The Rhode Islanders were poor white men that because of their lack of property were not allowed to vote until the 1830’s. While, wealthy black Philadelphians lost a right they had had for over 40 years when race overpowered class in society. These groups differ in both class and race, but both parties address the fact that voting is a right that all citizens should claim. This is shown when the Rhode Island protesters argue that the government is supposed to protect and offer rights, not restrict some citizens from them. They see this restriction as a contradiction to the republican principles the country was based on. A similar sentiment is seen with black Philadelphians, like Robert Purvis who believe that it is their birthright to vote as