The Myth Of Tax Cuts

Submitted By HWAN UG-JUNG
Words: 1068
Pages: 5
Open Document
28 September 2012
The Myth of Tax Cuts The biggest event in this year would be the 2012 Presidential Election on November 6. There are two major parties in the United States: Republican and Democratic. Mitt Romney and Paul Ryan are the Republican Presidential and Vice Presidential nominees, respectively. On the Democratic side, incumbent President Barak Obama and Vice President Joe Biden are seeking reelection. Perhaps the biggest issue is the economy. The two candidates have very different plans on how to fix the stagnant economy.
One contentious part of the economic recovery plans is taxes. How can taxes best be used to improve economic conditions? Can they be used at all to fix the economy? Obama favors taxing the rich more and giving tax breaks to the struggling middle class. On the other hand, Romney favors giving tax breaks to the wealthy, specifically corporate investors and executives. The right believes that these people are the “job creators” and that by cutting their taxes, they will be able to create more jobs which will in turn revitalize the economy. I disagree with this notion because statistics show that, historically, tax cuts for the wealthy do not spur economic growth. In fact, they increase economic inequality among the rich and the rest of society. As the old saying goes, “The rich get richer and the poor get poorer.” Moreover, tax cuts, in and of themselves, do not have a significant impact on the economy at all. My thesis is that tax cuts as a way to fix the economy is a public misconception, largely a myth.
In his campaign, Mitt Romney says that he would cut taxes like income taxes and marginal taxes. In general, most people like tax cuts because they think it is a way they can save money. Some people think that these tax cuts will free up citizens’ disposable income and then encourage citizens to spend this money on goods and services. The influx of disposable income as a result of tax cuts will improve the health of the economy. But this may be a misconception. There is no statistical evidence to support this claim. According to Henry Blodget, tax cuts do not spur a country’s economic growth. Yet the public and politicians continue to buy into this theory. As Blodget points out, referring to Mitt Romney, “One of our two Presidential candidates is so convinced of the theory that he has built his entire economic plan around it” (Blodget). Blodget goes on to show that from 1945 to the present, the average tax rates have declined for the highest-income taxpayers. The rich people pay fewer taxes and as a result, this creates more income inequality, widening the gap between rich and poor. “One thing tax cuts do unequivocally do – at least tax cuts for the highest earners – is increase economic inequality” (Blodget).
In contrast to Mitt Romney, Barack Obama plans to extend health care services to everyone, regardless of their income level. He also plans to create jobs and invest in construction. One of his campaign’s main objectives it to level the economic playing field. He will do this by giving tax breaks to the middle class. Those hit hardest by the economic recession are the middle class. Therefore, it doesn’t make sense to tax them higher because this will only hurt them further. Why would you tax those hit hardest in order to improve the economy? The middle class makes up the majority of the country, so to give them tax breaks makes more sense because, from a utilitarian perspective, this will benefit the most people, not just the richest. Obama believes that the economy will improve from “the bottom up,” not from the “top to the bottom.” This may be a better approach than Romney’s, but, as we will see, it is not grounded in any kind of evidence.
The graphs below illustrate the misconception that tax cuts lead to economic growth. New theories suggest that tax cuts don’t actually help the economy improve from a recession. If you look at the graph, in 1990, the first President Bush
Show More

Related Documents: The Myth Of Tax Cuts

Essay about Barack Obama and American Economy

our already wounded economy. What can be done to help the American economy and which political party has the answer? Larry Elder’s “The Four Lies About the Economy That Obama Needs Voters to Believe”, Steve Chapman’s “Myth of Unfair Paychecks”, and Malcolm Berko’s “Bush Tax Cuts and the Economy” provide three different issues that are upon the congressional floor in Washington that will effect our economy negatively one way or another. In Elder’s “The Four Lies About the Economy that Obama Needs…

