Was Socrates Justified In The Apology

Words: 817
Pages: 4
Open Document
Arguably the most influential philosopher to emerge from Ancient Greece, Socrates was widely despised throughout his lifetime for his incessant search to find a man with more wisdom than he. Socrates was subjected to trial on the charges of impiety and corruption of the youth and was ultimately deemed guilty by the jury. Plato recounts Socrates’ lengthy speech of defense and his subsequent sentence to execution in his dialogue, The Apology. Regardless of his innocence or guilt, however, the verdict of Socrates’ execution is the most appropriate outcome of the trial. In his plea for acquittal, Socrates unwittingly proposes a more compelling argument in support of his own execution rather than against it. He allots a significant amount of time …show more content…
In addressing the jury, Socrates asserts: “You are wrong, sir, if you think that a man who is any good at all should take into account the risk of life or death; he should look to this only in his actions, whether what he does is right or wrong, whether he is acting like a good man” (Grube 28b). Men should not be concerned with the prospect of death, he implies; rather, they should opt to devote their lives to truth and excellence (Grube 20b). His lack of fear regarding death emits an air of confidence, enforcing his belief that nothing evil could possibly come to him after death as long as he does what is fair and just while he is still alive. It is very probable, however, that the jury misconstrued Socrates’ confidence as arrogance and therefore felt even more inclined to sentence him to death. Presumably, the majority of jurors have felt wronged by Socrates at one point or another; otherwise, he would not be on trial facing accusations at all. He earned a reputation for invalidating and humiliating those around him by questioning their wit until they begin to contradict themselves. The average people of Athens resent him for his innate gift of human wisdom, especially when he denounces his wisdom as “worthless” (Grube 23b) and speaks of death as if it is not the most daunting facet of human existence. Jealousy certainly plays a role in …show more content…
He depicts this first option as a “dreamless sleep” in which there is no concept of time, but rather death feels like one endless night; the alternative describes the afterlife as an opportunity to meet with the most accomplished men who have ever lived (Grube 40d-41b). In reality, either option is favorable to the situation in which Socrates currently resides, thus justifying execution as Socrates’ ideal course of action. Plainly, he knows for certain that imprisonment would be disagreeable, whereas death has the capacity to be the best thing to ever happen to him. The wisdom he seeks, a “wisdom more than human,” (Grube 20e) conceivably either does not exist or is unattainable in the human universe. Upon dying, however, there is great potential that Socrates will ascend to a place where he will find the wisdom he has been pursuing for the entirety of his human existence. Ironically, he will have fulfilled his life’s purpose in death. For these various reasons, I presume that some if not many of his own supporters voted in favor of his execution. While Socrates never appeals for execution,
Show More

Related Documents: Was Socrates Justified In The Apology

Socrates The Apology Analysis

In “The Apology” written by Plato, Socrates is a man on trial for impiety and corrupting the youth of Athens. In the Athenian justice system, over 500 jurors are faced with deciding Socrates’ fate. Throughout the trial Socrates uses “harm” differently than others and states that even death would not harm him. In this paper, I will argue against the claim that death can’t harm him because his argument rests on two premises that are not true. Socrates does not give an exact definition of “harm.” I…

Words 1192 - Pages 5

Plato Paper

“Euthyphro,” Socrates is accused of corrupting the youth and spreading atheist ideology. Throughout “Apology,” Socrates presents a simple and logical defense to the court, but despite his efforts, is found guilty and sentenced to death. In “Crito,” Socrates and his friends are all convinced that he has been wrongly convicted, yet they respond very differently to the obvious injustice. Crito responds as most people would. Because Socrates’ death sentence was unfairly given, Crito feels justified in plotting…

Words 525 - Pages 3

Virtue In Plato's Apology Of Socrates

In Plato’s Apology of Socrates, a man whom seeks to show the citizens of Athens that virtue isn’t differed by rich or poor and tries to identify himself as the wisest. Socrates attempts to defend himself to the jury for his false accusations by examining his lifework to the citizens of Athens. He exclaims that he has heard the Oracle’s claim and sets out to seek the truth, though he does it in a very selfish manner. I believe that he is rightfully justified in claiming that he is wiser but incorrectly…

Words 1634 - Pages 7

Essay on What Is Piety

2011 What is Piety? Life in ancient Greece was unique in itself. The whole of the city revolved around the Gods. The primary belief of the people of ancient Greece was individuals who had the right to be free, a democracy, as long as they abided in the laws of Greece. In other words, do what the Gods do. Religion in ancient Greece did not occur in a church or in a belief, but as part of a democratic government. To go against the Gods of Athens, was just unthinkable. For untimely generations…

Words 1640 - Pages 7

Philosophy 101 Study Guide Essay examples

How did he interpret the words of the Oracle at Delphi? He used the notion that the oracle told him that no one was smarter than him to go an interrogate everyone, and be a nuisance to the people. He took it as a riddle, he knew he had no wisdom and gods didn’t lie. What punishment did he offer to accept? He is sentenced to death. Locke’s Essay ‘On Enthusiasm’…

Words 3879 - Pages 16

Philosophy Essay 3

PHIL 102 – 004 What is philosophy? Philosophical views and their criticism A philosophy is a comprehensive system of ideas about human nature and the nature of the reality we live in. The definition of philosophy varies with different idealists. Socrates identifies philosophy as the will to not just live life, but to constantly question and evaluate it. He believes people should stop living instinctively, like birds that fly south for the winter. Rather, everyone should stop and reflect in order…

Words 2417 - Pages 10

Antigone: Communism and Noon est Essay

answer, but not that they're both right. Apology: Socrates tells the jury why he has avoided politics his whole life. What reasons does he give? On the other hand, in Plato's Gorgias, Socrates says that he is the only politician in Athens – go here (http://www.ancienttexts.org/library/greek/plato/gorgias.html) and search for the phrase "Then to which service of the State do you invite me?" and read from there forward to the end. What do you think? Has Socrates been a politician? (You can't answer…

Words 937 - Pages 4

A Biblical View of Science, Technology, and Business: Do Utilitarian’s Agree with These Biblical Views? Essay

Biblical Views? Utilitarianism was originated by Epicurus in ancient Greece and is the doctrine that an action is right as long as it promotes happiness, usefulness, and overall pleasurableness. If the action inflicts pain than it is not seen as right. Many of these ideas adapted well with the all of the modernization and changes that were occurring in the technology, science, and business world during the eighteenth century. Although the idea’s did fit well there was one issue, the new Utilitarian…

Words 1848 - Pages 8

Biography Of Socrates

SOCRATES Socrates 469 BC–399 BC, was a classical Greek Athenian philosopher. Credited as one of the founders of Western philosophy, he is an enigmatic figure known chiefly through the accounts of later classical writers, especially the writings of his students Plato and Xenophon, and the plays of his contemporary Aristophanes. Many would claim that Plato's dialogues are the most comprehensive accounts of Socrates to survive from antiquity. Through his portrayal in Plato's dialogues, Socrates has…

Words 9241 - Pages 37