Essay about The truth, or not the truth. That is the question

Submitted By kyung93
Words: 1566
Pages: 7
Open Document
The Truth, or Not the Truth. That is the Question

Christopher Nolan’s film Momento and William Shakespeare’s play Hamlet are two very different works of fiction. At first glance one would never suspect the possibility of these two works of art sharing a connection. However, on the contrary, the similarity between obstacles, motives and note-taking in both works constitute the common underlining theme; truth, more specifically people's perception of the truth, consists of many layers of possible outcomes.
The central characters of Shakespeare’s Hamlet and Nolan’s film Momento are consumed by the false assumption that satisfaction will be achieved through seeking revenge. This results in the destruction and tragic downfall of both protagonists caused by this motive. Hamlet is a revenge story that is based around a protagonist that is passionate about finding justice through the death of his uncle. It is evident that upon hearing the ghost’s confession in his murder, Hamlet is overcome with compassion, and without question immediately pledges his efforts in avenging his father. This is apparent after Hamlet is asked to remember his father’s plea for revenge, and he replies by reassuring the ghost that, “While memory holds a seat in this distracted globe. Remember thee? Yea, from the table of my memory I’ll wipe away all trivial fond records...and thy commandment all alone shall live” (1∙5∙96-102). He directly promises to focus his attentions on no other matter besides the quest to fulfill the Ghost’s plea and rest his soul. Revenge is also used as the main motive in Christopher Nolan’s film Momento. Leonard is a man who has set out on a quest to find his wife’s killer and avenge her. However, due to his condition, Leonard suffers from a form of amnesia that enables him to create new memories. This forces him to rely on numerous methods of note taking as constant reminders of his purpose. The use of revenge as a motive is clearly evident in Leonard’s response to Natalie’s opinion of his quest being pointless, when he states, “My wife deserves vengeance, and it doesn’t make any difference whether I know about it” (Momento, 2000). Despite revenge acting as the joint motive behind both protagonists’ actions, ironically in Hamlet, the plot is driven by his inability to actually commit to the act of revenge, while in Momento, Leonard’s inability to create new memories results in a tragic realization. No matter how many times he tries to pursue this “John G,” Leonard will live in constant ignorance of the reality of how his wife truly died, and therefore will continue searching for pointless victims to fulfill his cycle of false reality. In Hamlet’s case, revenge also causes the death of innocent victims (such as Ophelia and Polonius), yet he is blind to the destruction caused by actions due to his ignorance of what is right and wrong. In these ways, both plots are driven by revenge, yet the consequences of ignorance results in the destruction of both protagonists.
In the quests of both the film and play, both protagonists struggle to overcome an inability to trust people which become a major obstacle in the attempts to achieve their goals. In the film Momento, Leonard’s form of amnesia prevents him from being able to instil his trust in others due to the chance one might take advantage of his situation and use it for personal gain. The consequence of trusting others is seen when Burt (the owner of the motel Leonard is staying in) admits, “Business is slow. I told my boss about you, about your condition. He told me to try and rent you another room” (Momento, 2000). This is evidence of the trouble Leonard faces when trying to determine who is trying to help him, and who his enemies are. This obstacle of trust is also seen in Leonard’s association with Natalie. Throughout the majority of the movie, it appears as though Natalie is helping Leonard avenge his wife’s death due to her own personal loss; however it is quickly revealed
Show More

Related Documents: Essay about The truth, or not the truth. That is the question

Analysis Of Sojourner Truth's Speech 'Ain T I A Women?'

the stereotypes put on women. Truth claims that women are just as capable as man despite being treated as inferior. In Truths piece she uses rhetorical questions repetition and diction to prove her argument that although she is not tested like a lady she is still a women. In Truth's speech she addresses her crowd forcefully. She wants everyone, men and women, to know she is a woman, and she is strong. We see in her speech she asks the crowd multiple rhetorical questions and in each her tone of voice…

Words 692 - Pages 3

A Conditional Sentence With A False Antecedent?

