The Painted Bird Analysis

Words: 2175
Pages: 9
Open Document
Kosinski, Freud, Marx and Mill all hold divergent opinions regarding human behavior, the state of human self and the role of society over its citizens. Freud and Kosinski share perhaps the most outwardly negative views of people, likening them to barbarians whose natural state without civilization is very violent and visceral. In The Painted Bird, Kosinski explicitly depicts the brutality of human nature through the horrid events that the protagonist witnesses in the rural villages, as well as the Nazi’s treatment of the Jews during the World War II era. According to Kosinski, there are clearly no illusions that can disguise the ugliness that is humankind (Kosinski, 1976). Although Freud’s view of humans and civilization is not as dire …show more content…
What further sets him apart from Marx is that he explains the utmost importance that liberty has on society, but Mill makes it more applicable and therefore more palpable by clearly citing the limitations that the state and individuals must set to prevent harm. Mill discusses several types of liberties, such as the liberty of speech and the liberty of individuality, and regards them as being crucial to society and even states that “no society in which these liberties are not, on the whole, respected, is free, whatever may be its form of government” (Mill, 2002, p. 10). Specifically, he believes that the liberty of speech is important because silencing an individual, regardless of how shocking their claims, does not provide the greatest benefit for society at large. This is because if the individual is silenced and he or she is correct, then society loses the truth and if the individual is incorrect, then society gains a “clearer and livelier impression of the truth” (Mill, 2002, p. 14). He then goes on to explain how allowing free discussion within a society is very beneficial as it encourages discussion and discourages persecution, in addition to the fact that nobody is infallible and therefore anyone has the chance of being incorrect (Mill, 2002, p. 18-20). Finally, Mill believes that another major reason in support of liberty of …show more content…
Human nature, which is primarily focused on self-preservation, contradicts the key principles of the Marxist theory of communist revolution, which proposes the end of private property and the state, in addition to equality for all. The improbable implementation of the Marxist theory of communist revolution is evidenced in recent human history, as political states that have tried to apply Marxist theory have never been able to totally adhere to its unrealistic ideals. In stark comparison, Mill’s theories on speech and non-conformity are designed to promote self-expression and individuality and an open public forum for the discussion of diverse opinions. Mill’s philosophy is a balanced one that allows people the unique opportunity to be creative in their daily lives, in a purposeful way that is properly aligned with human nature. Mill properly focuses on promoting liberties because these important rights are absolutely vital in order live in a free and open society, while keeping human nature in check by clearly enumerating a list of instances in which limitations on liberties are necessary. Accordingly, Mill’s philosophy is particularly significant because it
Show More

Related Documents: The Painted Bird Analysis

Breaking Through the Boundaries: the Ultimate Love Story Essay

equals eternal love and happiness. Gerard, as well as other neo- classical painters, painted his figures in the way painters of the Roman and Greek eras would paint in a classically pure fashion. Using crisp and defined lines Gerard outlines the two centered figures without creating ambiguity or mystery. Lighting is used to emphasize Cupid and Psyche’s angelic and mythical qualities. Their skin is painted so delicately it’s almost as if you can touch the softness of their skin at every curve…

Words 1308 - Pages 6

Research Paper About 1660 Rembrandt' Self Portrait

Commentators have discovered through x-ray examination of his self-portraits that Rembrandt sometimes painted himself in such white caps only to replace them later with darker ones (like in this case), such as colored turbans. As the light leaves the hat, it reflects next most brightly on the highest spots of Rembrandt’s forehead, the only other place in…

Words 1964 - Pages 8

Game Market Analysis Essay

European art, while astonishing to look at, is deeper than its surface, and with an educated eye can be viewed as an artifact that physically represents the history of a specific time period. Through different mediums of expression artists are able to bring the past into the present and reveal different truths determined by the observer that broaden present day knowledge about life thousands of years ago. These works of art are rightfully put on display so that a wide audience can interpret it for…

Words 1120 - Pages 5

Stark N3 Essay1

Daniel Stark Prof. Douglas Rigby English 106 N3 Essay #1 02/23/15 A Martian Sends a Postcard Home Analysis In life, we as humans tend to lean to the normal and the usual. We do things and perceive things in a way which is similar to a habit. By choosing to look at things differently is the first step in breaking that which is routine. In the poem, “A Martian Sends a Postcard Home,” we look at things that, to the average human, are normal or typical but we look at them in a different light. We look…

Words 2729 - Pages 11

Suite Popular Crew Analysis

l and Biographical Context: The Suite Popular Brasileiro was very telling of Billa-Lobos unique historical background and influences. This music clings closely to the devices Villa-Lobos learned at conservatory and mixes well with his unique compositional language. The influence of the French salon music is evident I this music as well as his Brazilian background. These two musical resources are deeply rooted together in said piece . The historical development that brought about the influence of…

Words 1397 - Pages 6

Ad Analysis Essay

Laura Throneberry Writ 101 October 4, 2014 Professor Joe Ad Analysis Ever since the turn of the 21st century, marketing has played a vital role on consumerism in the growing global economy. The various conventional marketing tools include advertising, branding, direct marketing, sales promotion, publicity and public relations. Advertising has become such an inextricable part of every human’s life. Greenpeace, the largest independent direct-action environmental organization in the world, has taken…

Words 1224 - Pages 5

Color Red In The Good Earth

The color red affects traditions in many ways. It is not just the basic red traffic light, which stops daily traffic, but it can be seen in many contexts, like clothing, sports, electronics, and etc. Thus, this is just a regular color that people see in their lives, but it also has a very symbolic meaning to it. This color is usually related to hatred or danger, however on Valentine’s day it symbolizes love. On February 14th of each year, this color is seen in gifts by men and women, or in the decorative…

Words 1832 - Pages 8

True Detective Media Analysis

True Detective Media Analysis True Detective is an all American crime series drama produced by Nic Pizzolatto. Season one stars two Vermilion Parish, Louisiana State Police Detectives, Matthew McConaughey as Rust Cohle and Woody Harrelson as Marty Hart. Masculinity is a leading theme the first season of True Detective. The show objectifies women, portraying female characters only as objects to be rescued or as trouble for the men. True Detective reels the audience into the world of criminal justice…

Words 1444 - Pages 6

Human and Neandertal Essay

archaeological theories are often based on individual interpretation of subjective data, Neandertals were a considerably more socially advanced and intelligent species than previously suspected. Given that Neandertals have exhibited, through the analysis of fossils, artifacts, and bio-molecular research, identifiably humanistic behavior. I, myself, was accustomed to the erroneous assertion that the Neandertal was a brutish, socially inferior and culturally inept species. The people who inhabited…

Words 1655 - Pages 7

A Guide To The Foundation Of The World

“Who is this that obscures my plans with words without knowledge. Brace yourself like a man; I will question you, and you shall answer me. “Where were you when I laid the earth’s foundation? Tell me, if you understand. Who marked off its dimensions? Surely you know. Who stretched a measuring line across it? On what were its footings set, or who laid its cornerstone—while the morning stars sang together and all the angels[a] shouted for joy? “Who shut up the sea behind doors when it burst forth from…

Words 3777 - Pages 16