Her first introduction in America labeled her only as Montraville’s mistress. Being without virtue was tough on Charlotte. She was “without society” and “no woman of character [would] appear in [her] company” (p. 50). Rowson broke the fourth wall to comment on how society expects benevolence from God, but it will not show compassion to “an unfortunate female, who has once strayed into the thorny paths of vice” (p. 52). Montraville contributed greatly to Charlotte’s fallen woman status. He was well aware that Charlotte was not the kind of woman his father would approve of, no matter how charming Montraville himself found her to be. Montraville ruined Charlotte by making her his mistress instead of ignoring the disapproval of his father and marrying