Youth Justice Essay

Submitted By mariarru
Words: 1020
Pages: 5
Open Document
Youth Justice
Maha Masoud Royal Roads University
Just 306
October 24, 2012
Barabara Jackson

Table of Contents Introduction 3 Social Environment Affects Understanding 3 Case 1: A Historical Case 4 Case 2: A Historical Case 4 Case 3: A Current Case 5 Discussion 5 Conclusion 5 References 7

Introduction
Throughout Canadian history juvenile crime has been an issue. There has always been a debate about rationales for sentencing the child, youth, and young adults. A current debate concerns the age of the offender and whether sentencing should be differentiated between persons on the basis of age. In other words, does age matter when considering sentencing for youth offenders? This issue is considered, as well, from a victim’s perspective. Should an offender be treated differently because of age? I believe that there should not be a separate justice systems for the young offender. The purpose of this paper is to explore how social environment, not age, affects youth’s ability to understand the ramification of committing an offence. I will discuss why age does not matter and relate this argument to three cases concerning youth and crime. Age is not as much a part of the equation as youths’ understanding of the offence committed, and that because of this, each offender should be considered on a case to case basis and the offender’s understanding of the crime should be thoroughly considered.
Social Environment Affects Understanding
A youth’s understanding of an offence is affected by the social environment in which they are exposed. Vygotski (1929) believed that a child’s characteristics were determined by social situations. He explained that the child’s social situation affected their development. The characteristic of a person from childhood to young adult develop depending on social environment:
The social situation of development represents the initial moment for all dynamic changes that occur in development during the given period. It determines wholly and completely the forms and the path along which the child will acquire ever newer personality characteristics (Vygotski, 1929, p. 198).
I believe that Vygotski (1929) was correct in his social theory. A youth’s social environment affects behaviour. An example of how social environment can affect understanding can be seen in a video by Plan International USA Sponsor a Child. A twelve year old orphan boy, named Alex, had to act as an adult because he had to take care of his younger brother after his parents died. This social environment dictated how Alex had to grow up. He had to develop an adult way of understanding his reality (Plan International, n.d.). On the other hand, a child who is supplied for and sheltered would have more of an opportunity to stay in a childlike social environment. The child would have less understanding of a grown up reality. This example shows that social environment affects behavior. The age of the person does not matter as much as the youth’s understanding and social environment. This can be seen in the following three cases.
Case 1: A Historical Case
On April 19th 1737, in Annapolis, Nova Scotia, a 10 year old boy servant burned his employers house down to kill his employer. The servant did this because he was tortured, deprived of food and severely maltreated (History of Nova Scotia, n.d.).
Case 2: A Historical Case
In 1849 George Green an 11-year-old adopted boy, living on a farm in the County of Peterborough, hacked his 5-year-old adopted sister to death with a hoe because of the jealousy he felt when more attention was paid to the sister by the adoptive parents (Hassard, 1924). George green was sentenced to be executed in 1850.
Case 3: A Current Case
On April 23rd 2006, Jasmine Richardson and her boyfriend murdered her parents and her 8 year old brother by stabbing them to death. She murdered her parents, due to her parents grounding her and forbidding her to see her
Show More

Related Documents: Youth Justice Essay

Youth Criminal Justice Act Essay

Youth Criminal Justice Act Essay The government of Canada introduced the YCJA about 13 years ago to help Canadian youth offenders reintegrate back into society without leaving anything on their criminal record that would affect their possible thriving career in adulthood. Some gangs use children that fall under the YCJA to carry their illegal items, such as weapons and drugs. They do so because the kids are under 18 meaning that they are under the YCJA and will not receive as harsh of punishments…

Words 972 - Pages 4

The Youth Criminal Justice Act (YCJA)

