The Giver Movie And Book Comparison Essay

Words: 1095
Pages: 5
Open Document
Throughout the novel and the movie versions of The Giver, there are some very recognizable differences in the plot. There are usually differences in film adaptations of books because of certain things that would be boring or hard to describe without having a constant narration. For example, it would have been boring to the viewer if all of the ceremonies were included before the ceremony of graduation. Often film directors cut out parts like that to make the events throughout the movie more interesting and action packed. Sometimes events or other features are cut because of the budget for the film, as it is a lot harder to get amazing props and show them than describe amazing things in writing. Some plot changes though, were pretty big and didn’t make much sense with the rest …show more content…
Not only that, but the fact that Fiona seems to be one of the main characters, while in the book Fiona is only one of Jonas’s friends from his childhood. Film scriptwriters tend to do this a lot with film adaptations of books; add an insane amount of romance and love stories to a story that really has nothing to do with romance, but that is simply because that is the kind of content that the public enjoy. Jonas, rather than enduring his emotions with only the Giver like in the book, convinces Fiona to stop taking her injections as well so she can feel emotions for him. Through this, she has a similar experience to that of Jonas, because she feels conflicted with the society because she can now feel real emotions. As I have said, the scriptwriters have done this because they want to cram in as much drama and conflict into one story that it almost becomes confusing. This is why many people say that the film adaption of the Giver is not a good movie: the writers just try too hard to make an already great story more interesting. It seems as if they brainstormed on new ideas but ended up including all of them in the final
Show More

Related Documents: The Giver Movie And Book Comparison Essay

The Giver Movie And Book Comparison Essay

The Giver, by Lois Lowry is an adventurous book about a young boy named Jonas. Jonas lives in a utopia where everyone and everything is the same, but Jonas is different. The movie, The Giver, is a movie based off of the book. The book and the movie are different in many ways. First, is the difference of the injections versus the pills. Second, are the assignments. Last, is the difference of the eyes from the book, and the birthmarks in the movie. The Giver Movie and Book are very different but tell…

Words 612 - Pages 3