Urban Design Essay

Submitted By baroeeisticmaal
Words: 9490
Pages: 38
Open Document
BEYOND THE ENTREPRENEURIAL CITY:
MUNICIPAL CAPITALISM IN SAN DIEGO
TIM CHAPIN*
Florida State University, Tallahassee

ABSTRACT: Over the last several decades the public sector has become much more innovative and entrepreneurial when pursuing downtown redevelopment, embracing characteristics previously restricted to the private sector. This article investigates this approach by reviewing a major redevelopment project in San Diego. In the course of this project the public sector acted in ways that exemplify the entrepreneurial approach to downtown redevelopment. However, rather than simply taking on an entrepreneurial role, the city's efforts are better described by the term municipal capitalism. No longer content to simply stand by after providing some resources at the outset, the public sector is now the lead player throughout the entirety of the redevelopment process, an actor as focused upon the return on investment from the project as the private sector.
This article concludes with a discussion of the emerging role of the public sector as a capitalistic actor, and explores the consequences of this emergence.

I

t has been well documented that cities in America and Britain have responded to the continued flight of families and jobs to suburban areas and the concurrent physical deterioration of downtown areas with a bricks and mortar approach to revitalization that has centered on entertainment, tourism, culture, and the arts (Frieden & Sagalyn, 1989;
Robertson, 1995). These approaches to redevelopment have taken many diverse forms including Baltimore's entertainment-oriented waterfront (Levine, 1987), Indianapolis' sports-centered redevelopment (Bamberger & Parham, 1984; Rosentraub, Swindell,
Przybliski, & Mullins, 1994), and Louisville's use of the arts to further its urban development agenda (Whitt & Lammers, 1991). The promotion of urban lifestyles has emerged as a key ingredient to downtown redevelopment as well (Lang, Hughes, & Danielsen, 1997).
The public sector has become much more innovative and entrepreneurial when pursuing downtown redevelopment, embracing characteristics previously restricted to the private sector (Frieden & Sagalyn, 1989; Roberts & Schein, 1993). Harvey (1989) characterized this shift in the approach of urban governments towards development-oriented activities

*Direct correspondence to: Timothy Chapin, Assistant Professor, Department of Urban and Regional Planning,
Florida State University, 336 Bellamy Building, Tallahassee, FL 32306-2280. E-mail: tchapin@garnet.acns.fsu.edu
JOURNAL OF URBAN AFFAIRS, Volume 24, Number 5, pages 565±581.
Copyright # 2002 Urban Affairs Association
All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.
ISSN: 0735-2166.

566 | JOURNAL OF URBAN URBAN AFFAIRS | Vol. 24/No. 5/2002

as a movement from managerialism to entrepreneurialism. Typifying this entrepreneurial approach, the public sector now regularly undertakes high-risk projects and utilizes innovative financing mechanisms such as speculative revenue bonds and tax increment financing. The public sector also routinely enters into public-private partnerships to complete revitalization projects and to achieve redevelopment objectives, further blurring the lines between public and private. The public sector has also generally organized its redevelopment agencies as quasi-governmental entities that often operate outside of the boundaries of typical government agencies.
This article investigates this entrepreneurial approach to downtown redevelopment by reviewing a major redevelopment project in San Diego. In some ways this is a very typical project as the city is the major financier for a new downtown baseball stadium, a familiar scenario in recent years. To further this project the city of San Diego acted in ways that exemplify the entrepreneurial approach to downtown redevelopment. The city utilized innovative financing tools and spearheaded a complex
Show More

Related Documents: Urban Design Essay

Geography: City and Urban Design Movement Essay

Year 12 Geography Revision Urbanism- a focus on cities and urban areas, their geography, economies, politics, social characteristics, as well as the effects on, and caused by, the built environment. Urbanisation-the loss removal of the rural characteristics of a town or area, a process associated with the development of civilization and technology. New economy industry- New urbanism- an urban design movement, which promotes walkable neighbourhoods that contain a range of housing and job types…

