Vaccines Ethic 2 Essay

Submitted By shardy94
Words: 2737
Pages: 11
Open Document
Becky Edwards
To Vaccinate or Not to Vaccinate: The Ethical Debate
South College-Asheville
Instructor: Gloria Simuel MSN, RN

To Vaccinate Or Not To Vaccinate
To vaccinate or not to vaccinate: this is an ethical debate that has been around since the 1700s. The debate in America can also be traced back to the 1700s, which was based on the right to be inoculated against smallpox. Currently the vaccination debate has evolved into the right not to vaccinate. Vaccinations are effective in eliminating many infectious diseases that are known to be harmful to the general public (Center Disease Control,[CDC] 2011). They are limited to their full effectiveness based on the percentage of the population vaccinated (CDC, 2011). Thus, another ethical dilemma: the people’s right to refuse versus the danger that they place the general public in. Through the history of the debate nurses have been at the front because ethics is a vital part in the foundation of nursing with its rich history demonstrating the concern for the welfare of the sick, injured and vulnerable and for social justice (American Nurses Association, [ANA] 2001). The strong influence by the nursing code of ethics is shown in the purposes they serve and what keeps nurses at the front of the debate on vaccinations.
“The code of ethics for nurses serves the following purpose: It is a succinct statement of the ethical obligations and duties of every individual who enters the nursing profession. It is the profession’s nonnegotiable ethical standard. It is an expression of nursing’s own understanding of its commitment to society” (ANA, 2001, p. 145)..
The ethical debate on vaccination is not a new topic. In fact it has been an ongoing debate for well over 100 years. The precursor to vaccination started with “inoculation which involved lancing open a wound and implanting dried scabs or fresh pus containing variola (the virus that causes smallpox) under the skin of a healthy, uninfected person” (Markel, 2011, p. D5). This was a common practice in China as well as used during the Ottoman Empire (Markel, 2011).
One such debate in the United States involved the Puritan minister Cotton Mather in 1721 when he was promoting inoculation in partnership with a Boston physician named Zabdiel Boylston. Mather’s efforts were opposed by none other than Benjamin Franklin’s brother James, the contrarian publisher of The New England Courant. James Franklin argued that beside the integral danger of the procedure those religious zealots such as Mather should not be allowed to practice medicine. James Franklin was not alone in his view; many colonists believed as he did that inoculation was a breach of the Sixth Commandment [“Thou shalt not kill”] (Markel, 2011, p. D5). After the death of his younger son Francis Folger Franklin from small pox at the tender age of 4, Benjamin Franklin took up the fight for inoculation.
One can see one of the reasons for his strong stance when you look at what he wrote: “In 1736 I lost one of my sons, a fine boy of four years old, by the small-pox, taken in the common way. I long regretted bitterly, and still regret that I had not given it to him by inoculation. This I mention for the sake of parents who omit that operation, on the supposition that they should never forgive themselves if a child died under it, my example showing that the regret may be the same either way and that, therefore, the safer should be chosen (Markel, 2011, p. D5). Franklin backed his stance in the following decades by compiling and publishing quantitative studies on inoculation’s value, while working with several physicians at the Pennsylvania Hospital (Markel, 2011, p. D5).
Franklin was not only concerned with the need for inoculation but was concerned with the high cost of the procedure. The colonists’ small annual income made it impossible for them to afford the treatment. “In 1774, to counter this inequity, Franklin established the Society for Inoculating the Poor
Show More

Related Documents: Vaccines Ethic 2 Essay

Module 3 Questions Essay

1. Are drug companies that test experimental drugs in foreign countries acting ethically? Drug companies that test experimental drugs in foreign countries are not acting ethically. Testing of experimental drugs should be done in the country where the drugs are being manufactured. The major ethical dilemma is that the foreign countries that these clinical trials are not fully educated on the risks and understand what they are getting themselves into. In the article, many things stood out that these…

Words 1304 - Pages 6

Ebola Boundaries

but to hasten the patient’s death.⁽5⁾ In 61% of these case (4941 patients), the intentional overdose was given without the patient’s consent.⁽6⁾ Euthanasia has never been accepted even on request since it’s violate the code of conduct of medical ethics. “A doctor must always bear in mind the obligation of preserving human life from time of conception to death” and “when a doctor intentionally and deliberately enables an individual to end life, the doctor acts unethically”. Despite, conducting euthanasia…

