What Criteria Can Be Used For Evaluating An Article

Submitted By Thiti-Phiriyayotha
Words: 1207
Pages: 5
Open Document
Writing a Critical Review

What criteria can be used for evaluating an article?
The following criteria are useful:
• the timeliness of the article
• the degree to which the article makes an original contribution
• the logic of the view put forward
• the validity of the evidence put forward
• the theoretical framework used
Is the framework valid?
Has the framework been applied appropriately?
• the methodology used
Is the methodology appropriate?
Is the methodological approach explained clearly?
Does the methodological approach have any weaknesses?
Is the study sufficiently comprehensive and thorough?
Is anything important omitted in the research?
• the findings
Are the findings presented and described clearly and fully?
Do the findings seem sound?
Could the data be interpreted in another way?
Do/does the author(s) account for everything in the data or do they ignore something that might be important?
• the validity of the conclusions
• the thoroughness with which the article treats the topic
• its value compared to that of other articles on the topic
• the appropriateness of the article for the intended audience
• the extent to which it might satisfy the specific needs of a specific user. Evaluation
Evaluation is the most important part in writing a critical review. Evaluation involves stating whether you agree or disagree with what the author says or has done. You will want to use the literature to support your views.
Evaluation can be described as implicit and explicit. Explicit evaluation would take the form of a list of questions. For example:
I will review this article by focusing on the following questions.
•
•

To what extent do the authors contribute to current thought on Second
Language Acquisition (SLA) pedagogy?
Are the authors’ propositions feasible within overseas SLA classrooms? Implicit evaluation is less direct. The following section on Linguistic Features of Writing a Critical Review contains language that evaluates the text.
You need to remember to locate and analyse the author’s argument when you are writing your critical review. For example, you need to locate the authors’ view of classroom pedagogy as presented in the book / article and not present a critique of views of classroom pedagogy in general.
Linguistic features of writing a critical review
Summary language
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•

•
•
•
•
•
•

This article / book is divided into two / three parts. First...
While the title might suggest...
Title is the first / second volume in the series Title, edited by...The books / articles in this series address...
The second / third claim is based on...
The author challenges the notion that...
The author tries to find a more middle ground / make more modest claims... The article / book begins with a short historical overview of...
Numerous authors have recently suggested that...(see Author, Year;
Author, Year). Author would also be once such author. With his / her argument that...
The author’s book / article examines the...To do this, the author first...
The author develops / suggests a theoretical / pedagogical model to…
This book / article positions itself firmly within the field of...
The author in a series of subtle arguments, indicates that he / she...
The author asks "..."
Topic, as the author points out, can be viewed as...

•
•
•
•
•
•

•
•

•

In this recent contribution to the field of...this British author...
As a leading author in the field of...
This book / article nicely contributes to the field of...and complements other work by this author...
The second / third part of...provides / questions / asks the reader...
Title is intended to encourage students / researchers to...
The approach taken by the author provides the opportunity to examine...in a qualitative / quantitative research framework that nicely complements... The author notes / claims that state support / a focus on pedagogy / the
Show More

Related Documents: What Criteria Can Be Used For Evaluating An Article

Essay about Nrs-433v Week 3 Research Critique, Part 1

help@mindblows.us NRS-433V Week 3 Research Critique, Part 1 Introduction to Nursing Research – Theory, Design, and Sampling Prepare a critical analysis of a qualitative study focusing on the problem statement, study purpose, research question, literature review, and theoretical framework. This can be one of the selected articles from your previous literature review or a new peer-reviewed article. The completed analysis should be 1,000-1,250 words and should connect to your identified practice problem…

Words 4239 - Pages 17

Babatunde Island Welcome Back Center Summary

Guide to Strategic Planning: Environmental Analysis – The Rhode Island Welcome Back Center In this guide, we have introduced the organization to help think about future direction. Also, we discussed the importance of preparing to plan. Therefore, the environmental assessment sets the tone for strategic planning (Zuckerman, 2016). In this section of the guide, the RIWBC board will start to think about the critical question that addresses the internal and external capacities that the organization must…

