What Are the Benefits and Problems of Performance-Related Pay Systems for Both Employees and Employers? Essay

Words: 2021
Pages: 9
Open Document
Performance-related pay (PRP) grew during the 1980s and 1990s due to the decline in Payment by Results (PBR) schemes. PRP looked beyond traditional PBR incentives, they reward individual contributions based on performance rather than on effort. These incentive schemes can filter throughout an organisation to motivate manager’s right through to the manual workers.

This essay will try to outline the benefits and drawbacks of the PRP method for employers and employees using case study examples particularly the education sector where PRP has been or could be effective. We shall also investigate the numerous forms of PRP and whether they are successful payment methods. PRP can be used for both Individuals and Groups, therefore …show more content…
Another problem put forward for employers is that measuring an employee’s performance can be an arduous task. This issue has been discussed with the recent moves by the government to promote PRP for nurses, doctors and teachers. “All these groups fear that the difficulties associated with measuring their performance will lead to subjective and possibly unfair judgements being made by their assessors” (Journalists of the BBC, 1994, cited in Torrington & Hall, 1995: 609). These specific types of employment are particularly difficult to measure, for example the education sector, although you can measure performance on grades the difficulty is that not every school is the same. All schools have varying class sizes and some are located in poorer regions so you can expect performance of these students vary; therefore the teacher cannot really be measured on the students grades compared to schools across the country.

The process of performance appraisal is subjective, therefore prejudice may occur, and judgements maybe formed through what is known as the ‘Halo Effect’, where we “draw a general impression about an individual based on a single characteristic” (Redman & Wilkinson, 1999: 38), another factor the employees could be subjected to is the ‘Contrast Effect’, where the assessor makes comparisons between other employees they have encountered.

A problem that
Show More

Related Documents: What Are the Benefits and Problems of Performance-Related Pay Systems for Both Employees and Employers? Essay

Essay on Employment and Individual-based Plans

manager/supervisor, team, customer What are the six guidelines for successful appraisal interviews. Performance ratings must be job-related. Employees must be given a written copy of their job standards in advance of appraisals. Managers who conduct the appraisal must be able to observe the behavior they are rating. Supervisors must be trained to use the appraisal form correctly. Appraisals should be discussed openly with employees and counseling or corrective guidance offered…

Words 2480 - Pages 10

Essay on Compensation & Benefits

AND BENEFITS Compensation and Benefits in the Twenty-first Century Abstract Team platinum will explore compensation and benefits in the 21st century. Any review of total compensation must include the crucial areas of health and retirement benefits and financial compensation, as well as discuss the implications of pivotal changes in the market and demographics which impact organizations and overall performance management issues. There are several different compensation and benefit strategies…

Words 6147 - Pages 25

Trends and Challenges in Human Resources Essay

existing and future challenges when working with employees such as diversity issues, turnover, health and safety, and benefits. These challenges will change as employees become more skillful and want more out of the company they work for to make them satisfied in the areas of pay and benefits. In this paper, reviewed will be the impact on HR regarding existing and future trends, existing and future challenges, advantages of turnover, performance appraisals, and safety and health in the workplace…

Words 3757 - Pages 16

Essay about Chapter 11 Strategic Pay Plans

Chapter 11 – Strategic Pay Plans THE STRATEGIC IMPORTANCE OF TOTALEMPLOYMENT REWARDS Total employment rewards: integrated package of all rewards (monetary and non-monetary, extrinsic and intrinsic) gained by employees arising from their employment. Encompass everything that employees value in the employment relationship. There are a variety of models to define the elements of total employee rewards. See below: WorldatWork conceptualized the total rewards model within 3 categories: 1) Compensation…

Words 5024 - Pages 21

Staffing: Human Resource Management and Employees Essay

in both products and service. In addition, an organization must respond to change effectively in order to remain competitive. The right staff can carry an organization through a period of change and ensure its future success. Because of the importance of hiring and maintaining a committed and competent staff, effective human resource management is crucial to the success of all organizations. Human resource management (HRM), or staffing, is the…

Words 4923 - Pages 20

Essay about 3prm Cipd

PRMPRM 1.1 Describe at least two purposes of performance management and their relationships to business objectives. Performance management is about creating a culture that encourages the continuous improvement of business processes and of individuals’ skills, behaviour and contribution. It is a repetitive process that is continually reviewed and is both strategic and integrated. It is about broad issues and long-term goals and integrated by linking various aspects of the business, people…

Words 1553 - Pages 7

Hrm Mid Essay

understand the human resources available to them, determine what human resources they will need, decide how to best use the human resources at their disposal, and develop a system to ensure human resources needs are sufficiently covered. 1. Identify both opportunities and problems that can affect your HRM plan. Consider the business environment, upcoming projects, potential drops in revenue, and anything else that may affect how many employees you’ll need and be able to hire. 2. Consider your current…

Words 5633 - Pages 23

BUS 8204 Final Case Essay

Q1) Please design a legally defensible selection process for BBI that would maximize solid hires i.e. high performing employees and ensure greater success in retaining engineers? Justify your design. Brown and Brown Inc. is not in good shape. After analyzing BBI's human resource (HR) practices there is no surprise that they are experiencing difficulties with recruitment and retention. Their struggles were made evident to management when the firm experienced a turnover rate of 25% last year. BBI's…

Words 3838 - Pages 16

HR Paper

regulations, the rapid changes of technology, and the economy of both the United States and the world. First, we will examine the legal implications of human resource management. We will follow that by discussing job analysis and human resource planning. Next, we will look at the recruitment process. Then we will look at the selection process. Following that, we will examine the training and development process. Next, we will discuss performance appraisals. After that, we will look over direct and indirect…

Words 6280 - Pages 26

Current Trends In Performance Management

FINAL RESEARCH PAPER What are Current Trends in Performance Management? Unit 5 Williemae McSwain by Kaplan University GB520: Strategic Human Resource Management for Professor: Steven Cates July 15, 2014 Authors Note This paper was prepared for GB520: Strategic Human Resources Management section 02N, taught by Professor Cates. FINAL RESEARCH PAPER TABLE OF CONTENTS Performance Management……………………………………………………………………..3 What is Performance Management Trends? ............…

Words 2462 - Pages 10