To What Extent Do Different Electoral Systems Produce Different Outcomes? Essay

Words: 1045
Pages: 5
Open Document
To what extent do different electoral systems produce different outcomes?
In this essay I will assess the outcomes of Additional Member system, First Past the Post system and the Closed Party List system. The F-P-T-P system is used to elect the members of House of Commons and local government in England and Wales. Voters select candidates, and do so by marking his or her name with an ‘X’ on the ballot paper. This reflects the principle of ‘one person, one vote’. The Additional Members system is used in Scottish parliament, Welsh assembly, and Northern Ireland Assembly and Greater London assembly. It is a mixed system made up of F-P-T-P and party-list elements. The Regional party list (or the closed party list) is used to elect the …show more content…
Thus Closed Party List system produces different outcome to other voting systems.
However, there is similarity between the outcomes of different electoral systems, as F-P-T-P can lead to coalition government. For example in 2010 general election a coalition was formed between the Conservatives (with 32.4% of the votes) and Liberal Democrats (with 22.0% of the votes). This suggests that coalition government still can be formed using F-P-T-P if neither of the two main parties have sufficient authority to run the government. Accordingly, third parties like liberal Democrats can in theory exert tremendous influence in such a situation since they can ally with one of the two main parties to form a coalition, which subsequently happened in 2010 elections. Thus, electoral systems do sometimes produce similar outcomes.
Moreover, all electoral system used in the UK provide geographical representation to varying degrees. For example in the 1974 election when Conservatives won 200,000 more votes than Labour but won fur fewer seats, as Labour had more concentrated support in certain degree. Furthermore, as AMS is a hybrid system which incorporates F-P-T-P system and closed party list system (which can be either regional or nationalists). Thus it can be said that electoral systems in the UK can have similar outcomes.
Furthermore, all the electoral
Show More

Related Documents: To What Extent Do Different Electoral Systems Produce Different Outcomes? Essay

Assignment: Elections and State Resources Essay

authoritarian regimes that hold elections tend to last longer than those that do not.1 It is only in “competitive authoritarian” regimes, which already exhibit some degree of political uncertainty and potential instability, that elections appear to increase the likelihood of a stable transition to democracy.2 Why do elections often tend to reinforce rather than undermine authoritarian regimes, and under what conditions do they do so? Focusing on legislative elections in the Middle East and North Africa…

Words 6115 - Pages 25

Essay on KeytermsinUKpolitics 1

authority of the king or queen; absolute monarchies are usually based on the doctrine of ‘divine right’. Act: A statute law; a bill that has completed its various parliamentary stages and become an Act of Parliament. Additional member system (AMS): A ‘mixed’ voting system that is made up of a constituency-based ‘first past the post’ element and a regional party-list element, the latter being a ‘top-up’ to achieve the highest possible level of proportionality (see p. 73). Adjournment debate: A debate…

Words 6971 - Pages 28

WhyAmericanPoliticalPartiesCan TGetBeyondtheLeft RightDivide Essay

to be a serious third party candidate in 2012, with a serious political movement behind him or her — one definitely big enough to impact the election’s outcome.” The Pulitzer Prize-winning scribe claimed that this new party would not come from the right or the left, but the “radical center” which he claimed was tired of a failed two-party system. Two years later, Friedman followed up, promoting former U.S. comptroller general David Walker as an independent candidate who would appeal to moderate America…

Words 8056 - Pages 33

work of art Essay

he stole. While she uses force against him, she did not initiate it. Her force is in retaliation in response the initiation of force by the mugger. While some people initiate force against others and some people use force in retaliation, governments do the same. For example, the young woman pulls her cell phone out of her purse and calls 911. The police arrive and arrest the mugger because it is against the law to commit assault, battery, and theft. This type of law is the use of force by the government…

Words 4638 - Pages 19

Contract The Budget System Of Fiscal Accountability In Presidential And Parliamentary Systems Of Government

processes and systems of fiscal accountability in Presidential and Parliamentary systems of Government. Student: Lyn Marie James Abstract There is diversity of forms of government (Laundy, 1989) and different ways of classifying them and as such, this paper sets out to discuss the budgetary powers of the legislature under different forms of government, and the environment that informed the political structures. The paper discusses the different forms of government systems that exist in…

Words 8218 - Pages 33

Getting Health Reform Right Ch 2 Essay

rarely takes place in such a simple fashion. Instead, reform efforts may begin in different places and skip stages, or several stages may occur at the same time. For example, health reformers might begin with a diagnosis, declaring, “The cause of all our problems is that public clinics and hospitals do not have enough resources to provide good service.” Or reform advocates might start with their favorite solution—”What our country needs is a new national social insurance scheme.” Yet however the reform…

Words 7603 - Pages 31

Theories Of The World-Systematic Perspectives In Identifying Patterns Of How Things Work

more centralized apparatus and the emergence of mass politics {electoral engagement}) the emergence of new and prominent social classes. Adam Smith Reading #1 The Scottish enlightenment (smith is an exemplar of) · Hume- investigated morality/human nature and politics · Smith engaged Rousseau (turned the tables on him) Smith- society taught man to be good Rousseau- society perverse of man. Smith thinks that what defines humanity is sympathy squared (putting yourself in someone…

Words 7937 - Pages 32

Quality of life three years after diagnosis of prostate cancer Essay

cancer were eligible if aged less than 70 years, diagnosed between October 2000 and October 2002, and notified to the New South Wales central cancer registry. Controls were randomly selected from the New South Wales electoral roll and matched to cases by age and postcode. Main outcome measures General health specific and disease specific function up to three years after diagnosis, according to the 12 item short form health survey and the University of California, Los Angeles prostate cancer index…

Words 9200 - Pages 37

Analysis Of Supreme Court Cases

critical thinking. In that regard students will be encouraged to identify an order, a system, and the interrelationships between agencies and individuals in the constitutional law process. Upon successful completion of the class each student should have confidence in his or her ability to understand and explain to others the logic used in Court decisions and, to the extent possible, predict specific outcomes in future cases dealing with issues which have not as yet materialized. INSTRUCTOR INFORMATION…

Words 7388 - Pages 30

Essay about Sovereignty Revisited Jens

224. $99.95 £52.50. ISBN 0754635341. Walker, Neil (ed.). Sovereignty in Transition. Oxford: Hart, 2003. Pp. 556. £53. ISBN 184113337X. Abstract This essay, in discussing some recent contributions to the contemporary debate on sovereignty, focuses on what is at stake in this debate. While most authors today agree that the meaning of the concept of sovereignty is open to change across time and space, students of international law and international relations disagree about the causes and consequences…

Words 6205 - Pages 25