Were Watching God Janie's Relationship

Words: 854

Pages: 4

Open Document

When Zora Neal Hurston passed away, her novel, Their Eyes Were Watching God, was not well-received by the public. After her death, people suddenly began to marvel at the phenomenality of the novel. The novel addresses a number of important issues for the time in which it was written, and it certainly extends in some way to modern society today. At the center of the novel is a black, female protagonist living in post-slavery society who confronts the social constructions imposed upon her. However, since the time it was published until today, there have been many criticisms and academic articles exploring different aspects of the novel. Many have explored the relationship the main character, Janie, has with her three husbands respectively and collectively. Logan Killicks, Joe Starks, and Tea Cake are evidently embodying different characteristics and therefore represent different types of relationships. Shawn E. Miller challenges the relationship between Janie and each of her husbands, focusing specifically on her submissiveness and rebellion to each of them in his scholarly essay, “Some Other Way to Try”: From Defiance to Creative Submission in Their Eyes Were Watching God”. Although Miller makes some strong arguments defending his opinions, there are a few …show more content…
Arguing against many different critiques of Janie, he sincerely refutes the notion that her final relationship with Tea Cake has improved because of Tea Cake’s personality. Nor is the relationship Janie acquires with Tea Cake “egalitarian and liberating” (Miller, 75). Instead, he attributes the success to Janie’s realization that the only successful relationship she can possess is through submission to both her husbands’ wills and to the role society attributes to any married female of her

Their Eyes Were Watching God Janie's Relationship

Their Eyes Were Watching God, a novel dedicated to showing the real struggles of Janie Crawford throughout her teen and adult life, meanwhile Oprah portrays this novel as something much different into a movie. In the novel Their Eyes Were Watching God, Oprah Winfrey changes the passion portrayed in the novel through a movie screen. Oprah tries to purify Janie relationships and completely remove all symbolism creating a love story changing Zora Neale Hurston story about love. Oprah portrays Janie…

Words 1619 - Pages 7

Their Eyes Were Watching God Research Paper

Eyes Were Watching God,” there are examples of themes that represent the spirit of the Harlem Renaissance, reflecting the era’s focus on racial pride, self-discovery, and resilience. The Harlem Renaissance was a major cultural movement that thrived in the 1920s and 1930s. During that time, art and intellectual creativity were everywhere among African Americans, and the era celebrated black culture, challenged racial stereotypes, and sought to redefine African American identity in the…

Words 702 - Pages 3

Their Eyes Were Watching God Character Analysis

The two versions on, Their Eyes Were Watching God, form a very contrasted view between both Oprah Winfrey and Zora Neale Hurston’s interpretation on the story. The differences greatly outnumber the similarities. The ways contrasted between the two include, the altered relationship between the characters, Janie’s strength increased throughout the movie, the overall message changed the meaning, and the symbols shifted towards other symbols. By changing these factors, Oprah takes the novel’s meaning…

Words 1447 - Pages 6

Their Eyes Were Watching God Research Paper

Lauren Fields John Walker DE English 12/ENGL 245 18 May 2024 An All-Female Classroom’s Comprehension of Their Eyes Were Watching God Reflecting on high school, no other class has affected me quite the same as my senior English literature class. With Mr. Walker and nine young women, this class is reminiscent of the dynamics of the Dead Poets Society (1989), minus the ever-present masculinity. Truthfully, it was the lack of male students that created a compelling class experience. Our conversations…

Words 2643 - Pages 11

Their Eyes Were Watching God Janie's Transformation

In Zora Neale Hurston’s novel “Their Eyes Were Watching God,” the protagonist Janie Crawford undergoes a profound transformation, evolving from a young girl stifled by societal expectations to a woman who embraces her independence. Throughout the course of the text, Janie’s growth is evident as she navigates through various relationships and challenges, ultimately breaking free from the constraints of social norms and gender roles. At the beginning of the novel, Janie is portrayed as a naive and…

Words 345 - Pages 2

Their Eyes Were Watching God Critical Analysis

As we journey through the tale of Janie’s life that Hurston shares with her readers through her novel, Their Eyes Were Watching God, we gain insight on many developed ideas of Harlem throughout it, however also varies from the idea of Harlem to a great extent moreover. Zora Neale Hurston's writing is a reflection of and a departure from the ideas of the Harlem Renaissance. Within the book, Their Eyes Were Watching God, Hurston expresses through the story of Janie’s life and the struggles she endured…

Words 984 - Pages 4

Their Eyes Were Watching God Quotes

everything in their power to remember it. An example of this in the novel “Their Eyes were Watching God” is when Janie leaves her bad relationship with Logan, to be with a man named Jody. She tries very hard to forget all her bad experiences with her ex husband Logan, while being married to Jody. Like the quote states, Janie ( a woman ) is trying to forget everything that she doesn’t want…

Words 474 - Pages 2

GUILLOT Their Eyes Were Watching God Essay

Noah Baudoin Guillot, 3 English III GT 1/29/14 Her Eyes Were Watching God According to a study done by Paul R. Amato, African Americans report lower levels of relationship quality. African American couples are also more likely to end their marriages in divorce. In Hurston’s Their Eyes Were Watching God, all of Janie’s relationships fail due to her need to be presiding. In Janie’s first marriage, the relationship led to failure because Janie had a lack of love for Logan and because Logan did not…

Words 595 - Pages 3

Springtime Symbolism

Both How to Read Literature Like a Professor by Thomas Foster and Their Eyes Were Watching God by Zora Hurston explore the idea that the season of spring is utilized in literature as a symbol for rebirth and renewal. Foster refers to the Christian story of Easter to reinforce his point, pointing out that “ the crucifixion and resurrection come very near the spring equinox, the death of winter and beginning of renewed life” (Foster 191). The fact that the renewal of life occurs just as spring approaches…

Words 399 - Pages 2

Their Eyes Were Watching God Gender Analysis

Concepts of gender inequity and Janie’s attitude towards it run throughout each of her relationships in Their Eyes Were Watching God. Zora Neale Hurston wrote the novel in a very revolutionary time, which lent to the overall tone of the book. Hurston, though unappreciated in life, plowed on, writing during the Harlem Renaissance in controversial ways about controversial topics. Zora Neale Hurston’s novel, Their Eyes Were Watching God, reinforces and demonstrates the idea that women are powerful and…

Words 906 - Pages 4