Michigan's Right To Work Law And A Perspective From Management And Labor

Submitted By amairs24
Words: 2349
Pages: 10
Open Document
Michigan’s Right-To-Work Law and a Perspective from Management and Labor

February 21, 2013

Michigan’s Right-To-Work Law and a Perspective from Management and Labor
Organized labor in Michigan took a devastating blow in December of 2012, with Republican lawmakers rushing a bill through the Senate and House that would have the state join the ranks of those considered to be “right-to-work” states. Those who are unfamiliar with unions and the “right to work” laws being passed in states across the nation may not realize that it is such a volatile topic or what sort of impact the law could have on their economy or jobs. The reality to those who are union members is that they are now paying dues for their co-workers to benefit from the collective bargaining benefits their union provides, even if those co-workers choose not to join the union or pay dues. Unions call these people “free-riders”. Michigan law would mean that employees no longer are required to pay union dues in order to take advantage of collective bargaining efforts. Prior to this bill being passed, employees were required to pay union dues as a condition of employment at an employer where unions were already present. According to Eichler (2012b), Michigan residents were extremely divided and heated about the bill potentially being passed prior to Governor Snyder even signing it. Both sides of the argument were clear in their opposition and/or support for the bill as well as their opinions about what the law meant for the future of Michigan. Eichler (2012b) also reported that “supporters of the bill say it would attract new employers to Michigan, but labor advocates say it would strike a blow to union finances, hurt the ability of employees to negotiate, and allow workers to skip paying dues while still enjoying the benefits of a unionized workplace.”
While unions have long been supporters of the Democratic Party and vice-verse, it is worth noting that the Republican having Senate and House rushed to have this law passed within a matter of days. Flesher and Karoub (2012) reported that while other states such as Indiana have drawn these types of legislative acts out over several weeks, Michigan’s leaders indicated their plans and pushed them through the Senate within hours, and the law was passed through the house after the legally required waiting period of five days. The governor of Michigan, Republican Rick Snyder, has been quoted as saying that the right to work law will now allow Michigan’s workers to be “free” and that it will “contribute to our state’s economic comeback while preserving the roles of unions and collective bargaining” (Flesher & Karoub, 2012). Adversaries of the new law have different views in that while the law may create more jobs, but the jobs being created will be at a much lower wage and include far less, if any, benefits.
Residents of the state are extremely divided in their opinions of the law. Two different school teachers offered their opinions on the law, one calling it a “sad day in Michigan history”, and another stating “We don't only bargain for us, but for smaller class sizes, curricular issues, and working conditions” (Flesher & Karoub 2012; Eischler, 2012b). President Barack Obama also provided his opinion on the matter saying that “so-called 'right-to-work' laws [...] don't have to do with economics, they have everything to do with politics," and that "what they're really talking about is giving you the right to work for less money” (Eichler, 2012b). Those who were in favor of the law threw around topics such as bringing in more jobs, opening up the state to more employers, and keeping the current population in residence. According to Eichler (2012a), “most added that they expect a healthier job market will soon follow.”
What is really clear to the public is the law which was rudely shoved through the necessary political maze with little regard to what the opposing (and seemingly majority) side had to
Show More

Related Documents: Michigan's Right To Work Law And A Perspective From Management And Labor

The Challenges Facing Labour Unions Today Essay

Good morning ladies and gentleman. Today I am going to talk about some of the challenges facing labor unions today and how we can rise to meet them. Government policies may vary from province to province but we are fortunate enough to have some of the strongest labor legislation out there. The economic recession has been hard on everyone and unions are no exception, with the lay-offs or closures of plants and businesses, the union faces the challenge of ensuring we stay strong and effective. In the…

Words 1639 - Pages 7

Sherman Anti-Trust Act Against Labor Unions

theory by applying the Sherman Anti-Trust Act against labor unions. The Sherman Anti-trust Act was originally passed to break up monopolies rather than unions, but it was invoked mainly against unions to hurt their power. The justification for this was explained as it was stated “combinations are condemned, not only when they take the form of trusts, but in whatever form found, if they be in restraint of trade”. The failure of the unions’ strikes, along with the involvement of the federal government…

Words 892 - Pages 4

BCOM Report Topics Spring 2015 Essay

1. For X union, investigate the impact technology has had on unions in the past ten years. 2. What are the effects of union pensions on state budgets? 3. What is the status of unions today? 4. Explore the relationships of the union and the white-collar worker. 5. What are the most important collective bargaining issues for unionized employees in X industry today? 6. Discuss and evaluate the grievance system for Company X. 7. Are white collar professionals joining unions? 8. Analyze…

Words 1473 - Pages 6

Sleepy Lagoon Case Study

The union was meant to help farmers obtain better treatment, and salary’s. Chaves helped many farmers that had no civil rights, however the government was not happy with that. The government was scared that many people were protesting, and labeled as union of violence. Cesar Chaves was not happy with his union and started to feast. However, at the end the farmers join together so their voices can be heard…

Words 445 - Pages 2

George Washington Farewell Address Summary

that his advice is timeless. Many of the pieces of advice Washington offers the American people are timeless and can be applied to life today. Washington first tries to convince the American people that their independence, peace at home and abroad, safety, prosperity, and liberty are all dependent upon the unity between all the states. This advice still applies today because if there is friction amongst any states there will no longer be peace at home. If there is tension on homeland it is more likely…

Words 554 - Pages 3

Propaganda During The Cold War

every country in the world at the time. After World War 2, the Soviet Union and the United States had an ongoing tension between each other. The cold war was a cause of the fear of communism, hate of capitalism, Truman dislikes Stalin, USSR fearing the atomic bomb, and the U.S. refusing to share nuclear secrets. If there was a claimed ‘winner’ of the war, it would easily be Ronald Reagan or the U.S.. The collapse of the Soviet Union and communism was a victory for the U.S.. There were many important…

Words 905 - Pages 4

The Pros And Cons Of Globalization

Globalisation is the current interaction of most if the world’s economies. In the world of today national economies are no longer separate entities but rather part of a world or global economy. Advantages; Integration of markets: Markets are interlinked- European Union Cheaper Products for Consumer: Trainers are Cheap Lowering of international Barriers: Now European Union can Trade with ASEAN and NAFTA. Helps prevent market Saturation in a specific market: stops there being too much…

Words 2175 - Pages 9

Unions: Union Coverage In The Private Sector

3. Why is union coverage in the private sector so much lower than coverage in the public sector and why has union coverage been much more stable among women than among men? Do you think young people today are attracted to unions? Explain why or why not? Unions have been an important part of modern day society. It gives voices to the workers whose voices are not heard and promotes laws and standards, which help all of the unionized workers and even the non-unionized ones. However in today’s society…

Words 1283 - Pages 6

Field Artillery: The Battle Of Antietam

1776 under command of President George Washington and Henry Knox. Throughout the centuries, the howitzer has come in various models and has constantly been improving to the what is it now as the modern-day piece. The howitzer today however would not be what it is today without one specific battle, The Battle of Antietam. In this paper we will prove…

Words 1129 - Pages 5

The Cold War: The Impact Of The Cold War

point of actual armed combat. It began after the end of World War II, in 1945, as a result of tension created during the war, and lasted a bit over 45 years, ending in 1991. The two main contenders in the war were the United States and the Soviet Union, though some other countries, such as Cuba and Turkey, were also involved.…

Words 991 - Pages 4