Essay A New Approach to Juvenile Justice

Submitted By nevets56
Words: 925
Pages: 4
Open Document
A New Approach to Juvenile Justice
Stephen Stivason
Strayer University
Juvenile Delinquency and Justice
September 7, 2011

Introduction There is little doubt that there is a fundamental problem with the contemporary American approach to juvenile justice. That is because the focus of the U.S. juvenile justice system is heavily based on procedural safeguards that protect juvenile rights whereas there may be more important concerns. Certainly, the rights of juvenile defendants must be protected and sentences should continue to reflect the different needs and capacity for reform of juvenile offenders as compared to their adult counterparts. However, much more emphasis should be devoted to the prevention of juvenile crime by addressing fundamental factors believed to be responsible for it. From a cost-benefit analysis, preventing juvenile criminal involvement is much more important than focusing on reform and on other aspects of criminal justice that are only triggered after criminal activity is perpetrated. In principle, it is much more beneficial to society—as well as to potential juvenile offenders—to provide the necessary assistance and opportunities to prevent criminal inclination rather than devoting the bulk of resources to offenders.
Recognizing the Principle Causes of Juvenile Crime Generally, some of the most important causes of juvenile crime are: (1) Social Control Theory issues, (2) lack of supportive family environment and structure, (3) exposure to deviant criminality in high-crime communities, and (4) lack of opportunities for positive community involvement. The proposed plan for reducing juvenile crime, therefore, will address those three causes and suggest an approach to mitigate their detrimental impact on at-risk youth and, simultaneously, on society.

Social Control Theory Issues There is a consensus among contemporary sociologists and criminologists that one of the principal causes of juvenile crime is the lack of connectedness of the individual to community (Akers & Sellers, 2004; Huebner & Betts, 2002). In particular, Hirschi’s Social Control Theory explains the importance of involvement, commitment, attachment, and belief to the development of individuals who share the dominant values and expectations of their community (Akers & Sellers, 2004; Huebner & Betts, 2002). Among at-risk teens, there is a very low level of satisfaction of these criteria outlined by Hirschi. Therefore, a plan for reducing juvenile crime must address this issue, ideally, by implementing a practical form of assessment process in public schools. This assessment approach would allow trained child psychologists to identify at-risk juveniles based on Hirschi’s criteria before they become offenders.
Criminal Deviance in High-Crime Communities High-crime communities typically feature combinations of two major factors that greatly increase the risk of juvenile criminal deviance and delinquency: the absence of a supportive family structure and environment and continual environmental exposure to criminal deviance as a social norm (Pinizzotto, Davis, & Miller, 2007). In fact, contemporary criminologists consider this combination to be especially problematic in blighted, high-crime/low-income communities in which most households lack a stable structure and adult role models fulfilling the parental role. Unfortunately, this explains the manner in which criminal gangs manage to recruit and indoctrinate new gang members before they reach their teenage years (Pinizzotto, Davis, & Miller, 2007). In gang-dominated communities, street gangs frequently provide the only family-type of structure and stability in the lives of children raised by parents who are absent from their lives or, in many cases, involved in chronic criminality themselves (Pinizzotto, Davis, & Miller, 2007).
Reducing Risk Factors Providing better social services for low-income families with children would likely go a long way toward
Show More

Related Documents: Essay A New Approach to Juvenile Justice

Master: Crime and Nsw Police Force Essay

issue of juvenile crime and it is no denying that juvenile crime has been around for many generations . However due to the fact that there has been quite a dramatic increase in juvenile offenders , our society has began to take a new approach in dealing with such an issue and it has been relatively successful . The methods adopted by our society include rehabilitation , crime prevention and education . The methodology or approach that our society has taken towards the issue of juvenile crime is…

