The Other Slavery Analysis

Words: 1255
Pages: 6
Open Document
Dr. Resendez acknowledges current trends placing power in the hands of natives in regards to their relationships with Europeans. At the same time, he argues these attempts fail to recognize European adaptions to Native control. Resendez only retreats from the argument, Europeans controlled almost all aspects of their relationship with indigenous people, when for the first time in the monographs covered in this essay, the notion of Natives mass enslaving non-indigenous people is introduced. Despite this slight deviation, from the first page through the last he chronicles abuses suffered by natives over centuries as a result of their interactions with Europeans. In the final analysis, The Other Slavery is an example of good history and how …show more content…
Newell explains the reasons behind, execution of, and ramifications of King Philip’s War. She wrote, “King Philp’s War, 1675-76, represented a watershed in Indian-English relations and the Native American experience on many fronts.” Ultimately, pressures placed on Native societies by British expansion created resentment. Furthermore, British demand for ever increasing numbers of forced laborers along with diminished power by once dominate Native groups exploded in violent conflict. This struggle for power is what differentiates Dr. Newell’s book from others covered in this paper. In the other monographs, there was clear intent to place power with one group over the other. While each details conflict as a result of that fight, Dr. Newell not only writes on that struggle but makes it central to her …show more content…
For the most part, all add to the conversation, although each is also flawed. Namely, all of the books are guided by bias of their writer. Good history is about discovering evidence, writing about those findings, and letting the facts lead to conclusions. Bad history is starting to write from a certain perspective and using evidence to support preconceived beliefs. When scholars write good history, it resonates and comes through the pages like sun through the clouds. Dr. Christina Snyder, professor of history at Indiana University, is such a scholar. Namely, she breaths a breath of fresh air into the historiography of indigenous slavery and the struggle over power in her book, Slavery in Indian Country: The Changing Face of Captivity in Early America. From the beginning, she separates herself from others historians who have written on the topic when she wrote,” the standard historical narrative tells is that bondage was an American aberration. Restricted in time and space,”. Compared to the other monographs covered in this essay, she does not try and place power in one groups hands over
Show More

Related Documents: The Other Slavery Analysis

Rhetorical Analysis Of Blood And Slavery

A Rhetorical Analysis of a free negro’s “Blood and Slavery” At the outset of his speech the free negro insists he has the authority to talk about the malevolent force of slavery by describing himself as, “that unfortunate race of men who are distinguished from the rest of the human species by a black skin and woolly hair,” implying that his life has been trampled upon by society’s perception of blacks as inferior and that he was previously impressed into the wicked practice of slavery. He then proceeds…

Words 306 - Pages 2

Declaration Of Sentiments Analysis

society. As a feminist, Stanton eliminated “obey” from her marriage vows, as well as kept her maiden name. The concept of the convention was first formed when Stanton and Mott met in 1840 at the World Anti-Slavery Convention in London (“An Analysis of”). During the convention, Stanton, Mott, and other women were not allowed to sit because of their gender. This offended feminists Stanton and Mott, and they “discussed the possibility of women’s rights convention.” Stanton was the one who drafted and presented…

Words 537 - Pages 3

Why Did The North Win The Civil War Essay

constitution in the year 1789. The main differences were in putting an end to slavery and the states’ rights. The enactment of the thirteenth, fourteenth, and fifteenth amendments and the South losing the war, the significant effects of the war entailed putting an end to slavery in the United States and the redefinition of America as a united country instead of a collection of states which act independently. The analysis puts into perspective why the North won the civil war and be successful in obtaining…

Words 558 - Pages 3

Rhetorical Analysis Of Chatgpt's 'Mac' Marquis Teaching Assistant

The abolition movement was a significant historical movement dedicated to ending slavery in the 19th century and this essay is an analysis of ChatGPT's essay on this same subject. First of all, the thesis statement of ChatGPT’s essay is not incorrect, but it becomes kind of repetitive and loses clarity at points. Essentially, the essay asserts that the abolition movement aimed to end slavery and affected socially and economically the nation during that time. However, there's no need to…

Words 1451 - Pages 6

Final Essay

her essay, Slavery, Race and Ideology in the United States, “those holding liberty to be inalienable and holding Afro-Americans as slaves were bound to end by holding race to be a self-evident truth” (Fields, 101). In a short, both statements examine how the development of whiteness become the explanation for the domination of other groups and the continued avarice of trying to justify superiority and the existence of entitlement to economic, political and social rights. In her analysis of whiteness…

Words 2191 - Pages 9

Summary Of The Life Of Clara Brown

circumstances. The chapter explores the life of Clara Brown, a former slave that migrated to Colorado, in hopes of a better future and reunion with her daughter. The chapter covers her life from birth into a slavery, marriage, loss of her family at the slave podiums, the abolishment of slavery , expansion in the west, and reunion with her daughter. It provides a broad outlook of her life supported with specific details as well as background information about the time and obstacles a black woman had…

Words 512 - Pages 3

The Abolitionist Movement: US War On Slavery

Bao-Khang Ngo HIST 1301 T/Thu 8:00AM- 9:30AM U.S Abolitionist Movement U.S War on Slavery The abolitionist movement had its roots in Great Britain during the American Revolution and gradually evolved into a more radical form of reform that drastically divided the nation as no other issue did before. The prime basis of the abolitionist movement started with no other than the Atlantic Slave Trade where slaves were tormented and brutally mistreated on the ships by the crews. Upon reaching the colonies…

Words 684 - Pages 3

Covey And Douglass

dehumanizing oppression. "My Bondage and My Freedom" presents a more reflective account, focusing on the psychological dynamics and Douglass's resistance. Both narratives highlight Douglass's resilience and determination, exposing the horrors of slavery and asserting his agency and humanity. Comparing the language, tone, and emphasis provides deeper insights into his quest for freedom…

Words 1416 - Pages 6

Native American Slavery System

Throughout history, slavery has been the controversial social expression of the human desire for control and superiority. This notion set the base for monolithic slavery systems which are designed around the needs, beliefs and tradition of the culture that develops them. In particular, Native American systems of slavery represent the development from that design, how it integrates itself in the society, and also how it adapts to the social changes that surrounds them, in this case, the contact with…

Words 969 - Pages 4

Early American History Research Paper

Understanding America's early history and the long-lasting social, economic, and political legacy it has left behind requires an understanding of both slavery and colonialism in the country. The late 15th century saw European exploration and colonisation of the Americas, with countries such as Spain, England, France, and the Netherlands founding colonies for the purpose of territorial expansion and economic exploitation. This marked the beginning of colonialism. During this time, indigenous peoples…

Words 1540 - Pages 7