Tradition Definition Essay

Submitted By th13ga
Words: 521
Pages: 3
Open Document
Traditional definitions, at least as commonly portrayed in contemporary discussions of the definition of art, take artworks to be characterized by a single type of property. The standard candidates are representational properties, expressive properties, and formal properties. So there are representational or mimetic definitions, expressive definitions, and formalist definitions, which hold that artworks are characterized by their possession of, respectively, representational, expressive, and formal properties. It is not difficult to find fault with these simple definitions. For example, possessing representational, expressive, and formal properties cannot be sufficient conditions, since, obviously, instructional manuals are representations, but not typically artworks, human faces and gestures have expressive properties without being works of art, and both natural objects and artifacts produced for the homeliest utilitarian purposes have formal properties but are not artworks.

But the ease of these dismissals serves as a reminder of the fact that traditional definitions of art are not self-contained. Each traditional definition stands in (different) close and complicated relationships to its system's other complexly interwoven parts — epistemology, ontology, value theory, philosophy of mind, etc. For this reason, it is both difficult and somewhat misleading to extract them and consider them in isolation. Two examples of historically influential definitions of art offered by great philosophers will suffice to illustrate. First, Plato holds in the Republic and elsewhere that the arts are representational, or mimetic (sometimes translated “imitative”). Artworks are ontologically dependent on, and inferior to, ordinary physical objects, which in turn are ontologically dependent on, and inferior to, what is most real, the non-physical Forms. Grasped perceptually, artworks present only an appearance of an appearance of what is really real. Consequently, artistic experience cannot yield knowledge. Nor do the makers of artworks work from knowledge. Because artworks engage an unstable, lower part of the soul, art should be subservient to moral realities, which, along with truth, are more metaphysically fundamental and hence more humanly important than beauty. Beauty is not, for Plato, the distinctive province of the arts, and in fact his conception of beauty is extremely wide and
Show More

Related Documents: Tradition Definition Essay

Samuels V. Gotham Case Study

Powell and Sarah Samuels v. Gotham. The parties wish to engage in a voluntary marriage union (lesbian). The state feels that in the protection of the traditional marriage, the definition of marriage should be between a man and a woman. Using the standard rational scrutiny, the court is expected to move that the definition remain within the powers and providence of the state. The due process clause says “nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of…

Words 1467 - Pages 6

Aquinas And Catherine Of Sien Faith Analysis

Thomas Aquinas and Catherine of Siena help give a definition to the concept of faith as known today. Faith is defined as the fullness of reason; that is the fullness of knowable, rational, and content. Faith is God’s very knowledge of all things including all the saints and angels. Faith is hard to understand and comprehend, because one’s current grasp of reason. The Catholic Tradition defines tradition as an argument extended through time in which certain fundamental agreements are defined and redefined…

Words 993 - Pages 4

Human Ethical Condition Research Paper

individual beings, in that part I will be discussing how humans are social creatures in the sense of what social, relational and inter-rational creatures actually mean. In part two I will be looking at my above answer and will be explaining the role of traditions in the human condition. In my conclusion I will be summarizing all of the above discussed topics from part one and part two. Part One Confucius like most of mankind believed that humans were made to be apart of the greater society, meaning…

Words 661 - Pages 3

Edith Windsor Case Summary

undeniable that its judgement is based on federalism”. The Court had found that the DOMA had offended the Constitution because it had represented an “unusual deviation from the usual tradition of recognizing and accepting state definitions of marriage (U.S. v. W).” The Court had stated that “By history and tradition the definition and regulation of marriage has been treated as being within the authority and realm of the separate States (Understanding…

Words 853 - Pages 4

Summary Of David Chidester's Authentic Fakes

the beliefs and traditions that people live by on a daily basis. According to the article, no one has the same understanding of the definition of religion. For example, Emile Durkheim defined religion as “beliefs and practices relating to a sacred focus that unifies people as a community.” Whereas E. B. Tylor defined religion as “beliefs and practices relating to the supernatural”. No two people have the same perspective on religion because there essentially is not just one definition.…

Words 451 - Pages 2

Religion The Silk Road Summary

As an associate professor of Religion at Concordia University in Montreal, Richard Foltz specializes in the history of Iran along with religions such as Islam and Zoroastrianism. He is the author or editor of eight books and around seventy articles. In his book, Religions of the Silk Road, Foltz takes readers along the path that many travelers would have taken centuries ago. He outlines reasons the trip was dangerous, but also why it was worth it. He mentions that while trade was what the road became…

Words 433 - Pages 2

Euthyphro And Confucius's Argument Analysis

choices and consequences, thus defining “good” to be based on the knowledge you possess. Although Confucius’s Analects may seem stronger because the act of a “good citizen” is introduced through moral reasoning, Plato’s Euthyphro provides a stronger definition of how humanity urges a good reasoning so that a social order is achieved through the use of logical assumptions and commonalities from one’s knowledge because rational reasoning is made from one’s true understanding of what they choose to belief…

Words 1392 - Pages 6

The Medicine Bag Theme

Virginia Driving Hawk Sneve and "Who are You Today, Maria?" by Judith Ortiz Cofer show examples of how generations are tied together. Tradition and items connect people of different generations. Tradition is something that keeps occurring throughout each generation. Items are passed down if it's valuable, so it would be received to each generation. The definition of tradition itself is the handing down of beliefs, customs, etc., from generation to generation, or a continuing pattern of culture beliefs…

Words 571 - Pages 3

New Economics Spaces Definitions Essay

New Economic Spaces Definitions Term | Definition | Lecture | Space | An area of the earth’s surface with physical distance; an abstract concept, w/ territoriality/form, location within space, “flowable”, unevenly developed | 1 | Place | Area to which a group of people have become attached; specificity and uniqueness | 1 | Scale | Geographical levels of human activity; differently sized units of analysis (ie. Global, macro-regional, national, regional, local, lived places, body) | 1 |…

Words 859 - Pages 4

What Is A Religion Essay

What is a Religion? A dictionary definition of religion looks something like: Religion, n.; An organized system of beliefs and/or rituals, centering on a supernatural being or beings. Everyone with me so far? Good. I think we can all agree on definitions for "Beliefs" and "Supernatural", so the only sub-definition will be "Ritual": any ordered sequence of events or actions, including directed thoughts, especially one that is repeated in the 'same' manner each time, and that is designed…

Words 909 - Pages 4