Essay on Whistle: Ethics and Health Care Fraud

Submitted By dfguzman1407
Words: 685
Pages: 3
Open Document
Blowing the Whistle on Healthcare Fraud: Should I?

Diego Guzman

Professor Al Williams
MAN 2010
February 21, 2010

Blowing the Whistle on Health Care Fraud : Should I ?
A whistle blower is defined as an individual who raises a concern about wrongdoing occurring in an organization or body of people, usually this person would be from that organization. This article brings to light the ordeal that individuals, specifically nurses, in the healthcare industry face when contemplating the possibility of whistleblowing. Unfortunately in healthcare, fraud is very easy to cover especially when considering that there are thousands of claims processed on a daily basis. Due to the high number of claims, violators also assume that they are not making a dent in the insurance companies since they have plenty of money as it is. Are these assumptions correct? The National Healthcare Anti-fraud Association estimates a loss of $56.7 to $170billion annually. The numbers are shocking and perhaps yet more eye opening when recognizing that as taxpayers we are also loosing an enormous amount of money due to these fraudulent claims. A doctor may for whatever reason feel compelled to “up code” a service that was provided or even bill for a service that was not performed. As the person of highest authority within the organization, the risks of loosing your job or causing more wrong than good are reasons that would refrain a nurse from whistleblowing. Depending on the severity of the case, possibilities of threats against self and family, and psychological and emotional stress may be inevitable. Although for many the consequences may be sufficient to consider taking the unethical approach of staying quiet, in the end those that are not loyal deal with significant amounts of guilt and ultimately feel they suffer most than those that have dealt with the consequences of whistleblowing. In the end, the nurse’s duty is to familiarize themselves with regulations regarding billing and then if they witness unethical acts, proceed to weigh the pros and cons when considering whistleblowing. From our text we learned that, “Ethics requires courage and it is up to the person to decide what is right and wrong.” In our text we are given the example of the situation between Coca Cola and Pepsi Company. An executive secretary from Coca Cola’s company headquarters contacted Pepsi to offer confidential samples for a price. Instead of accepting her offer, Pepsi decided to contact Coca Cola about the situation, which then resulted in the secretary being fired as well as the FBI becoming involved. Pepsi took the ethical approach when handling the situation and therefore was
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on Whistle: Ethics and Health Care Fraud

whistleblowing paper

Whistle Blowing Paper Libra Butler Law and Ethics 500 Dr. Andrea N.Brvenik January 25, 2015 Whistle blowing is a way to offer a solution to resolve certain situations. It releases…

Words 642 - Pages 3

business ethics Essay

Adms 3360 York University Ethics Course Exam review Chapter 2 and 3 1.Corporate Social Responsibility: What is corporate social responsibility (CSR)? Is CSR good business? Social Investment: What is the field of social investing? What are social investment criteria? Social/Ethical Auditing Learning Objectives: understand CSR theory and debate, evaluate CSR criteria, formulate your own position on CSR. The Central Focus of CSR Theory: What obligations does a firm have toward society? CSR…

Words 2189 - Pages 9

HSA 515 Dealing with Fraud Essay

Dealing with Fraud Demetrice Armwood Dr. James Coon, Jr HSA 515 Health Care Policy, Law, and Ethics June 16, 2013 As the Chief Nursing Officer of the state’s largest Obstetric Health Care Center, this author is responsible for complaints regarding fraudulent behavior in the center. The purpose of this report is to (1) evaluate how the Healthcare Qui tam affects health care organizations, (2) provide four examples of Qui Tam cases that exist in a variety…

Words 1967 - Pages 8

Do They Healthcare About Us?

Do They Healthcare About Us? MGT 282 Ms. Stark November 21, 2011 Washington 1 There are many ethical issues surrounding the American healthcare industry. Health care insurance is meant to provide adequate financial service to support a person’s medical needs. In some instances these needs are not always met by insurance providers. For instance, a working class citizen with a standard HMO policy could be denied assistance upon diagnosis of a terminal illness such as cancer. There are…

Words 1074 - Pages 5

Hcmg730 Full Course (All Discussion, Reflections, Case Analysis and Final Assessment) Essay

the use of the following documents- advance directives, living will and durable power of attorney for health care. Refer to appendix E in the textbook which includes examples of these documents. You have been approached by an elderly relative seeking information about her options in planning for future medical care in the event she is unable to communicate her wishes or otherwise direct her care. How would you respond? What options should you provide? Weekly Reflection Week 4 Reflect on the topics…

Words 2080 - Pages 9

Essay on Legal notification

Understanding Dismissal Legalities 8 IV a. Memorandum for Record of Ethical Stand 10 V. Whistle Blower Opportunities, Obligations, Protections, Benefits 11 VI. PharmaCARE and Environmental Stewardship 12 VII. The Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA) 13 VIII. References 17 Abstract Workplace ethics are definable differently according to who you or the leader really are. Who you really…

Words 3814 - Pages 16

Assignment: Privacy and Ethical Issue Essay

7 Stakeholders Actions – Case Two 8 Personal Actions 8 Personal Actions – Case One 8 Personal Actions – Case Two 8 Conclusion 9 References 10 Appendix A 12 Appendix B 18 PRIVACY AND SURVEILLANCE ETHICS INTRODUCTION Privacy and surveillance ethics are apparent in many different areas. Privacy is an individual’s right to control his or her own information. Surveillance is a method in which has the ability to breach an individual’s privacy. It is the monitoring of people…

Words 4554 - Pages 19

Essay about Week 3 Assignment 1 04 20 15

Week 3 Assignment 1: Whistleblowing and Sarbanes-Oxley Act Michelle M. Webb Dr. Boneita Campbell LEG500 Law, Ethics, and Corporate Governance April 20, 2015 . Week 3 Assignment 1: Whistleblowing and Sarbanes-Oxley Act Who are Whistleblowers and what do they do? Could you be a Whistleblower? There are several definitions for the term whistleblower. The most accurate and significant definitions to the subject of this paper are the definition given by the Black’s Law Dictionary and the one…

Words 1067 - Pages 5

Fina 315 Notes Essay

Personal and Professional Ethics While there may not exist any universal definition for personal or professional ethics, ethics reflects the concern for the well being of our fellow man. Ethical principles are not absolute, nor carved in stone, as ideas and beliefs will develop and change over time as the views of society change. What is considered acceptable ethical practices in one country today may be considered unethical or even illegal in another country. As noted in the attached document…

Words 4209 - Pages 17

Assignment 2 Essay

Assignment 2: Employment-At-Will Doctrine LEG 500-Law, Ethics and Corp. Governance August 3, 2014 Employment-at-will is a legal rule that developed in the nineteenth century, giving employers unfettered power to “dismiss their employees at will for good cause, for no cause, or even for cause morally wrong, without being thereby guilty of a legal wrong” (Halbert, 2012). Likewise, an employee is free to leave a job at any time for whatever reason with no adverse legal consequences…

Words 1545 - Pages 7