Words 971 - Pages 4

Is College Tuition Too High

salary with families in the current salary. He also uses a comparison and contrast effect on the different countries and their percentage’s on. Davidson develops his thesis by using graphs and giving statistics on. The overall thesis is that if we cut out tuition then that would…

Words 223 - Pages 1

science beyond Essay

the emergence of New Frontier Idealism Cuba – Bay of Pigs and the Missile Crisis – Change of Heart on policy Vietnam – Early buildup – Advisors – He also understood guerilla war Assassination and the myth of Camelot Lyndon Johnson Politician v. Statesman Social Programs - '64 Tax Cuts Mass Transit funding War against Poverty Civil Rights Act Social Programs –‘65 Medicare/Medicaid Education Act Manpower Training Housing Act War on Poverty – increased HEH/HEA…

Words 560 - Pages 3

The Contributions of Reagan Era Policies to the Recession of 2007 Essay

class, specifically – and allowing the wealth to spread throughout the economic system. This, in fact, is wholly inaccurate. The Tax Equity and Fiscal Responsibility Act of 1982 was the single largest tax increase in peacetime American history. Total tax increases throughout Reagan’s regime through bills he championed are $132.7 billion. Reagan was not only a frequent tax augmenter, but a serial spender and interventionist, which is contrary to contemporary conservative beliefs and the idea that Reagan…

Words 2307 - Pages 10

Class cleavages Essay

Discussion Paper 1 How relevant do you think class & urban-rural divides will be in the future? In the context of Canadian society, both class and urban-rural cleavages will be subdued going forward. Firstly, the Canadian social and economic backdrop is grounded on compassion and prosperity (Brooks, 2012). On the economic front, Canada over the last decade has seen unemployment fluctuate between 6 to 9 percent. Using unemployment as a leading indicator for deep class stratification and perpetuated…

Words 1191 - Pages 5

Segregation In The 1950's

“…St. Louis residents who called it home,” were middle class members (The Pruitt-Igoe Myth: An Urban History). Pruitt-Igoe was planned to have capacity for the growth of a manufacturing powerhouse city, which was already in a shade of its past. The project was a Modernist dream come true. It was an effort to replace St. Louis’ slums with…

Words 1373 - Pages 6

Health Insurance Essay

medicine. Authorities also said medical practices should be structured and that they will be paid. Government will mandate exactly what health insurance with what benefits the workers and the employees that they will have to pay for. The act imposes tax penalties on them if they decide not to comply with the new law. Authorities has dictated insurance companies with exactly health insurance that they must sell. Through the government control and there compulsion over time primarily through bureaucratic…

Words 1920 - Pages 8

History: Great Economic Prosperity Essay

slavery in 1865, a sinister group was established which was designed to spread fear throughout the Black population that still lived in the southern states. This was the KKK. Only WASP’s could belong to it — WhiteAnglo-Saxon Protestants. It is a common myth that the KKK targeted only the Blacks - also hated were the Jews, Catholics, liberals etc but most hatred was directed against the poor black families in the south who were very vulnerable to attack. A meeting of the KKK in 1922 The leader of…

Words 1893 - Pages 8

The Nature Of Poverty

poor for their state of impoverishment, attributing their poverty to irresponsibility and an absence of work ethic. The evidence contradicts such a mindset. Time and time again, studies have found that the jobless welfare queen is largely a figure of myth, a straw man constructed by GOP ideologues to bear the brunt of their intolerance. Most of the able-bodied poor do work, and those who come off of welfare and get a job often find that their wages are not sufficient to secure a livelihood. Those…

Words 932 - Pages 4

Penny Argumentative Essay

drain on the economy over the last several years. The opposition of the removal of the penny is on baseless arguments. The penny has needs to be retired because of it has no buying power, the high production cost wastes millions and causes a burden on tax payers, others have done it with positive results, the prices post-penny and rounding policy benefit consumers, and charities will not suffer. Today's penny have next to no buying power. The purpose…

Words 1312 - Pages 6