A Justifying Necessity Essay

Submitted By RISKinator
Words: 867
Pages: 4
Open Document
AP Language and Composition 9/16/13

“A Justifying Necessity” In Truth and Beauty, Ann Patchett uses letters from her late friend Lucy Grealy, along with her own writings, to illustrate their friendship over the years since they graduated college together as writers. However, questions are raised, especially by the Grealy family, about whether or not Patchett is justified in presenting only one viewpoint of Lucy. In Suellen Grealy’s article, Hijacked by Grief, Lucy’s sister goes as far as to claim that Patchett is riding on Lucy’s fame and that Patchett provides too narrow of a viewpoint to truthfully represent who Lucy is. This is not Ann Patchett’s intention. As evidenced by her long-standing friendship with Lucy, Patchett’s inclusion of Lucy’s letters is not to ride on her fame, but to help her describe her friend as she knew her; a charismatic, outgoing person who overcame cancer and the related physical deformities by becoming a successful writer, only to be overcome by depression.

Following their graduation from Sarah Lawrence College, Ann and Lucy both travel to Iowa City to live together as they continue their studies to become writers. This is the start of their long and intimate friendship. In the following years they provided food, money, support, and companionship for each other. When they are far away from each other they call, write letters, and send packages to each other. “I got home today to find my St. Lucy medal waiting for me: I have always wanted one of those. Thanks pet: it's just so amazing to me how good you can make me feel, more than anyone else...”(p.52) They support each other when trying to win grants to writers’ workshops, when stuck in meaningless relationships, and when they hit writer’s block. They share grief, sorrow, joy, depression, good times, bad times, triumphs, and failures. They're best friends, and Ann Patchett successfully conveys this in her book by using her own recollection of the events supported by Lucy’s letters to her.

Truth and Beauty is a sometimes brutally honest book that revealed Lucy’s frailties and insecurities to the world. “She told me later that's when she started grinding up the OxyContin and snorting them. When they were gone, she made the simple transition back to heroin.”(p.232) This was too much, too soon for the Grealy family, who were already left in a state of intense grieving following Lucy’s death in 2002 from an accidental heroin overdose. In Hijacked by Grief, Suellen Grealy describes the negative impact Truth and Beauty has had on her family, mainly that it was too narrow of a viewpoint to accurately present who Lucy actually was. Suellen laments that this skewed version of Lucy is the one that is presented to the public, who then jumped to conclusions both about Lucy and the Grealy family, especially her mother. She also alleges that the reason Patchett published her book so soon after Lucy’s death was to attract more publicity because Lucy was so famous from her writings. Suellen raises the question of whether or not Patchett was justified in using Lucy’s writings to add to what she says is an incomplete book.

Ann Patchett is justified in using her friend’s letters for a number of reasons. She needs Lucy’s
Show More

Related Documents: A Justifying Necessity Essay

Ron Kline's Argument Analysis

rights movement in 1989, Dr. Ron Kline was studying experimental medical technology at the National Cancer Institute in Washington D.C. In the Newsweek article “A Scientist: ‘I Am The Enemy’.” Kline is effective in justifying research on animals through his thorough explanation of the necessity of accurate test subjects when discovering new medical treatments. Kline’s first argument begins by addressing what he believes to be a common initial reaction to animal testing “I am the enemy! One of those…

Words 703 - Pages 3

Jules Ferry's Views On Imperialism

this semester, both have had their great deal of supporters and opponents. Jules Ferry was one such supporter of imperialism. In his speech to the Assembly on July 28, 1883, the reasons he gave for French imperialism was for economic necessity, transportational necessity and to civilize “inferior races”. Concerning the first two points, his views were in reaction to the growing strength of the other western superpowers. The expansion of the French Empire would allow for a growth in their economy and…

Words 559 - Pages 3

Poetry and Dulce et Decorum Essay

used in both Pirandello’s prose and Owen’s poetry to convey that war has little meaning. After the grieving parents discuss the necessity of sending their children to battle, a woman brings the encounter back to an emotional level. After witnessing the reactions of the parents riding the train, the woman poses an unassuming question to one traveller who insists on justifying the reason to go to conflict: “… just as if she had heard nothing of what had been said and almost as if waking up from a dream…

Words 418 - Pages 2

Nazi: Morality and Data Essay

conundrum in his article “The Moral Instinct”. Pinker argues that “reassigning an activity to a different sphere, or taking it out of the moral spheres altogether, isn’t easy. People think that a behavior belongs in its sphere as a matter of sacred necessity and that the very act of questioning an assignment is a moral outrage” (Pinker p.52). Pinker argues that by examining our different moral thinking through the lens of these five moral spheres (harm, fairness, community, authority, purity), it may…

Words 1034 - Pages 5

Comparing Bonjour And Devitt's Arguments

phenomena and that is not particularly obscure. The crux of the debate is whether both theories can offer viable explanatory power, with obscurity being secondary to the issue. BonJour's arguments for the necessity of the a priori will be analyzed first, followed by Devitt's arguments against the necessity of the a priori. Despite both positions being radically different, there are arguments to analyze.…

Words 1110 - Pages 5

Atomic Bomb Dbq

Justifying the Atomic Bomb Through the United States’ isolationism caused by the Great Depression dictators arose across the sea in Europe. While the dictators rose in Europe so did Japan. Having opened up to foreign trade, it began to quickly catch up to other international superpowers. This exponential growth in trade caused Japan to pick up speed and begin to search for more land to gain resources for its growing population. As many know the United States was dragged out of the Great Depression…

Words 1451 - Pages 6

week 4 media paper cmst

part of the melee after being shot in the head with a non-lethal police projectile. He tells of almost unlivable conditions in overcrowded jail cells, inedible food, and god-like correctional officers in charge of the systematic denial of basic necessities. When telling the stories of the other prisoners arrested for rioting and looting, there is almost a sense of justification for their actions. The common argument that the troublemakers are just repressed, unheard, and frustrated youth out to get…

Words 578 - Pages 3

Human Resource Management - EEO and the law Essay

Chapter 2 – Equal Opportunity and the Law Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act An employer cannot discriminate on the basis of race, color, religion, sex or national origin with respect to employment. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission The commission, created by Title VII, is empowered to investigate job discrimination complaints and sue on behalf of complainants. Affirmative action Steps that are taken for the purpose of eliminating the present effect of past discrimination. Office…

Words 894 - Pages 4

9/11: A Groupthink Action

Irving Janis spoke and defined groupthink as, cohesive groups of people making and justifying faulty decisions. Groupthink is when a group of people come together and think as a whole. The downfall with groupthink is that the group will commonly make irrational decisions or overestimate their positions. I feel that 9/11 attack was a groupthink action. 9/11 came as a shock to the U.S and had given a terrible blow to this country. After the terrorist had destroyed the twin towers, damaged the pentagon…

Words 671 - Pages 3

Comparing Morality In Machiavelli's The Prince And Julius Caesar

Essex’s rebellion due to insufficient support. Specifically, Brutus’ syllogism in the orations, “As Caesar loved me, I weep for him…but, as he was ambitious, I slew him” characterises Caesar as over-ambitious and a danger to the Roman Republic, hence justifying his death appealing towards the plebeians’ appreciation for honour and patriotism prevalent in Elizabethan England. However, Antony appeals to pathos of the crowd mocking Brutus’s nobility through his anaphoric epithet of “honourable” undermining…

Words 1098 - Pages 5