why they stayed Essay

Submitted By lynnloo2
Words: 2897
Pages: 12
Open Document
CITE - Why did free blacks stay in the south? http://www.theroot.com/views/why-did-free-blacks-stay-old-south?
Like most of you, I suspect, I was raised to believe three things about slavery in America: first, that slaves who gained their freedom did so by escaping on the Underground Railroad to the North; second, that all of the black people living in the South before and during the Civil War were slaves; and third, that all of the free black people in pre-Civil War America lived in the North. If any of us knew anything at all with certainty about the history of slavery in our country, it was these three things, right?
But in last week's column, we learned that, quite surprisingly, this is not the way it was. In fact, the Free Negro population (to use the contemporary term for them) in the South before the Civil War actually outnumbered that in the North by a substantial margin. Of the 488,070 free African-American people in the United States in 1860 -- 11 percent of the total black population -- according to the federal census, some 35,766 more lived in the slave-holding South than in the North, as analyzed in Ira Berlin's magisterial study, Slaves Without Masters, and more recently in Eva Sheppard Wolf's graceful book Race and Liberty in the New Nation: Emancipation in Virginia From the Revolution to Nat Turner's Rebellion. Just as remarkably, the vast majority of these free Southern black people stayed put in the Confederate states even during the Civil War. How was this possible?
As you can imagine, the comments that last week's column received were wide-ranging. "White people back then made the Freeman's life a living hell. It was almost better for them to be slaves than to be free," one reader responded. Another took a rather different view: "All the talk about slavery all these years and now we are finding out it wasn't nearly as bad … a lot of the blacks were actually free." But remember, while almost half a million free black people before the Civil War is no insignificant number, 89 percent of all African Americans in 1860 remained enslaved.
Moreover, the plight of the Free Negroes, as I pointed out last week, could be quite perilous, leading some people in places such as New Orleans and Pensacola to flee just before and during the Civil War to Mexico, Haiti and Cuba. Some who were living in border cities such as Baltimore chose to move to Northern cities such as Philadelphia and New York, only to return after the War was won.
Still another reader points out, with a great deal of common sense, that given the fact that Free Negroes were sometimes given land by their masters upon being granted their freedom, we shouldn't be surprised to learn these facts: "I'm not really sure why it's so confusing," this reader added, "moving is hard." And moving away from loved ones, whether slave or free, is even harder. I think this was true in the case of my own freed ancestors, on two of my own family lines, living for about a century in the slave state of Virginia (and from 1823 on another line) rather than resettling in the North. Ira Berlin helps us to understand why the vast majority of these former slaves stayed in the slave states.
So, Why Did They Stay?
One of the most important reasons Free Negroes stayed in the South, Berlin suggests, was uncertainty: They couldn't be so sure things would be better for them in the North. In many cases they were right, especially in states that restricted the admission of free blacks, among them Ohio, Iowa, Indiana and Illinois (the last two in their state constitutions).
Interestingly, an antebellum case from Massachusetts, Roberts v. Boston (1849), upholding segregation in Boston's public schools, was cited by the U.S. Supreme Court in its dreaded 1896 opinion reinforcing Jim Crow segregation, Plessy v. Ferguson. Even though the Massachusetts decision was later overruled by legislative action, the point was made. "In the North," Berlin writes, "blacks were despised
Show More

Related Documents: why they stayed Essay

Valley Forge Dbq Analysis

December of 1777-June 1778, in Valley Forge, Pennsylvania was Washington’s winter camp, which was a difficult place to live in. Would you have stayed? I would have stayed in Valley Forge to be in Washington’s army because Washington was getting help, there were a lot of people sick, but not dying, and the conditions are poor but there is spirit of alacrity. People in Valley Forge were either sick or dying, but more were getting sick than they were dying. So, 3,989 out of 8,000 which is 50% of…