The Youth Criminal Justice Act (YCJA) was introduced to Canada in 2003, replacing the Young Offenders Act ( YOA). The YCJA is the law system that governs youth ages 12-17 in trouble with the law. The YCJA is mostly fair and equitable due to these aspects. It lowers youth crime rates in Canada, the court system applies the right consequences to the troubled youth, and the system somewhat successfully rehabilitates and reintegrates the youth criminals into society. Many factors have been considered…

Words 920 - Pages 4

Review: Youth Detention Center and Juvenile Justice Essay

departments: intake, the court, detention, the POST adjudication program, and JJAEP (Juvenile Justice Alternative Education Program). My intern experience consisted of working with juveniles placed in the Courage to Change (CTC) POST adjudication, which is a diversion program of the Texas Juvenile Detention Department (TJJD). However, while interning, I was able to experience the many facets of the juvenile justice system, from the juveniles’ entry into Denton County Juvenile Detention Center, all the…

Words 500 - Pages 2

Juvenile Justice System Essay

these youth are unnecessarily placed in or referred to the juvenile justice system for relatively minor, non-violent offenses, often in a misguided attempt to obtain treatment services that are lacking in the community. However, the unfortunate irony of this approach is that the mental health services typically available to youth in the juvenile justice system are often inadequate or simply unavailable, as documented by a series of investigations conducted by the U.S. Department of Justice.7Instead…

Words 656 - Pages 3

Future Juvenile Reform Essay

Future of the Juvenile Justice System CJA/374 Future of the Juvenile Justice System Juvenile Justice System reform is a critical and current issue in the United States. The call to action by various researchers, industry leaders, and multi-disciplinary teams has been strong and convincing. This team proposal will offer reform recommendations in five vital areas of the system: law enforcement, community, courts, corrections, and the private sector. In addition, justifications for change and the…

Words 1524 - Pages 7

Juvenile Justice System

and rehabilitation within the juvenile justice system. This article discusses evidence-based programs and practices, data-based tools, and the importance of understanding the effects of trauma. Reform efforts have focused on reducing the number of youth committed to facilities. The focus on trauma-informed treatment and research has allowed youth to be diverted from long-term facilities. However, this means that the strengths, needs, and challenges of youth must be considered when implementing treatments…

Words 750 - Pages 3

take home exam JST Essays

Part A- Short Answer Questions 2. 'Diversionary measures in the juvenile justice system are a cost-cutting measure that reduces the burden on the court system and provides less formal options of dealing with young offenders. It is a win-win'. Critique this statement by providing 5 key points regarding the advantages and disadvantages of diversionary measures. 1. Financial- Court based methods of dealing with youth justice are amongst the most costly means of dealing with juvenile crime due to high…

Words 3063 - Pages 13

Juvenile Justice System Analysis

The current representation of Indigenous youth contact with the juvenile justice system is a widely researched and discussed topic through Australia. The widely accepted social consensus is that Indigenous youth are vastly over-represented within the justice system. Although a deeper exploration through the analysis of the history of the relationship between the Indigenous community and the early European settler to the criminalisation of the indigenous community by the state to 'help' and 'protect'…

Words 1596 - Pages 7

YCJA Case Study

government and the provincial governments, which delineates which levels of government have jurisdiction over certain areas of legislation (Constitution Act, 1982, s. 91-92). The Canadian Parliament enacted the Youth Criminal Justice Act (YCJA) in 2003 as a set of federal laws to govern the youth justice system across the country (Bala, Carrington, & Roberts, 2009). Although the YCJA is a federal law, the provinces and territories maintain responsibilities for its implementation in meeting the objectives…

Words 2973 - Pages 12

9110 Ethical Issues

responsibility refers to the idea and/or belief that all people prosecuted in the adult criminal justice system should be above the age of 18. This paper will specifically look at how certain jurisdictions within the US have raised the age of criminal responsibility and its benefits, how youth currently go through and get processed within the Juvenile and Adult systems, historically how have youth been treated…

Words 3408 - Pages 14