Wounded Knee Essay

Submitted By zacharyj7
Words: 1552
Pages: 7
Open Document
Wounded Knee
Very few Americans are aware of what truly happened in their history. They may have learned the textbook version of how white European settlers voyaged across the Atlantic to be free from their former governments and begin a new life based on freedom. Americans also probably learned that this country has had its fair share of issues such as slavery, encroaching on Native American lands, racism however there is one history that is severely shadowed by other major issues. The dark history of how the Native Americans were treated is a story not known by most Americans. There are always two sides to every story and unfortunately textbooks created by white American’s paint over this issue and make it seem not nearly as horrific as it was. If one wants to learn what truly happened, one must step aside from the textbook version of the history, and dive into a non-fiction account of what happened. Dee Brown’s, ‘Bury My Heart At Wounded Knee’, is an incredible yet horrifying story showing many accounts from different tribes of what truly happened in Native American history when white settlers encroached on their land. Although the textbook version of Native American history told by white settlers touches on some issues such as manifest destiny, Brown’s portrayal differs significantly as his story shows true accounts of what Native American’s faced from their viewpoint such as countless lies and deceit by the American government, genocide, and ethnic cleansing.
Manifest destiny played a very important role for white settlers and their conquest through America. The term defined is “a policy of imperialism rationalized as inevitable (as if granted by God)” by prinston.edu. This of course was completely irrational but since this country was based on Christian values, manifest destiny was somehow rational to European settlers. European settlers did not have the right to take the Native American’s land however because of manifest destiny they somehow justified taking land that wasn’t theirs. European settlers truly believed that the land between the Atlantic and the Pacific was theirs and not the Native American’s. Their insatiable appetite for precious minerals lead to the mistreat of the Native American’s land which was somehow justified by manifest destiny. It is hard to imagine another human treating another human in this day and age, but it happened not too long ago. Red Cloud, a head chief, once said “The white man was raised over the great waters, and his land is over there.” 1 Red Chief was correct in that his land belonged to the Native American’s and that the white settlers land was over the Atlantic. Native American’s had a sense of sharing but that was because the sense of land ownership was not there until European settlers came. Then Red Cloud went on to say, “Since they crossed the sea, I have given them room. There are now white people all about me. I have but a small spot of land left.” 2 This was the sentiment of all the tribes, however somehow the white settlers justified it.
Even recently, this still seems to occur. Even in the 1970’s and 1980’s, the issue of manifest destiny came up once again. This was just a mere 30 years ago. The United States wanted access to rich deposits of coal in the Hopi and Navaho reservations deep within the four corners. The Navaho resisted such acts of invading their lands which were a result of continuous push backs from white settlers on which this country was founded upon. Congress was in agreement with private companies that wanted these minerals which of course is greed once again. The United States passed the Hopi-Navajo Land Settlement Act of 1974 which divided land between the Hopi and the Navaho. These tribes didn’t have a sense of ownership. The United States government decided to split this land which created a conflict between the Hopi and the Navaho. This brought many hardships to these two tribes in which people were deported from their sacred grounds all
Show More

Related Documents: Wounded Knee Essay

The Wounded Knee Massacre

actions. As Americans were looking for a quick way to make money, Indians were quickly pushed off their land into smaller reserves. This lead to numerous clashes between Indians and American forces. One big clash that could have been avoided was the Wounded Knee massacre. This massacre cannot be blamed solely on the American Army, it can be blamed on the…

Words 830 - Pages 4

Essay Wounded Knee

On December 29, 1890, almost 300 Miniconjou Sioux Indians were killed at Wounded Knee Creek in the Pine Ridge Oglala Sioux Reservation in South Dakota. Of the Miniconjou killed over half were women and children. In retrospect, the Battle of Wounded Knee was the product of 400 years of greed, racism and conflict. This long turmoil between the whites and Native Americans was aggravated by 40 years of betrayal, lies, misunderstandings, aggression, and fear from both the White Man and the Sioux. Forty…

Words 2505 - Pages 11

Wounded Knee Massacre

The massacre done to the Sioux at Wounded Knee was unwarranted and a terrible tragedy that the US soldiers are to blame for because they lacked communication and patience. The things done over this time period resembled that of a genocide, the US government targeted the Native American people…

Words 815 - Pages 4

Wounded Knee Research Paper

Wounded Knee: Preserving Tradition and Fighting for Equality A common misconception regarding cultures and ethnic groups is that all individuals belonging to one share the same opinions – however, this could not be further from the truth. Native Americans in North America are one example; they should not be regarded to a homogeneous group because they are like any other culture, race, or religion composed of individual people with his or her own set of beliefs. The occupation of Wounded Knee, on…

Words 1303 - Pages 6

Wounded Knee Research Paper

The Wounded Knee Massacre: A Tragic Symbol of American Indian Struggles Introduction The Tragic event at Wounded Knee Creek on December 29, 1890, became a very dark symbol of the everlasting conflict between the US and Native American tribes throughout American history. On this day, over 150 Lakota Sioux, including men, women, and children, were killed by the U.S. Army's 7th Cavalry Regiment. By exploring the events leading up to the massacre, more specifically the Ghost Dance movement, and recognizing…

Words 1293 - Pages 6

Wounded Knee Massacre Analysis

The Wounded Knee Massacre was a very upsetting and shocking event that sat in the hearts of many Native Americans. In Black Elk’s account of the Massacre he constantly stressed how often he “felt that something terrible was going to happen.” Now, before the massacre even took place, a good amount of policemen from Standing Rock decided to arrest Sitting Bull but he decided against this. His resistance caused a quarrel which ended in Sitting Bull’s death. The night before the massacre, Black Elk couldn't…

Words 525 - Pages 3

Wounded Knee: The American Indian Movement

Wounded Knee is a small piece of land in South Dakota where two hundred members of the American Indian Movement reside, but it is also the known site of the 1890 massacre in which three hundred unarmed Sioux were killed by the U.S. Seventh Cavalry. The occupation began in early 1973 in protest of the Pine Ridge administration. Once there, they demanded that the original terms of their presently broken treaties with the U.S. government be restored. Armed and ready for a fight, AIM members took eleven…

Words 223 - Pages 1

Black Elk Wounded Knee Analysis

Document Analysis According to Black Elk, what atrocities took place a Wounded Knee? There was a bloody massacre, a lot of Natives were killed. Many children and women were killed by the soldiers as they tried to flee. As Black Elk describes how Natives men, women, and children tried to flee away from the scene when the soldiers begin to attack them with their gun and wagon guns. Soldiers even attack Natives who were unarmed. The atrocities results in a lot of killing and many dead Natives.…

Words 358 - Pages 2

Wounded Knee Massacre Accounts Analysis

The content of both documents, Accounts of the Wounded Knee Massacre (1890s) and the Black Elk, Account of the Wounded Knee Massacre,1890 were about the horrible killings that took place during the Wounded Knee Massacre. Many innocent people, mostly women, and children were killed during this horrible massacre. The first document is a general overview of the massacre, while the second document is a first person account of the massacre written by Black Elk himself. The first document talks about…

Words 209 - Pages 1

Bury My Heart At Wounded Knee Analysis

Bury my Heart at Wounded Knee In the 1800s, settlers begin moving into the west. The Americans are searching for gold or just seeking to own new land. The United States Government supports them in the movement and they look to drive the Indians off of their land. The Indians have lived in the western land in harmony but the Americans have fierce desire to obtain gold. In the 1800s people want to explore new places and become rich. Many go in hopes to strike it rich and do not care what it takes to…

Words 806 - Pages 4