The Boston Tea Party: An Analysis

Words: 780
Pages: 4
Open Document
Freedom. The principle that individuals have a right to make their own choices, so long as they do not interfere with the equal rights of others (Dorn, The Scope of Government in a Free Society). It is this ideal that forms the foundation of free societies around the world.

The framers of the U.S. Constitution sought to create their own free society by stating that it was “self-evident that all men are created equal” possessing “unalienable rights.” The existence of freedom however, is not inextricably linked to the existence of government. Since maintaining liberty is more important than preserving an unjust governmental structure, civil disobedience can become an invaluable tool. Peaceful resistance to laws positively impacts …show more content…
the Sons of Liberty threw 342 chests of British tea into Boston harbor. This act of resistance to the British Tea Tax, imposed on colonists without their consent or representation, is one integral to American history. The Boston Tea Party helped spark the American revolution, putting the 13 colonies on their path to independence.

Detractors of civil disobedience painted the Boston Tea party as beneath civility, even if they did agree with its innate principles. In his book, Defiance of the Patriots, historian Benjamin Carp writes that there “was a sense of shame, a belief that the Boston Tea Party was an act of hooliganism.” Ostensibly, the Boston Tea Party may appear to be a senseless act of destruction. In actuality, this act of civil disobedience became a preserver of …show more content…
Still, in 1991 apartheid was abolished – in large part due to this resistance, which helped transform South Africa’s moral conscience. When a government systematically discriminates against its citizens, civil disobedience is required to force a reassessment of society’s moral parameters.

Henry Thoreau supports this sentiment in his essay “On the Duty of Civil Disobedience.” He wrote, “I think that we should be men first, and subjects afterward. It is not desirable to cultivate a respect for the law, so much as for the right.” When law and justice do not coincide, obeying the law can be an abdication of ethical responsibility. A government or a national law cannot always define principles of right and wrong. It is up to each and every individual to recognize his own morality and live accordingly.

Peaceful resistance is often one of the most effective means of protecting the freedom which seems implicit in a free society, either by justifying the righteousness of a new government, or transforming the moral standards of a present regime. In modern times, society lacks the 20/20 vision of hindsight; thus, is difficult to perceive whether civil disobedience, from violating an immigration ban to Keystone XL pipeline protests are truly in defense of a revolutionary moral good. More importantly however, the right to such civil disobedience changes society
Show More

Related Documents: The Boston Tea Party: An Analysis

Analysis: The Boston Tea Party

In the dead of night, colonists creeped over to the British ships and threw over forty-five tons of tea into the Boston Harbor on a chilly December night in 1776. The American colonists are not justified in this extreme rebellion mishap because of the aftermath. The Boston Tea Party caused a great financial loss for the British, local business’ and property were demolished, and many laws were broken that night. The colonists were not justified for their actions because it made the British lose…

Words 659 - Pages 3

Boston Tea Party Analysis

The resulting response was the Boston Tea Party, which can be seen as an example of the Crown not sufficiently controlling the governed. This, in turn, led to an exaggerated response by Parliament that only served to antagonize and unite revolutionary New England with the rest of America against the perceived tyranny of the Crown, yet another instance of the government failing to control itself. The Tea Act in 1773 lowered the price of tea by removing duties on tea imported by the East India Company…

Words 1450 - Pages 6

Boston Tea Party Analysis

On Dec. 16, 1773, "radicals" from Boston, members of a secret organization of American Patriots called The Sons of Liberty Freedom, boarded three East India Company ships and we threw 342 chests of tea into the water. The coat of the amount of tea we threw into the water was valued at $18,000. Resistance to the Crown had been growing larger over enforcement of the 1764 Sugar Act, 1765 Stamp Act and 1767 Townshend Act, which led to the Boston Massacre and gave rise to the slogan, “No taxation without…

Words 283 - Pages 2

The Boston Tea Party Analysis

that's what he was trying to change. Now for a matter that everyone knows of, The Boston Tea Party. Everyone knows the story, the Americans were being censored by the British government and this was an act to try to get revenge for the Americans(History). They went against society, and we talk about it like that is not a big issue, but this also isn’t a big issue and we are making it one. Looking at the Boston Tea Party from another angel you could say that the evidence also works. They attempted…

Words 923 - Pages 4

Analysis Of A Boston Shoemaker Recalls: The Boston Tea Party

From the document “A Boston Shoemaker Recalls British Arrogance and the Boston Tea Party” from the book, Reading the American Past, it recalls a serious time that sparked in the 1700s.The narrator, whom the story happened to recalls the situation starting by bringing up how he had small encounter with a boy named Malcolm who seemed be easily tempered. It all started by Malcolm hitting the narrator in his skull then fleeing away. George, the narrator, it is known that he was a Boston shoemaker. George’s…

Words 383 - Pages 2

Boston Massacre, Boston Tea Party, And The Battle Of Bunker Hill

The colonists were restricted from political freedoms by the king. The British government caused the rebellion by trying to tax the colonists in ways that had not previously been done. The unprotection of the colonists was lead by the Boston Massacre, Boston Tea Party, and the Battle of Bunker Hill. The colonists were justified in wanting independence with England for three reasons: failure to protect political freedoms, economic wellbeings, and safety for the colonists. Between 1763 and 1775, the…

Words 569 - Pages 3

American Revolution and College Board Essay

Great Britain and the British colonies. • Develops the thesis with substantial and relevant historical information about the effect of the war and its aftermath on the relationship between Britain and the British colonies. • Provides effective analysis of the aftermath of the war and its effect on the British/colonial relationship; treatment of the aftermath’s effect on the relationship may be somewhat uneven. • May contain minor errors that do not detract from the quality of the answer. • Is…

Words 1599 - Pages 7

Shadracham Jail Rhetorical Analysis Essay

God-given ability to learn due to the "wrongdoing" of civil disobedience. Finally, King's allusion to the Boston Tea Party shows irrefutable evidence supporting his claim. The Boston Tea Party is a major event in the United States history, being a massive act of civil disobedience that is in fact celebrated due to its contribution in leading to the American Revolution. By The Boston Tea Party being a major advocate for freedom, this adds to his claim through his reasoning of freedom needing to have…

Words 943 - Pages 4

American Revolution and Sheila Skemp Essay

SHAPING AMERICA FINAL SCRIPT TITLE: WRITER: PRODUCER: DRAFT: DATE: Lesson 7: “Making a Revolution” Gretchen Dyer Julia Dyer Final 6 February, 2001 Lesson 7 “Making a Revolution” • VISUAL Final Script • 1 AUDIO 1 UNIT OPENING 2 3 1. VIVID MONTAGE of images of violent protest--e.g.: 1) riots in bread lines during the Depression; 2) the Cultural Revolution in China; 4) the student anti-war demonstrations of the 1960s; 5) MLK’s March on Washington;…

Words 5257 - Pages 22

Visual Rhetoric

“You Need to Calm Down” Video Analysis Visual rhetoric is one of the most impactful ways to tell an important story. Through images, colors, sounds, and people, this rhetorical strategy effectively orates the deeper meaning that exists without the use of words. Visual rhetoric can be used in all sorts of media, such as movies and shows, but in this particular case, the topic of study is music video. The music video up for analysis is Taylor Swift’s “You Need to Calm Down”. The overarching style of…

Words 1182 - Pages 5