Thomas Aquinas Argument For The Existence Of God

Words: 1434
Pages: 6
Open Document
I. Short Topics
1. The argument of the piece of wax was proposed by Descartes in Meditation II. He explains that even though wax may change different states and the characteristics of the wax may alter, it still remains as wax. Descartes uses this argument to define what it is that allows him to discern the different states of the wax to still be wax. Descartes finds that a piece of wax is “in no way revealed by my imagination, but is perceived by the mind alone” (Rosen, 360). He doubts his senses, that although allow him to experience the smell and texture of the wax, could otherwise be deceiving. He says that his ability to judge what he perceives with his senses is how he knows the changed state of wax to still be wax. He says “Something …show more content…
The impossibility of there being infinite series of causes is one of the main arguments defending the existence of God. It is believed that there was a primary cause that set the universe in motion. The first of Aquinas’ Five Ways that serve to prove the existence of God, is the idea of the unmoved mover. Aquinas explains that “whatever is in motion is put in motion by another” (Rosen, 12). This is the idea that nothing can be the cause of itself, and behind every action there must be separate cause behind it. His argument, the cosmological argument, says that there cannot be an infinite series of causes, as there must be one sole cause that is the “first mover, put in motion by no other; and this everyone understands to be God” (Rosen, 12). Aquinas says that it is “plainly false” (Rosen, 12) that efficient causes can go on to infinity, as there would be no first cause, neither any “ultimate effect, nor any intermediate efficient causes” (Rosen, 12). This is one of the most prevalent arguments for the existence of God, and is quite …show more content…
The transparency of consciousness is what inhibits us from fully understanding the difference between our mind, or consciousness, and our body. Thomas Nagel explains that it is impossible for us to understand the experiences of other beings, because “no matter how the form (of our sense perception) may vary, the fact that an organism has conscious experience at all means, basically, that there is something it is like to be that organism” (Rosen, 403). The fact that all living things with any conscious experience have different interpretations of stimuli, and thus have different experience. Our consciousness makes our interpretation of the world transparent, and infinitely different compared to other beings. This dilemma is significant in that it has separated the experiences of our bodies from that of our minds, and has acknowledged that there is an incongruity between the experiences of all beings despite how similar our sense perception may
Show More

Related Documents: Thomas Aquinas Argument For The Existence Of God

Thomas Aquinas Arguments For The Existence Of God

plausible arguments and theories on the controversial topic of the existence of God. Among the arguments for the existence of God, the cosmological arguments provide the best evidence. In this essay I will be analyzing the argument from contingency. The argument from contingency is Thomas Aquinas’s third argument for the existence of God and argues that the universe is contingent upon the necessary existence of God. While plausible, I believe that this argument fails in proving the existence of God…

Words 588 - Pages 3

Saint Thomas Aquinas Argument For The Existence Of God

In his work Summa Theologica, Saint Thomas Aquinas ponders the existence of God and debates a series of questions, culminating in an overview of his five ways to prove there is a God. In the fifth way, now better known as Thomas' "Argument from Design", the philosopher uses a teleological approach to assert nature is governed, or directed, by an intelligent being known to man as God. Aquinas states that everything has an order, which can be explained only by a purpose, or design. Since design…

Words 1175 - Pages 5

Compare And Contrast Anslem Vs. Anselm

of 76 in 1109. Reasoned God's’ existence with ontological argument. Another Philosopher was born later named Thomas Aquinas or Saint Aquinas, born in 1225-1274 (Palmer 2013). He argued over the existence of God, but he had five philosophical arguments called the cosmological arguments. Anslem and Aquinas have two different philosophies, but some comparisons and contrasts exist between the two arguments. While Anselm’s argument comes from a theory of being, Thomas was concerned with observing the…

Words 371 - Pages 2

Thomas Aquinas Five Ways

Thomas Aquinas: The Five Ways Thomas Aquinas was a Dominican monk who lived from 1225-1274, who is mainly known and respected as one of the greatest theologians in religion. In The Five Ways, Aquinas puts forth five valid philosophical arguments to prove the existence of a God or higher being. The first point proposes that because change occurs all the time, there must be an Unmoved Mover that all change or movement originates from. The second argument is similar, and points out that with causation…

Words 754 - Pages 4

Term Paper

St. Thomas Aquinas Thomas Aquinas is a famous Christian philosopher. Although he died very young, he lived his life to the fullest teaching people and even writing many volumes of books outlining his thoughts. Through Aquinas’ history and philosophical studies we know about his own views of philosophy. Thomas Aquinas was born in 1225 in southern Italy. “Before St. Thomas Aquinas was born, a holy hermit shared a prediction with his mother, foretelling that her son would enter the Order…

Words 1803 - Pages 8

The Existence Of God

The Existence of God Proof of Gods existence has always been a question I often ponder about. Almost everyone at some particular point in his or her life has challenged the existence of God. This may happen for a number of reasons. For example he or she might have been at a point in their life when their faith alone was just not enough for them to believe. Humans have a natural instinct to find reasons for events that can’t be explained. Whether or not God exists has risen to conflict and caused…

Words 2512 - Pages 11

Thomas Aquinas Arguments Against Contingency Analysis

I intend to justify and prove Thomas Aquinas’ Argument From Contingency, and through that the existence of God. This argument can be backed up by a later argument by Aquinas, The Teleological Argument as well as the watchmaker theory. They prove this through saying that if there is an intelligent designer. This intelligent designer must also be a necessary being therefore arguing for the Argument from Contingency. There are also arguments placed against the Argument from Contingency such as the Theory…

Words 1141 - Pages 5

The Cosmological Argument Essay

Cosmological Argument- Basic essay plan layout INTRODUCTION * One of the oldest arguments for the existence of God * Based on experience that everything has a cause- a poseriori * Its premises are drawn from experience, not from analytical truths, and reach an inductive conclusion, that is, one which may possibly be correct, but is not logically necessary * It moves on the assumption that the universe must have a first cause – a priori * Originates from the thinking of Aristotle…

Words 542 - Pages 3

Cosmological argument essay

“Explain Aquinas’ cosmological argument” The cosmological argument or first cause argument is that everything has a cause, causal chains cannot be infinite, and so there must be an uncaused cause at its origin. It is a posteriori argument (knowledge gained after experience) which attempts to prove that there is a rational basis for the belief in God. Christian philosopher St Thomas Aquinas (1225-1274) came up with the cosmological argument not to prove the existence of God but rather solidify his…

Words 507 - Pages 3

School Work Essay

pray and ask, but we are never shown” - George Petit St. Thomas Aquinas explores in Question Two: The Existence of God the over arching question of whether God exists. He examines five reasons or arguments as too how God must exist and the ways in which it can be proved. The most interesting of which is argument number three, that is the reductio argument, or rather the argument from possibility and necessity. In his argument, Aquinas establishes a theory that everything in the material universe…

Words 944 - Pages 4