Words 1000 - Pages 4

Paternalism In Health Care

For many years now, humans have struggled to answer questions about the meaning of life and how to properly conduct themselves. Ethics are principles created to guide us from what is right to what is not. Ethics help health care professionals deal with difficult and complex problems that lack easy answers. The important of ethics in the principle of health care has been recognized for many years. Health care employees have a significant impact on human life. Practice of health care involves life…

Words 1291 - Pages 6

Essay on Flu Vaccine Case Study

2004-2005 U.S. Influenza Vaccine Shortage Influenza, or the flu, causes approximately 36,000 deaths and 200,000 hospitalizations annually in the United States and costs the American economy between $11 and $18 billion each year (General Accounting Office 2001b, page 1). The primary method for preventing influenza is the flu vaccine, which is generally available in a variety of settings including clinics, hospitals, schools, workplaces, and other convenient locations. The vaccine is typically distributed…

Words 1732 - Pages 7

animal sciene Essays

beings and ask for effective banning of such acts. (Moore, 88) However, there is another side of the coin. Several diseases have been effectively eradicated in the present world. This was made possible with the invention of new vaccinations. These vaccines are tested over animals for years, before they are introduced for human consumption. Similarly advancements in organ transplantation from other species to human beings had been possible only due to such experimentations. There are various other beneficiary…

Words 601 - Pages 3

Effects Of Sucrose For Pain And Comfort

Pain and Comfort Tresha Corso Fundamentals of Nursing The Effects of Sucrose used For Pain and Comfort IASP International Council of Nursing Code of Ethics states: “It is a nurse’s responsibility to help alleviate suffering and contribute actively to accommodating vulnerable groups specific health care needs.” Children are a part of that group. Vaccines are given by the process of using a needle to inject a solution into the muscle. This is not a pain free process. As stated above we are responsible…

Words 482 - Pages 2

Intercultural Business - Drug Tests in India Essay

standards and norms 1 2 The practical value of economic ethics concepts 3 3 The RADAR concept 5 4 Business activity in India 8 5 Comparison of the cultures 9 6 Preperation for the NGO meeting 14 IV. Bibliography V Declaration II List of figures Figure 1: Overview of the different business ethics concepts 3 Figure 2: Points of the RADAR concept 5 Figure 3: Comparison of the differen cultural dimensions 9 IV List of abbreviations BVVB AG Bacteria and Virus Vaccine Biotechnology CRE…

Words 4036 - Pages 17

Bioethics Of Research Synthesis Essay

STATISTICS FOR BEHAVIORAL AND SOCIAL SCIENCES2 PART 1: Essay one: Vaccines The research question of this study tends to answer the most effective vaccine in preventing from contracting flu between a shot and a nasal spray. Therefore, the study was conducted to determine the effectiveness of the two vaccines disclosed above. Hypothesis testing encompasses careful creation of two different statements: the Null Hypothesis and the Alternative hypothesis. The Null Hypothesis echoes that there will…

Words 2254 - Pages 10

Immunizations: Vaccination and Parents Essay

Why Vaccines are Beneficial to our Children, Community & Future Jeremy W. Harris Ethics March 9, 2014 ITT Technical Institute Why Vaccines are Beneficial to our Children, Community & Future Whether to vaccinate your child or not has become a debatable issue for parents. More and more parents are choosing not to vaccinate their children, leaving them susceptible to various diseases such as measles, mumps and pertussis. Diseases which controlled are now infecting and…

Words 1518 - Pages 7

Mandatory Vaccinations

(smallpox and cowpox). Ever since then there has been a lot of controversy over effectiveness, ethics, safety of vaccinations. In 2009 it was argued whether or not it some or all vaccinations should be obligatory for all children. Parents were not happy about this at all because they thought they should be able to decide what is best for their child. Every parent is concerned about their child’s health but vaccines are questionable for some parents. Some parents believe that vaccinations are great and are…

Words 1425 - Pages 6