sure that I was in a quiet room, away from any distractions. I concentrated on each activity as they appeared on my computer screen. I chose six categories to…

Words 765 - Pages 4

Term Paper

Community Organization September 16 2013 Compare and Contrast Community Organizations The two community organizations that I choose to compare and contrast is Do-All,Inc and United Way. I have worked with both of these organizations in the past, and they are both really good organizations, and do a lot of improve the overall community. Do-All, Inc. evolved from a dream for a better life for people with disabilities. Do-All, Inc was formed in 1952 by the Bay County Association of Retarded Citizens…

Words 723 - Pages 3

term paper

Progressive Roots - In the beginning of the 1900s, America had 76 million people, mostly in good condition. Then before the first decade of the 20th century, the U.S. would be influenced by a “Progressive movement’ that fought against monopolies, corruption, inefficiency, and social injustice. 1. The purpose of the Progressives was to use the government as an agency of human welfare. - The Progressives had their roots in the Greenback Labor Party of the 1870s and 1880s and the Populist Party…

Words 2369 - Pages 10

Term Paper

Pediatric Oncology Nursing Did you know that one in one hundred new nurses will become a pediatric oncology nurse? Pediatric oncology nursing is a very demanding and heartwarming career. To be a pediatric oncology nurse means to be a primary care coordinator for the management of patients with cancer. A pediatric oncology nurse will assess patient needs, implementing a plan with appropriate tasks for the patient to gain progress. Not only will the pediatric oncology nurse help with the patient…

Words 1781 - Pages 8

Term Paper

Introduction Software as a Service (SaaS) has the potential to transform the way information-technology (IT) departments relate to and even think about their role as providers of computing services to the rest of the enterprise. The emergence of SaaS as an effective software-delivery mechanism creates an opportunity for IT departments to change their focus from deploying and supporting applications to managing the services that those applications provide. A successful service-centric IT, in turn…

Words 6880 - Pages 28

Term paper

issues that occur there are many that people may not be aware of, but the ones that will be discussed to explore ethical situations are Unauthorized Access related to software, hardware, network, internet web mining, IT freedom and hacking. This paper examines how each unauthorized access should be handled and provides examples of each related area of security. Security – Unauthorized Access Unauthorized access is known as the act of gaining access to a network, system,…

Words 3103 - Pages 13

Term Paper

The Emancipation Proclamation and the Death of an American Hero. Students Name Professor’s Name History 150 Online 10 March 2014 There were many different events that happened during the time of President Abraham Lincoln and the Civil War. President Abraham Lincoln came up with the Emancipation Proclamation which was an effort to help end slavery, eventually leading to the thirteenth amendment to abolish slavery altogether. Sadly his life was cut short. John Wilkes Booth assassinated him…

Words 1950 - Pages 8

Term Paper

he Glass Menagerie is a very character oriented poem. Tom, Amanda, and Laura are all very well developed characters. They all have significant and unique characteristics that are shown well throughout the poem. Tom is the most interesting to me though because of his qualities and even his flaws. Tom has a few different and contradicting characteristics such as he is easily persuaded, his determination and his strong sense of guilt. Tom Wingfield seems to be easily entrapped and persuaded into…

Words 348 - Pages 2