Essay on Yank and Rank

Words: 1253
Pages: 6
Open Document
Abstract
This paper will discuss will discuss rating system that judge employees on job performance. The rating systems that will discuss in this paper are the following: forced-ranking, absolute-rating and relative-rating system. The author will discuss weather forced ranking is a good performance management system, the different between the absolute-rating and relative-rating systems, an what would the author rely on as a rating system and can a absolute-rating system be devise that would guarantee differentiation among workers,

Rank & Yank: Legitimate Performance Improvement Tool
Or
Ruthless and Unfair Management
1. Do you think forced ranking is a good performance management system? Why or Why not.
The forced ranking system …show more content…
According to Balkin “The absolute rating approach is an appraisal format that asks superiors to make judgments about an employee’s performance based solely on performance standards” (p.211). No direct comparisons between co-workers are made and it do not cause conflict among workers that relative-rating approaches to absolute performance judgment are not wrong. Supervisors are asked to rank employees by the particular qualities and competencies listed on a form. Relative judgment requires supervisors to compare an employee’s performance to other workers doing the same job. There are issues with the absolute ranking system. In the absolute ranking system there is a possibility of supervisors ranking several employees the same, but on the other hand overall I believe an absolute rating system is perceived as fairer than a relative one. In the absolute rating system the performance criteria are clearly defined across the levels of the rating scale, whereas it is not in the relative rating.
3. As a manger, would you prefer to rely on an absolute performance rating system or a relative system such as forced ranking? Why?
As a manager, I would prefer to rely upon an absolute performance rating system. According to Balkin, “The absolute rating approach is an appraisal format that asks superiors to make judgment about an employee’s performance based solely on performance standards” (p. 211). Rating
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on Yank and Rank

Hairy Ape as a Modern Tragedy Essay

the disintegration of Yank’s personality. If there is any villain in the play, we must not find that the villain is any God or fate. But it is the mechanical forces of the social environment. Attention is focused throughout on the spiritual decay of Yank. He begins to see in him a sight of hairy ape. This carries him to the gruesome death. Now the question arises whether the play Hair Ape is a successful tragedy or not. I think, it is a play of great significance. Its theme which is handled with perfect…

Words 864 - Pages 4

Essay on Performance Appraisals

Performance appraisals are a hot subject in management and organizations these days. Organizations rely on employees to complete business tasks in a timely and competent manner because their reputation may depend on the performance of its employees. It’s essential that organizations develop a performance management system to assist in evaluating their employees. The performance management system is usually used for annual employee evaluations. The performance management system can be performed…

Words 980 - Pages 4

Essay on Enron and Enron’s Demise

company supported unethical and illegal behavior so long as it lead to financial gain. 2. They used a “reward system” that gave employees that brought in money huge bonuses and punished employees that weren’t as cutthroat. 3. The company used a “rank and yank” evaluation system that fired the lowest ranking employees. 4. Their primary goal was not to generate profits for the shareholders, it was to enrich executive officer wealth. Did Enron’s Bankers, auditors and attorneys contribute to Enron’s demise…

Words 513 - Pages 3

Marketing Strategy Essay

Marketing Strategy Enron - The Smartest Guy in the Room Enron was once the seventh largest company in the world, they were even featured in fortune magazine as America’s most innovative company for six years in a row from 1996 to 2001, but somehow they allowed their greed and arrogance to get the better of them. Though they have been successful for many years, it took very little time for them to go bankrupt. Enron’s demise is a result of implementing outrageously unethical and unrealistic strategies…

Words 384 - Pages 2

Essay about Instructor: Enron and Ethical Issue

STAKEHOLDERS List and describe the key stakeholders of your case. Describe the stakeholders specifically to your case – examples follow: Employees (The 1400 plus employees of Enron were subjected to fear tactics such as the company’s “rank and yank” policy, which put their jobs constantly at risk. Delivering bad news at Enron could result in “death” of the employee messenger so problems were covered up. Etc.) Shareholders (Enron shareholders included institutional investors such as pension…

Words 700 - Pages 3

Military Disobedience

disobedience from either enlisted personnel towards an officer or even officer to officer, honestly it was quite normal; especially when it comes to one individual having more power over the other even though they both have the same rank but the other would have more time then rank. When the undue stress of being in the middle of a war zone is involved sometimes people can lose their composure and cause a situation that they really had no control over, for example an argument over control, and the fact that…

Words 1396 - Pages 6

399 Accounting Theory Essay

the fundamental failure of morality.. Dishonesty organization culture affects many working areas. Under the ambition of Skilling and his Skilling style leadership, the whole atmosphere of the organization is too aggressive to control. Enron’s ‘rank-and-yank ‘machinations created “an environment where employees were afraid to express their opinions or to question unethical and potentially illegal business practices”. Enron has an obligation to follow company policies, to ensure accurate financial reporting…

Words 1391 - Pages 6

Essay about Enron: the Smartest Guys in the Room

The purpose of this paper is consider three possible rationales for why Enron collapsed—that key individuals were flawed, that the organization was flawed, and that some factors larger than the organization (e.g., a trend toward deregulation) led to Enron’s collapse. In viewing “Enron: The Smartest Guys in the Room” it was clear that all three of these flaws contributed to the demise of Enron, but it was the synergy of their combination that truly let Enron to its ultimate path of destruction.…

Words 1843 - Pages 8

Essay about Enron Organization

of a few executives that were extremely driven by power and greed. Skilling thoughts of motivation were to reward the employees by giving out bonuses of varying sizes to those who made the company money. He built this internal ranking system, “rank and yank”, where the employees would rate the other employees on a scale of 1 to 5; if someone had a rating of 5, the average time/life span that they would have working for Enron was only about 6 month. The closer you where to 1 the closer you got to Skilling…

Words 2573 - Pages 11

Stadiums Increase Budgets, Heighten Security Measures To Protect Fans

es-protect-fans-espn-magazine 1/12 7/10/2014 Stadiums increase budgets, heighten security measures to protect fans - ESPN The Magazine - ESPN Subscribe Photo Illustration by CJ Burton for ESPN The MagazineThe Department of Homeland Security ranks stadium attack as one of the 12 most devastating possible acts of terrorism. This story appears in the Sept. 19 issue of ESPN The Magazine. THE SNIPER WORE a baseball cap. He found a secluded spot on a grandstand near the 20-yard line at the south…

Words 3632 - Pages 15