Why Is Christopher Columbus Bad

Words: 414

Pages: 2

Open Document

Christopher Columbus is neither a villain nor a hero, he is a person in history whose actions can be reflected on and learned from. Judging if Columbus was a good or bad person based on modern values and beliefs would lead to a biased conclusion; Columbus “lived in earlier times [and] w[as] different from us [people today]; [he] faced different circumstances, and [he] had different views on many issues” (Perlman 6). The definitions of good and bad when Columbus explored the New World were different from modern perspectives; the people who lived in 1492 might have considered the explorer as a brave pioneer. There is an equal chance he was viewed as a merciless invader, but neither can be determined as fact. Whether Columbus was good or bad depends on perspective—different people will have different answers—so rather than …show more content…
Columbus’s discovery of America is often considered an act of greatness, while his treatment of Native Americans is often considered as an act of cruelty. But how Columbus’s actions are interpreted is irrelevant. The explorer’s actions do not solidify his title of hero or villain. Instead of focusing on the question of whether Columbus is a hero or a villain, he should be considered as a historical figure that modern society can learn from. Although historic figures such as Columbus do not necessarily “teach us [people today] particular lessons,” they can still “tell us [them] how we [they] might live in the world” (Wood 6). People of the past did not exist to teach what is right or wrong, which makes the character of Columbus irrelevant to what can be gained from evaluating his life. Whether or not Columbus was a hero or a villain does not change how he impacted the world and helped shape

Christopher Columbus: Cruel Or Necessary?

Some people think that Christopher Columbus was a great man, well not me, not this piece. Columbus was a cruel,and harsh man. He was violent, and mean. Yet everyone loved him.This is why Columbus Day should not be celebrated. He was unjust, and unfair for no reason. This is why Columbus Day is useless and has no meaning. Columbus was a man who came from England. He judged people by the color of their skin, or where they came from. He had native americans killed for their looks. They did nothing…

Words 460 - Pages 2

Christopher Columbus Research Paper

Christopher Columbus As Christopher Columbus leaves his ancient history behind there are many reasons why he is or is not a hero towards children today. Today Columbus is celebrated on October 13 of every year. This celebration includes “the discovery of the New World by Christopher Columbus in 1492.” (Google Dic) This paper will argue why Christopher Columbus is and is not a hero towards children today. Christopher Columbus is presented as a hero towards children today because of the sacrifices…

Words 518 - Pages 3

American me Essay

DBQ Columbus: Villain or Hero? What do you consider evil? I think that killing millions of people is evil and taking someone’s land from them is evil. I feel that Christopher Columbus was a fraud and he was nothing but a cold-hearted evil man. His so-called “holiday” should be abolished and a new one called First Americans Day. I feel that if America wants to represent themself as a free country that Christopher Columbus should not be recognized as a hero. I think that Christopher Columbus…

Words 484 - Pages 2

What Did Christopher Columbus Do For America

What did Christopher Columbus do for America and its people? What percentage of America did Christopher Columbus affect in a bad way and think, were the deaths of some early Americans worth it to make that unsophisticated land one of the futures most powerful nations in the world? Christopher Columbus was clearly a hero, he found America, fought for it and traveled across the sea and did what had to be done to claim and create a separate nation for his country. One reason Columbus is a hero is that…

Words 408 - Pages 2

Why Is Christopher Columbus Not A Great Hero

Christopher Columbus Was Not A Great Hero Do you think Christopher Columbus was a great hero or was he not? I think that Christopher Columbus was not a great hero because he discovered America by an error/accident. He was looking for a new trade route to India and found The New World (America) but he did not know this, he still thought that he found India. In The New World he found that there were Natives living there but he referred to them as Indians because he thought he had made it to India…

Words 275 - Pages 2

Why Is Christopher Columbus A Hero

"CHRISTOPHER COLUMBOUS : HERO OR VILLIAN?" By: Joshua Mills West Limestone History 1st period Was Christopher Columbus a hero or was he evil? Many think of him as being a hero because he found what would soon be America. Actually many people don't know much of him. He discovered American which opened a new home for people but it also could be looked at as a new way for people to be homeless or dead. Why could he be considered a hero? Why could he be considered evil? Could he be both by accident…

Words 498 - Pages 2

Columbus Day Research Paper

Obviously, Columbus Day should continue to be celebrated throughout our country. One reason why Columbus Day should still be celebrated is because Columbus Day is one of America’s oldest celebrated holidays. Columbus Day has been memorialized since 1792. It would be quite difficult to get rid of Americas first celebrated past times. Another reason why Columbus Day should be celebrated throughout America is because the Europeans brought new art, music, science, and other components of their culture…

Words 207 - Pages 1

Advantages Of Columbus

In 1492 Columbus sailed the ocean blue and discovered the Americas. Columbus set out to find a quicker route to India but in the process instead found the Americas. But why did people believe the world was flat? During this time period maps, atlases, charts and other navigational technology were roughly handmade based on where people had traveled to. The tools and technology of this time period were not always completely accurate. Unlike today's technology, which is far more advanced, we are able…

Words 807 - Pages 4

Why We Should Celebrate Columbus Day Be Abolished

America has been celebrating Columbus Day, the holiday that honors Christopher Columbus for discovering America. He was a Portuguese explorer, who during his exploration of the New World was sponsored by the queen Isabell of Spain. Because the Columbus’s men killed thousands of Native American, the day has good meaning for some, and bad ones for others. So, many people wonder if America should keep celebrating Columbus Day or not. Even though it was because of Christopher Columbus that America got colonized…

Words 976 - Pages 4

Christopher Columbus Research Paper

The Truth about Christopher Columbus On the 12th of October in 1492, an Italian and possibly Jewish explorer made a contract with the Spanish king and queen. In this contract, the businessman promised to sail across the Atlantic Ocean to find a new trade route to Asia (Carle 107). However, instead of finding the East Indies, the captain and his 90 men found the islands of the Bahamas. When this man and his crew returned to Spain, they were named heroes. This hero, who was the first European in 600…

Words 1250 - Pages 5