1) In the truth table for an invalid argument, Student Answer: on at least one row, where the premises are all true, the conclusion is true. CORRECT on at least one row, where the premises are all true, the conclusion is false. on all the rows where the premises are all true, the conclusion is true. on most of the rows, where the premises are all true, the conclusion is true. Instructor Explanation: The answer can be found in Chapter Six of An Introduction to Logic…

Words 435 - Pages 2

Truth Serum Research Paper

Truth about truth Serum Popular culture makes gratuitous use of powerful lie-repelling agents known as Truth Serums. They are usually depicted as injected drugs which strongly inhibit a subject’s ability to lie, causing him or her to mechanically recite the truth to an interviewer upon questioning. Such drugs have been utilized by some of the three-letter government agencies in the not-so-distant past (CIA, FBI, DOD, KGB, etc.)., particularly during the rampant paranoia of the Cold War…

Words 532 - Pages 3

Essay about What Is Truth - Comparison of Plato and Peirce's Philosophy

What is Truth? For thousands of years, mankind has persistently pursued truth, knowledge, and understanding. For most, this pursuit is a driving force which usually doesn't end until one finds a "truth" that is satisfying to him or her. Even then, however, one may choose to look for an alternate truth that may be even more satisfying to them. This pursuit does not always follow the same path for everyone as there are different ideas as to how truth is actually obtained and which is the best way…

Words 975 - Pages 4

Truth and Artist Essay

each author’s time. In “Allegory of the Cave” the philosopher is being portrayed by the one prisoner of the cave who is freed and finds that everything he has believed to hold true is in truth not reality at all but are copies, just mere shadows, of the real world. Once the prisoner understands and accepts this truth he knows he has to enlighten the other prisoners. Pause button. Fast forward two thousand years to Baldwin’s essay “The Creative Process” where he writes “A society must assume that it…

Words 663 - Pages 3

Apologetics Research Papers

today. Finally, we'll deal with the question of presenting a case for Christianity.…

Words 550 - Pages 3

Explain Plato's Definition Of Truth

Discuss Plato's definition of truth. Why does he maintain that truth is eternal and perfect? How do most people feel about truth today? Is truth relative or is it absolute? Plato believed the truth was something only exclusive to the wise. He stated that wisdom was a type of knowledge that only belong to whoever was allotted with the birthright. It was up to the wise to teach the truth to the others who couldn't see the truth or lack that birthright. Plato maintains the truth is eternal and perfect…

Words 214 - Pages 1

Response: Oedipus and Key Character Essay

Question: Explain the function of the character Tiresias in the play. What does Tiresias’ blindness signify? Chen Xin (Hannah) Tiresias is a key character in “Oedipus the King”. Firstly, he tells the truth and summary for the story although he only shows up for one scene. As a key character, he shows up at a key moment telling truth, summarizing for the plot and making critical comments on it. What he does causing a small upsurge and promote the development of plot. Secondly, when Oedipus…

Words 319 - Pages 2

Summary: Victory In Spiritual Warfare

depending the belt of truth (v14). If time permits, we will also cover body of armor of God's righteousness (v14) and shoes... peace...from the Good News (v15). Also use other reliable Christian resources to help you understand and breakdown the scriptures and to gain deeper insight of each pieces and how to properly use them in your daily battle in spiritual warfare for yourself, your family, your Christian brothers and sisters and non-believers. Below are a few questions that can help you in…

Words 562 - Pages 3

Ain T I A Woman Analysis

to say without any of the long winded sentences, cryptic metaphors, and flowery imagery we are used to seeing in other works of the genre. Instead, with her simple spoken words, poignant examples, and passion, Sojourner Truth uniquely argues for women’s rights. Sojourner Truth doesn’t burden you with historical…

Words 540 - Pages 3