Words 2060 - Pages 9

Jayla Dallis State Paper

Jayla Dallis 4311 Juvenile Justice State Paper October 10, 2014 Dr. Johnnie Dumas Myers “This assignment is submitted in partial fulfillment for the course requirements in Juvenile Justice.” The juvenile justice system in Idaho is 102 years old. In the early 1900s reformist believed that the “common practice of treating al offenders the same and housing them in the same correctional facilities, regardless of age, was inhumane. (Juvenile Justice In Idaho, 2006)” In 1903, Idaho’s…

Words 824 - Pages 4

Juvenile Justice System Essay

referred to the juvenile justice system for relatively minor, non-violent offenses, often in a misguided attempt to obtain treatment services that are lacking in the community. However, the unfortunate irony of this approach is that the mental health services typically available to youth in the juvenile justice system are often inadequate or simply unavailable, as documented by a series of investigations conducted by the U.S. Department of Justice.7Instead of relying on the justice system to address…

Words 656 - Pages 3

Essay on Crime and Juvenile Court Judge

website research on juvenile justice system On November 17, 1999, a Michigan Circuit Court jury found thirteen-year-old Nathaniel Abraham guilty of second-degree murder.1 Abraham was convicted of killing Ronnie Greene Jr.—a crime he committed when he was only eleven years old.2 Although tried in an adult court, Abraham was sentenced by Judge Eugene Moore to juvenile detention until the age of twenty-one, at which point he automatically will be released.3 Abraham’s case illustrates the current controversy…

Words 8224 - Pages 33

Biological Factors Of Juvenile Delinquency

The question posed this week asked if juvenile justice personnel pay enough attention to potential biological factors when considering juvenile delinquency. I do not believe it currently gets enough attention. However, this may be due to earlier unproven scientific theories that were thought to predict criminality. For example, Cesare Lombroso believed physical characteristics (which match closely to what we know today as features of fetal alcohol syndrome) were tell-tale signs of a criminal due…

Words 252 - Pages 2

Juvenile Sex offenders Essay

Juvenile Sex Offenders, The Problem No One Wants to Talk About Dennison Muczynski Ashford University CRJ301: Juvenile Justice Instructor: Curtis Turney March 29, 2015 Most people feel uncomfortable openly discussing sex offenders in open forums, let alone juvenile offenders. People often look for simple answers and quick to rush judgement and demand a person to be punished for their actions. We see this type of thinking all over the news, like in Ferguson, MO, where half of society was willing…

Words 3576 - Pages 15

Juvenile Justice Crime

With youth justice crime as it is now, and how it was before, there has been a lot of enforcements that have been brought in, to specifically deal with it (see: Goldson, 2010). It was said that young people shouldn’t mix with adults, this idea was brought in the latter half of the nineteenth century. It was obvious that a juvenile justice system had to exist, but how it was going to exist was the issue (Crawford and Newburn, 2003). The home office took control of the individual schools in the 1860’s…

Words 1030 - Pages 5

Prison Bootcamps Essay

The Juvenile Justice System came up with a new alternative to help the problem of juvenile delinquency. This new alternative was juvenile boot camps. Boot camps aim to address major problems children have in their lives as well as those that are first time offenders. A major problem some of the children have is with authority, which institutions treat with a heavy dose of authority in the form of drills, exercises and other training led and enforced by staff as part of a military platform. (Puzzanchera…

Words 1743 - Pages 7

9110 Ethical Issues

belief that all people prosecuted in the adult criminal justice system should be above the age of 18. This paper will specifically look at how certain jurisdictions within the US have raised the age of criminal responsibility and its benefits, how youth currently go through and get processed within the Juvenile and Adult systems, historically how have youth been treated…

Words 3408 - Pages 14

Juvenile Court Case Study

Question 1 With the first U.S. juvenile court being established in 1899, it is no surprise that much has changed since then. There are two fundamentally essential principles that accompanied the establishment of the juvenile system. First, the idea that the law should treat children differently than adults. The revolutionist thinker John Locke rightly argued that “children’s lack of reasoning capacity, which [disqualifies] them from participating in government, also [makes] them less culpable for…

Words 1491 - Pages 6