In the minimalist short story, the passive unlikeable narrator’s unexpected connection with a blind man named Robert pushes him to undergo a mystical transformation. A slightly similar mystical transformation earned from human connection is explored in Herman Melville’s 1853 short story “Bartleby: The Scrivener.” After the lawyer’s unexpected encounter with Bartleby, his perspective changes. The lawyer, like the narrator from “Cathedral,” undergoes a mystical transformation. After encountering Bartleby, he is enlightened. By characterizing the narrator as an unlikeable, passive protagonist incapable of connecting, and by exposing the mystical transformations the narrator and the lawyer (in “Bartleby: The Scrivener”) underwent after their profound human connections, this essay seeks to prove how impactful and important—unexpected—human connections are to one’s character development. Furthermore, this essay underscores the notion that profound human connections can occur unexpectedly and from unexpected sources, as seen in the narrator’s quiet epiphany during his connection with Robert. The narrator is no longer the same passive, unlikeable protagonist; he has