B Gods Existence Through Definition Alone Essay examples

Submitted By Soumia97
Words: 560
Pages: 3
Open Document
B) It is not possible to prove God’s existence through definition alone (10)
Philosopher, Kant would agree with the quote and believes existence is not a predicate. You cannot talk about something and then state that it exists because we could do this with anything He gave the example of unicorns. Humans have an idea of what a unicorn is but this does not mean to say it exists just because we can picture what it could be like. Therefore in this example, we see through definition alone, God cannot be proved to be real because we could demand anything into existence but this does not mean it will happen.
Similarly, Hume argued that we cannot define something into existence. Just because we can think of a perfect form of it, it doesn’t mean it exists so again, Hume would agree with the quote and support the idea that God cannot be proved to exist simply through definition.
Gaunilo’s island supports Hume and Kant’s theory. He described the most perfect island with ‘beautiful sea and palm trees rustling in the wind’. He gave this ideal island to show that just because you can think about a perfect island in your mind, it does not mean it exists in reality.
Gods existence is not self-evident according to Aquinas. God requires empirical evidence which he offers in 1-5 of his ways of proving God’s being. He stated that we will never know if God just exists, we must prove is through his 5 ways. Due to God not being self-evident, we need proof to support the notion of His existence instead of defining Him into existence without evidence.
Russell’s supporting argument shows that we can talk about cows but not unicorns because we know that cows exist. This goes for God also. We can talk about things that are evident to us but we shouldn’t talk about things we cannot see.
Anselms argument however, opposes this greatly. He argued and said that if you accepted the ontological argument, then it would be unimaginable to believe that God exists. He says that God
Show More

Related Documents: B Gods Existence Through Definition Alone Essay examples

Essay about Convergence of Buddhism and Quantum Mechanics

seemed like two polar ends of the knowledge spectrum. Religion is borne from spirituality, in which man tries to find truth within oneself and within a higher power. Science, on the other hand, focuses completely on empirical data; through science, man tries to find truth through observation of the world we live in. If truth were a castle, science builds the castle piece by piece from the foundation, whereas religion “puts castles in the air”, giving each person the opportunity to “build the foundations…

Words 1476 - Pages 6

Essay on KRISHNA AND SHAKTI

stories about the down coming of Krishna can be found in the Puranas as well as the Bhagavad Gita. Krishna is often depicted and worshipped as either; a mischievous child, a lover, or a warrior and spiritual leader. It is difficult to give a precise definition of Shakti, as Jamison says, ‘this unique emphasis on the female power of the divine needs some exploration, as it is not always... straightforward.’ (Hinduism) However we can divide the ideology of Shakti into certain distinct features. One of…

Words 1229 - Pages 5

Euthanasia: Ethics and Life Essay

TASK 1 1. What is Euthanasia? Euthanasia is the act of intentionally killing someone to end suffering. To support this definition quoting from the Sacred Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith: euthanasia is ("an action or omission which of itself and by intention causes death, in order that all suffering may be eliminated.")- John Paul II's encyclical letter Number 65. Euthanasia comes from the greek word euthanatos : 'well' 'death' Euthanasia can be considered: voluntary - with the active…

Words 7350 - Pages 30

Philosophy 101 Study Guide Essay examples

How did he interpret the words of the Oracle at Delphi? He used the notion that the oracle told him that no one was smarter than him to go an interrogate everyone, and be a nuisance to the people. He took it as a riddle, he knew he had no wisdom and gods didn’t lie. What punishment did he offer to accept? He is sentenced to death. Locke’s Essay ‘On Enthusiasm’ What is “enthusiasm”? Enthusiasm is a vain and unfounded confidence in divine favor or communication, Locke strongly rejects it.…

Words 3879 - Pages 16

Essay on VALUE THEORY FINAL

Dr. Elliot Dorff Value Theory 17 December 2014 Final Examination Part B Question #2a: Why should I help someone else in need? David Hume based his philosophy on a belief in cause and effect relations. Hume would begin by observing the person’s current situation and what originally caused him or her to end up there in the first place. He would then analyze the factual relationships between the events (i.e. events A and events B), provided by the senses and evidence, and try to search for a reason…

Words 2669 - Pages 11

Patristics Revision Essay example

authenticity: chosen by God (not laying on of hands) o Not primacy of Rome ▪ ‘Presiding over love’ – flatters them to stop them preventing his martyrdom o Minister of word and sacraments, and pastor of local congregation ▪ Polycarp: exhortation to salvation, constant prayer, firm against error, preaching on pertinent moral issues o Authority resides in gospel (even more than OT Scriptures) and God • Typology o Respect bishop – God the Father; deacons –…

Words 3285 - Pages 14

APOL 104 Week 2 Essay

faith is tested as Christians. People may ask us, “How do we know Jesus rose from the dead?” How do you know: Our reply should involve critical thinking. Some will say in reply, ‘b/c bible says so’. So then they ask how do you know the Bible is true? Some will say, ‘b/c the Bible says it is: “All Scripture is God-breathed and is useful for teaching, rebuking, correcting and training in…

Words 7772 - Pages 32

Public Forum Debate Case Essay

Cape Town in South Africa, Ethics for Wildlife Conservation: Overcoming the Human-Nature Dualism, 3/1/06, http://www.redorbit.com/news/science/410448/ethics_for_wildlife_conservation_overcoming_the_humannature_dualism/#uOkeloY9LSY3hiby.99) The existence of intrinsic value in nature, on the other hand, would free conservationists of the obligation to prove that there is value in conserving a particular species. Although it is generally accepted that human life is intrinsically valuable, the possibility…

Words 3673 - Pages 15

Illness And Grief Outline Essay

start PRAYING. “Your word is a lantern to my feet and a light upon my pathway” (ps.119:105) I remember saying Lord I’m depending on this your word to be true and I’m depending on you to guide my steps and thoughts. “And ye shall serve the LORD your God, and he shall bless thy bread, and thy water; and I will take sickness away from the midst of thee.”(Ex: 23:25) Please Lord let this pertain to me and mine. All the reasoning comes and bargaining and pleading, and the “ Oh Lord whatever I did wrong…

Words 7100 - Pages 29

Eudora Welty and Jean Rhys Essay

Eudora Welty’s “A Worn Path” and Jean Rhys’s “I Used to Live Here Once” concentrate on one specific theme which is “Journey”. While the two works display comparable themes the difference is point of view. Each of them has shown a particular journey through which life can change. There is one thing in common in these two works; no matter what journey a person takes there are a lot of obstacles in the way to dissuade them and ultimately find that love is the end result in which they make that voyage.…

Words 2279 - Pages 10