Words 220 - Pages 1

Explain Why Did Daisy Stay With Tom In The Great Gatsby

In the novel The Great Gatsby, some argue about why Daisy stayed with Tom and did not leave him for Gatsby. Tom and Daisy stay together because of social status, their child together, and because Daisy actually did love Tom, regardless of what she said. Daisy is the cousin of the narrator, Nick Carraway. She was married to Tom Buchanan, a polo player who was born into money. Before Daisy married Tom, she was “in love” with a man by the name of Jay Gatsby. Gatsby was sent off to war and did not come…

Words 294 - Pages 2

Valley Forge Dbq Research Paper

Would you have quit or stayed being a soldier at Valley Forge? Even though people were dying and getting sick, having to sleep on the floor where the huts were made out of sticks and mud and not having a bed,have no blankets, and no food? But would you have stayed to save your country and family? Valley Forge was were the soldiers were staying at. A lot of them were dying and getting sick in just a few months. There would be no food, blankets, shoes, and clothes. They would freeze. But they would…

Words 371 - Pages 2

Essay about Christine Tiernan Quantitative Homework

paths and rates, and turnover (exit) rates. Sales Department (Full-time) 50% of the sales department stayed the same it was no changes 10% of the full-time transferred to a part-time position 5% of the full-time was promoted to an Assistant Sales Manager 0% of the full-time was promoted to Regional Sales Manager 35% exited the organization Summary: The Company has a lot of employees that stayed in their present position. Either individuals got demoted or decide to go to part time positions. The…

Words 722 - Pages 3

Valley Forge Dbq Analysis

staying loyal to fight. So if you had been a soldier at Washington’s army would you have quit? I would stay at Valley Forge because, only 15% of the people died, there's also help coming from the Congressional Committee, and Dr. Waldo suffered but he stayed loyal and helped other surgeons care for sick soldiers. There are a lot of sick people, but there are not a lot of dying people. In document A it states that 3,989 people were sick, which is about 50 percent, But the percent of people getting sick…

Words 515 - Pages 3

Explain Why I Want To Be A Nurse

the Nursing program I am supposed to answer the question “why I want to be a nurse”. I should be able to answer this question very quickly yet I cannot. I cannot answer this quickly because there are so many reasons that I long to be a nurse. I did not grow up knowing that nursing was my calling. For a long time, I thought I would be a teacher, and while I do enjoy helping children I feel I have more to offer the world. To help explain why I want to be a nurse I will share just part of my story.…

Words 649 - Pages 3

Analysis Of My Scary Story 'The Burning'

cabin. The teenager cried, “I heard he’s coming!” The other teenager cried, “Let’s get out of here!” While the teenagers ran out to his cabin quickly, he came inside to his cabin, and the teenagers threw the baseball to his window. He smelled and stayed, “Did I smell gasoline?” Then, the ball crashed to his window and it hitted the light post of candle. He screamed, “Ahhh! I’m on fire! I’m burning!” He’s burning in the cabin, he opened the door quickly and he fell down and roll down and he’s injured…

Words 502 - Pages 3

The Influence Of Messengers In Shakespeare's Romeo And Juliet

Romeo undelivered, he gives this as a reason why he was not able to fulfill his mission. “Suspecting that we both were in a house/Where the infectious pestilence did reign,/Sealed up the doors and would not let us forth,/So that my speed to Mantua was stayed.” (5.2.9-12) When the Friar’s messenger explained that his speed was “stayed” because of an infectious sickness, or “pestilence”, he is making an allusion to a higher power, fate. The usage of “stayed” suggests that something was causing the delay…

Words 399 - Pages 2

The Drugs And John Smith Research Paper

few hours before the party in the mall. After an hour of being there, a friend of their school went to the bathroom, his name was Peter, he got back with an ounce of Medical Marijuana. Some of the students got away from that place, but some others stayed.…

Words 361 - Pages 2

Character Analysis: Of Mice And Men By John Steinbeck

The book I read of hers and it was a great book. Tuck is my character from my novel that I read. He’s one of the main characters in the novel that I read. Why did I pick this person from my story? I picked him because he had the most interaction in this novel and he was the best character in book. Tuck was scared because he didn’t want anybody to find out about the water and he had a real good feeling that they will find it soon enough. Now tuck is comfortable because he thought they would find…

Words 561 - Pages 3