Trench Warfare Source Analysis

Words: 638
Pages: 3
Open Document
Source C can be considered useful to a historian studying the nature of trench warfare as it summarises modern discoveries into the living conditions within the trenches as well as the battle conditions on the front. It is a secondary source from the Daily Mail Online and written by Graham Smith, published on the 10th of February 1012. Being a secondary source and published in 2012 would mean that it was written with hindsight from the war resulting in a substantial lack of bias being so far removed from the war. Smith would have also had a plethora of both primary and secondary sources about trench warfare to compare their article to thus conveying the reliability of the source. However it is an online article from the Daily Mail, which suggests that there is a highly …show more content…
This would mean that the source lacks historical background and in conjunction with the possibility with little to none peer reviewing, it makes the source fairly unreliable for a historian studying the nature of trench warfare. Also the perspective of a journalist wouldn’t increase the usefulness of the source for a historian, as it provides information already available elsewhere in the historical discourse by a person will little to no historian background. Though Source C is unreliable in terms of how it was written and researched, its content is reliable as it presents information that corroborates with the historical discourse of the nature of trench warfare making it highly useful for historians. It is known that the state of the terrain during trench warfare was usually muddy which led to a hazardous and arduous battleground and this is conveyed in “the remaining men had to be left under a mountain of mud as it was too dangerous to retrieve them”. This portrays the swamp-like grounds that soldiers fought on due to usually wet
Show More

Related Documents: Trench Warfare Source Analysis

Trench Warfare In World War 1

1. This activity helped me acquire more knowledge about trench warfare in World War 1. It learned more about the way the trenches were built and their structure. As well, it helped me learn about the advantages and disadvantages of trench warfare and made me realize that it was both effective and dangerous. In addition, it helped me learn about the experience of the soldiers, the diseases they had in the trenches and the effect trench warfare had on them. 2. The part of the activity that was the…

Words 304 - Pages 2

Great War Effects

evoked by war, the outcomes of the First World War is present in our world today. The Great War prompted the emergence of the a modern era in technology and medicine. Among the deaths of over ten million soldiers was the death of traditional European warfare. No longer would war be dictated by the rifle; rather new technological advances such as tanks, airplanes,…

Words 1463 - Pages 6

Chemical Weapons Essay

and their lethality and disposal. The following report also shows the history of chemical warfare, their demilitarisation, proliferation and the various councils set up to reduce their use. It also includes a news release by the sunshine project on the use of chemical weapons by the US military. All in all it tells you everything about chemical weapons and explosives. Chemical Warfare Chemical warfare (CW)…

Words 8195 - Pages 33

Soviet Union and R.b Bennett Essay

Germany would face a war on two fronts. Germany wanted to avoid this at all costs. Germany planned to defeat France rapidly and then turn to the eastern front for a major offensive on Russia. Germany attacked France from behind. Trench: Lice was never ending in trenches, trench foot was a infection on the feet possible amputation. Rose rifle: The Ross rifle was a straight-pull bolt action .303 inch-caliber rifle produced in Canada from 1903 until 1918 Robert Borden: Promised 2500 solders to Britain…

Words 3494 - Pages 14