The Border Fence Essay

Words: 1339
Pages: 6
Open Document
Brian Wagner
Eng-1102-115
Essay #1- The Border Fence
9/16/13

In the essay “The Fence of Lies” the author Mario Vargas Llosa’s thesis is that the border fence between Mexico and the United States is a bad idea and a waste of taxpayer’s money. Some of the main points he uses to strengthen his argument are that it is purely a political ploy to get officials re-elected, that the fence is far too costly and the construction will never happen, and the money should be spent elsewhere. In addition, we should allow immigrants an open door policy into our country because of the immense contribution they make to our economy and that they are willing to do the jobs that most Americans will not. Vargas Llosa’s most compelling argument is that …show more content…
Where do we even begin to help and is it really our problem? Why should the taxpayers of the America be responsible for an undertaking of that size and is it even possible? I think these are reasonable questions to ask oneself and if looked at logically will find this a ridiculous proposal that has no validity.
Another argument Vargas Llosa made, that “if, by some miracle, it is built, it will serve for absolutely nothing” (1). He also says in the conclusion of his essay that the “cement monstrosity would soon be as full of holes as Swiss cheese” (11) saying that the fence would not even obstruct migrants determined to get across. He makes a point of saying that the fence would only cover a portion of the border, leaving 1200 miles of open frontier through which people could easily pass over. Well, that is true, however, in those areas where there is not any fence, there are natural obstacles such as large, desolate stretches of desert or mountains with no cities close by to take refuge. All of the major ports of entry are included in the fenced area, which provides at least a moderate obstacle when it comes to illegal crossing. As for the damaging alterations that will happen over time, such as, holes cut into it, sensors could be added in the ground and or in the fence, plus routine patrols done for visual inspection. To say that the fence would do
Show More

Related Documents: The Border Fence Essay

Border Fence Case Study

A border fence would wreak havoc on the jaguar population. The implementing of a border fence would result in a decrease of the jaguar population. This is due to the jaguars being cut off from a source of food because of the newly implemented border fence; the area in which the jaguars obtain their food needed for survival is fenced off. In other words, the jaguars are prevented from getting proper nutrition, which inevitably leads to their deaths and population decrease. Also, the border fence blocks…

Words 307 - Pages 2

Border Fence - Article Analysys Essay

Article Analysis Border Fence Many Americans believe the Southwest Border fence is not effective. More than 49 billion dollars of tax payer money has been dedicated towards building the fence. The border fence has impacted many property owners in Texas, the environment, Indian reservations and American’s pockets. There have many articles written about the border fence and many provide great information that contain statistics and opinions on those who favor or oppose the border fence. Randal C.…

Words 1521 - Pages 7

Why Are We Being Forced To Pay Something That Doesn T Work?

Jasmine English 1301 9/29/13 Why are we being forced to pay something that doesn’t work? Billions of our tax dollars are spent on a wall dividing the U.S and México border going from San Diego, California to Brownsville, Texas. Which is supposed to prevent immigrants crossing over to United States illegally, but that isn’t stopping them from doing so. There must be another way to prevent immigrants from crossing over illegally rather than making us pay for a wall that isn’t helping at all.…

Words 1023 - Pages 5

Fencing Out Foreigners

come over. I believe the best and most effective way to stop immigration would be to seal up the border, by building a fence between America and Mexico. If you think about how many miles the boarder covers, a fence is a big undertaking and a very large expense. It’s not practical to watch every foot of the fence 24 hours a day. However, monitoring equipment could be provided along with the fence to detect when someone attempts to scale it. Also, the shear height of it may act as a warning, given…

Words 587 - Pages 3

Secure Fence Research Paper

The Secure Fence Act of 2006 was enacted October 26, 2006 and is a part of President George W. Bush's effort on immigration reform which was intended to allow the Department of Homeland Security to gain operational control over the entire United States-Mexico border and maritime border. It will have 700 miles of double-layer fencing , about 1,989 km long. This fence includes 18-foot steel fencing, high-tech surveillance, unmanned aerial vehicles, increased prosecutions of illegal border crossers and…

Words 1000 - Pages 4

Border Wars Final Draft Essay

beginning of the United States. Border security is at the tip of this argument. Many people believe that TSA and Border Patrol have gone too far with laws and regulations that they have set up and that they are stomping on both the rights of individuals as well as the rights for the United States economy to improve itself due to these laws and regulations that have been established over time. The opposition has these and other major aspects to argue into why tightened border security is necessary for the…

Words 3197 - Pages 13

Immigration Policy

An immigration policy is any policy of a state that agree about the transit of individual across its border into the country, especially those individual expect to work and stay in the country. Immigration policy can choice from allowing no migration at all to allowing most types of migration, this type is call free immigration system. Immigrant is a person who have has a citizenship in one country and enters a different country to establish a permanent residence. However, there are two types of…

Words 1826 - Pages 8

Immigration Policy: Two Types Of Immigrants

An immigration policy is any policy of a state that agree about the transit of individual across its border into the country, especially those individuals expect to work and stay in the country. Immigration policy can choose from allowing no migration at all to allowing most types of migration, this type is called free immigration system. Immigrant is a person who has a citizenship in one country and enters a different country to establish a permanent residence. However, there are two types of immigrant…

Words 1829 - Pages 8

Essay On Border Wall

it in the end. We should build a border wall between Mexico and the United States because fences make good neighbors, protection purposes, and the need to take control. First of all, we should build a border wall because fences make good neighbors. Our border needs to be blocked with this wall. A wall will allow our country to become stronger and not have to worry about illegal immigrants seeking entry into our country without our authority. “The proof that border walls are effective deterrents against…

Words 762 - Pages 4

Essay on Synth: Immigration to the United States

Kyle Seager Dr. Restivo AP English Language and Composition 13 October 2014 Tear Down This Wall How does a country go from "Tear down this wall!" to "Build a fence to keep out all immigrants." An integral issue in today's American politics is whether or not to fence the southern border of the United States and close it to immigration. States such as Arizona have taken action regarding this issue: Arizona passed a bill stating that anyone suspected of being an immigrant must carry their documentation…

Words 2015 - Pages 9