Words 1354 - Pages 6

Introductory to Online Learning Essay

assignment? • What are the elements of the assignment? • How will the assignment be graded? • What are other considerations for completing the assignment well? The purpose of this worksheet is to guide you in “decoding” any GCU assignment. Assignment Instructions: Review the sample syllabus and sample rubric under the questions below. Then, provide…

Words 1034 - Pages 5

Assessment 1 Essay

Assessment 1: Literature review (30%). Word count: 2000 Due: 27th March 2015 at 5pm through turn it in. Submission Information This assessment is weighted at 30% . Students will submit a literature review which explores a topic of relevance as outlined below. Learning Outcomes Completing this assessment item will help you achieve the following learning outcomes: SWK2104 Online Unit Plan 2015 3 1 . Describe development, including biosocial, cognitive and psychological as an ongoing set of processes…

Words 599 - Pages 3

Child Abuse and Nurturing Environment Essay

Assignment 03.08 Review & Critical Thinking Review Questions 1. Explain the different forms of child abuse? Include Shaken Baby Syndrome in your response. Physical abuse, emotional abuse, sexual abuse, and neglect. Physical, violence toward a child by a parent or other caregiver. Emotional, causes the victim to feel worthless and rejected. Neglect, parents do not care for their child’s physical, emotional, educational or disciplinary needs. 2. What types of physical care must a parent provide an…

Words 330 - Pages 2

Critical Review of Experimental Research - Showing Off in Humans: Male Generosity as a Mating Signal Essay

Student Number: 129073174 (as shown on student ID card) Programme: BSc(Hons) Psychology (e.g BHSc (Hons) Occupational Therapy) Module Tutor: Nathalie Noret Module Code: 3PY344 Module Title: Statistics and Psychology 3 Assignment Title: Critical Review First Attempt *please delete as appropriate Declaration of Academic Integrity Please complete before submitting your assignment: By entering an ‘x’ in the box above, I confirm that I have read and understood the University regulations…

Words 4059 - Pages 17

Essay A Day in the Life of Alex Sander

successfully rebranded two of Landon’s skin care products in the United States. Alex has created a winning enviornment at the Toiletries Division by applying very high standards to everyone, and often pushing his staff to the limits. A recent 360 degree review has revealed that Alex’s strong drive to succeed has come at a cost, as his staff are highly disenchanted by his iron-fisted ways. (Alex has since discounted the importance of the these findings.) Sam Glass, Alex’s direct manager, is one of the…

Words 2235 - Pages 9

Airbrushing College Essay

a range of surfaces, in a range of styles. The two key tools for airbrushing are the gun and the compressor. And while you might think that the gun is all that matters, that isn’t true. As any airbrush compressor buying guide will tell you, the right compressor is also a critical element in achieving the right results. So with that in mind, let’s look at what’s important to look for in choosing an airbrush compressor.Intro-Kit-IW100 Some good questions to ask when evaluating…

Words 519 - Pages 3

Bsbrsk501 Essay examples

Assessment Tasks Assessor Guide BSBRSK501A: Manage risk Copyright ownership: United Business Services (Aust) Pty Ltd. This book is copyright protected under the Berne Convention. All rights reserved. No reproduction without permission. This book is protected by copyright and may not be reproduced or copied either in part or in whole nor used for financial gain without the express approval in writing of the owner (United Business Services (Aust) Pty Ltd) of the copyright. United Business Services…

Words 8783 - Pages 36

1 Program Schedule Standards1 CCB Change Essay

1. Program schedule standards 1. CCB Change Control Board 2. CR Change Request 3. Critical Path The longest group of activities in a project plan which must be completed on time for the project to meet its due date 4. DDI Design, Develop and Implement 5. Proposal Response to RFP submitted by Xerox 6. PMBOK A Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge 7. PMO Project Management Office led by Xerox 8. PMP Project Management Plan 9. QM Quality Management 10. RFP Request for Proposal; document…

Words 483 - Pages 2