Words 682 - Pages 3

Islamic City Essay

Kent State University – College of Architecture and Environmental Design The Forces that Shape Cities – UD 55705 Fall 2012 – Steve Rugare, Instructor Final Exam Directions You have one week after the studio jury to compose responses to each of the questions below. Your response to each of the first three questions should be no more than four pages (double-spaced, 11 point type). The purpose of the page limits is to force you think through what you write. Unlike a conventional, in-class essay…

Words 560 - Pages 3

Comparative Essay, Concrete Dragon vs Suburban Nation

University of Idaho Department of Architecture and Interior Design Arch 483: Urban Theory and Issues Fall 2014 Professor Wendy McClure COMPARATIVE BOOK REVIEW EVALUATION SHEET Please print out and attach this form with a stapler to your comparative book review before handing in and write your name on back of last page. Title of Books1 and 2 Suburban Nation & Concrete Dragon Your Name: Identification of significant points from each book used for comparative discussion Excellent…

Words 2065 - Pages 9

The Importance Of Urban Space

the environment, a design must be able to vibrate its spatial potential and conduct improvements. “Lighting improvements are among the most cost-effective and environmentally sustainable measures. Long-term investments are profitable within a relatively short period of time, because savings are gained by low power consumption and shorter maintenance intervals for the replacement of lamps.” (Paskovic, 2012) To enhance the vibe of the urban space, we could work on the urban lighting system and…

Words 762 - Pages 4

Smart Growth Community Essay

Malaysia. The case is about Strategising urban planning in Penang. In this context, excessive land use has been widespread in Penang area. Therefore, government put an effort in strategized planning to reduce the issue. The smart growth urban planning and transportation was one of the many recommendations to reduce the urban sprawl affecting Penang. The smart growth concept been used towards Penang by considering Penang island’s urban pattern. Proper development has been channelled…

Words 2427 - Pages 10

Mixed Use Urban Development

INTRODUCTION Background of Study Over the past several decades, mixed-use development has taken center stage in the urban planning and real estate development worlds. Mixing land uses is a ubiquitous component of the underlying visions and ideals whether it is the New Urbanism, Smart Growth, the Compact City, or any other movement relating to the improvement of the built environment. The concept is being embraced more by private sectors, and by each of the major parties involved in the real estate…

Words 5134 - Pages 21

Essay On Smart City

storm drainage network by using smart components, tools, and ideas in a system. By using smart technological tools. Hear we talk about smart city suart. It is the 8th largest city and 9th largest urban agglomeration in India. Surat is the 3rd "cleanest city of India" according to the Indian Ministry of Urban Development, and 4th fastest growing city of the world. Water which originates throughout precipitation events is known as Stormwater. soak into the…

Words 963 - Pages 4

Race-Based Sociological Analysis

a main factor in urban design. Brooke…

Words 693 - Pages 3

Article Summaries Essay

nicotine dependence? Tobacco use is responsible for more deaths in the world than most other accidents and medical incidents combined (Riggs, Chih-Ping, Chaoyang, & Pentz, 2007). The reviews in this article show the results of a longitudinal research design conducted for studies from ages 12-28. Evaluations of these tests offered at six month intervals, and 18 month intervals showed that most people peaked as adolescents and declined with emerging adulthood (Riggs, Chih-Ping, Chaoyang, & Pentz, 2007)…

Words 875 - Pages 4

Essay Urban Planning and City

HIPPODAMUS THE “FATHER” OF URBAN PLANNING Hippodamus, a pioneer of many urban planning’s which he devised an epic ideal city that would be inhabited by 10,000 men (free male citizens) but the overall population including correspondent women, slaves and children would reach about 50,000 citizens. He read and studied the function problems of the city/s & linked them to a state administration system. He divided the citizens into three classes (artisans, soldiers & ‘husbandmen’), with land divided…

Words 1770 - Pages 8