Essay on a comparison of three studies from a co

Submitted By ladyvee6558
Words: 1037
Pages: 5
Open Document
Vanessa smith a comparison of three studies from a completed matrix
GRAND CANYON UNIVERSITY
DR. DALE KIMBELL

a comparison of three studies from a completed matrix

Introduction
The three authors that I will compare in this paper is Wright & Pandey whose research sought to answer the question does structure Matter? Emery & Barker whose article sought to examine different leadership styles on job satisfaction and finally, Julia Houch whose article on shared leadership vs vertical leadership examined employee integrity.
The three articles each presented very strong rationale and yet used different styles of research study designs to present the information. Qualitative research explores the meaning behind why individuals perform a certain way. Quantitative research explore relationships among different variables. Mixed methods combines qualitative and quantitative research methods.
In the preceding paper article 1, article 2 and article 3 will be compared in areas such as purpose, strength of case, research questions, sample populations and limitations.
Purpose
Purpose is define as the reason something is done. In the three articles the authors have examine a certain hypothesis at a doctoral level and validated the researched elements for validity and bias thus creating a paper that increases knowledge in a particular field.
The purpose of article one was to test paradigms in transformational leadership in regards to public organizations and the hierarchical structures. The authors Wright & Pandey built a strong case in which they provided an argument supporting the idea that when a employee performance is motivated to perform in a satisfactory manner when transformational leadership is in place. When an organization has structural barriers employees are less productive.

The purpose of article two was to show that an employee’s customer service skills is directly affected by how he or she feels about themselves in relation to their job. The authors Emory & Barker further sought to prove that the employees feeling about his job can be connected to the type of leadership practiced in the organization.

The purpose of article three was to explore the effectiveness of an organizations effectiveness under an umbrella of shared leadership within team leadership. Julia Houch built a strong case supporting the ideal that employees were motivated and behaviors were changed when shared leadership was practiced within the organizations.

All three of these articles presented a clear purpose for the research as well as building a strong case in support of the purpose. Research questions Research questions are used to validate the purpose. Research questions allows the author to present a somewhat basis for proof. “Your research question is the most critical part of your research -- it defines the whole process, it guides your arguments and inquiry, and it provokes the interests of the reviewer. “ (chsbs.cmich.edu)

In article one the authors presented five strong research questions to aide in the validation of the research. The questions seemed to bit a bit redundant and was not really necessary for the topic in question. In article three the authors presented less questions for consideration. The questions were strong and probed directly into the hypothesis they were attempting to prove. The third article did not hesitant in addressing why the research was presented and what she sought to uncover.

When comparing the three articles and the questions they presented. I would say that the third article worked best for me in the choice of questions that the author chose. I believe it was because my interest was in her particular research more so than the other two articles. I understand that in most research it may work to your advantage when more questions are presented for review this allows a reviewer to have more information, however I also believe it depends on the way you learn and your ability to think through what is
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on a comparison of three studies from a co

Southwest: Airline and Horizontal Analysis Essays

ago, Herbert D. Kelleher and Rolling W. King started Air Southwest Company and commenced customer service. In 1971, Southwest changed its name to Southwest Airlines Co. (“Southwest”). Since then, Southwest has grown to an extremely popular and successful airline company. They started from scratch with three 737 aircraft serving three Texas cities, and today, they manage more than 250 planes that provide flights to more than 50 cities throughout the United States. Southwest is an airline that is…

Words 558 - Pages 3

Definition Of Eresearch Methods

eResearch Methods – Ch. 7 definitions Design – the design of a study is the specification of how the research question will be answered. A research design should specify how the selection of participants, method of assignment, and choice of measures and time frame work together to accomplish the study objectives. Interval validity – the approximate truth of inferences regarding cause-effect or casual relationships Casual – pertaining to a cause-effect relationship Casual relationship…

Words 1078 - Pages 5

Cogmed Notes Essay

underlying defect of ADHD, namely a deficient working memory. For clinical practice, it would be highly relevant to make a direct comparison of the effects of medication (methylphenidate) and working memory (Cogmed) training in the treatment of children with ADHD. Key features- Key features --• Therefore, in this study, children with ADHD will be randomly assigned to three treatment conditions: (1) methylphenidate, (2) a Cogmed training, or (3) a combination of methylphenidate and Cogmed training.…

Words 309 - Pages 2

Big Five Theories Essay

the best from the rest when it comes to success, skill, and overall mentality. For the purpose of this paper, I researched my topic using PsychINFO and other online databases. The key words and phrases that led to the most promising results were: “personality traits in athletes,”…

Words 974 - Pages 4

Examples Of Descriptive Statistics

It is found from table 3.3 that the calculated P value of all the Educational loan repayments factors i.e. Perceived quality, Parental influence, Intention to repay, and Students attitude, is 0.172 which is greater than 0.05 which indicates perfectly fit. Here GFI (Goodness of Fit Index) value and AGFI (Adjusted Goodness of Fit Index) value is greater than 0.9 which represent it is a good fit. The calculated CFI (Comparative Fit Index) value is 0.986 which is greater than 0.90 means that it is a…

Words 1441 - Pages 6

Bachelor Thesis on Business Intelligence Essay

studiów: stacjonarne Evaluation and comparison of Business Intelligence platforms as systems supporting decision-making in small and medium-sized companies in Poland Warszawa 2013 2 Abstract Business Intelligence (BI) systems are applications that are used to enhance decisionmaking in organizations. However, Small and Medium-sized Enterprises (SMEs) in Poland has only recently begun to discover the benefits of these systems. This study elaborates on the architecture of these…

Words 11637 - Pages 47

Marketing: Stock Exchange and Hong Kong Essay

_______________________________________________________________ || _______________________________________________________________ Report Information from ProQuest 04 March 2013 16:55 _______________________________________________________________ Table of Contents Search Strategy Set#|Searched for|Databases|Results| S3|tsingtao bear in UK|ABI/INFORM Global, Applied Social Sciences Index and Abstracts (ASSIA), British Periodicals, Design and Applied Arts Index (DAAI), ERIC…

Words 6210 - Pages 25

Belief Statement of Christianity Explained Essay

a church called the San Joaquin Valley Bible Church that possess these same beliefs. I will do a comparative study of my eight foundational beliefs with that of the Hindu religion. First of all my eight foundational beliefs are as follows: • I believe the Bible to be the inspired and only infallible written Word of God • I believe that there is One God, eternally existent in Three Persons; God the Father, God the Son and God the Holy Spirit. • I believe in the Blessed Hope, which is the…

Words 1918 - Pages 8

Definition Of Budgeting

It expresses the income to be generated and expenditure to be incurred during that time period. Budgetary control – It the establishment of budgets relating the responsibilities of executives to the requirements of a policy, and the continuous comparison of actual with budgeted results, either to secure by individual action the objectives of the policy or to provide a basis for its revision. Budget centre – A budget centre is a section of an entity for which control may be exercised and budget…

Words 1756 - Pages 8

Small Group Communication Analysis

communication processes, and relevant factors in relation to small groups. Most of the communication skills discussed in the book are directed to group interaction. According to Tubbs (2012), small group communication refers to interactions among three or more people. Group Development During group formation, associating new relationships and tasks through initial interactions placed the foundation for group activities. These states explained as “storming” which the group implements their roles…

Words 595 - Pages 3