Abortion and a Doctors Decision to Choose Essay

Submitted By lyoung541
Words: 2290
Pages: 10
Open Document
12/4/2012
ABORTION AND REFFERALS Abortion is a polarizing topic. I do not intend on discussing the morality of abortion itself, but the idea of doctors refusing to perform services and the referral process they lawfully must provide. Abortion, now legal in the U.S, is a necessary procedure. However doctors can decline providing abortion services, as long as they refer a patient to a provider who can assist them. Pro-choice advocates have said the refusal of service puts extra stress on the woman, considering the decision is stressful enough. Pro-lifers however, argue that forcing a doctor to refer a patient to an abortion clinic is just the same as the doctor performing the procedure his self. In some cases both sides can be right, but the issues at hand are the rights of both the woman and the doctor. Doctors should be given the right to refuse to offer abortion services as long as a referral is provided to the patient. In the article “Abortion and the Referrals for abortion: Is the law in need of change” by Demian Whiting, he addresses the legal issue of personal morality in the health industry. Whiting reviewed a paper by Daniel Hill published in a medical journal discussing the issue of when conception occurs. Whiting does not take on the issue of abortion; instead he questions whether a doctor’s personal moral belief should be paramount. Abortion is one of the only procedures doctors are lawfully able to refuse to perform. The current law requires a referral to be given to any patient turned away, which to Whiting is the only reason this refusal is acceptable. Whiting states “it seems very likely that not requiring doctors to refer is something that would be considered contemptible by society at large, including, we might surmise, by a large number of doctors who refuse to abort on grounds of conscience”(Whiting 1007). The Journal “Abortion Incidence and Access to Services in The United States” is based on research done by Rachel K. Jones and Kathryn Kooistra compiling the relative statistics of abortions and harassment of all abortion providers. The research and statistics provided in this article detail the drop in abortions performed from 1980’s to current day. “Nationwide, the number of abortions peaked in 1990, at 1.61 million, and dropped 25%, to 1.21 million, by 2005. Similarly, the abortion rate declined 29% over the same period, from 27.4 per 1,000 women aged 15–44 to 19.4 per 1,000” (Kooistra and Jones 41) according to the research the two compiled. While the number of abortions went down the amount of harassment the clinics encountered increased. They stated,”89% of the offices performing more than 400 abortions per year encountered harassment (Kooistra and Jones 48). Only 15% of all clinics that perform abortions did not have any occurrences of harassment.
“Hospital Admissions of Unsafe Abortions” by Marge Berer focuses on the incidence of hospitalization due to subpar and clandestine abortions in several countries. In many countries where abortion is illegal women are forced to go to secret clinics to get services. These clinics are often staffed with unlicensed and unqualified people. Many of the abortions performed after the first trimester are unsuccessful in ending the pregnancy and commonly cause death to the mother after complications. Berer notes, “When legal restrictions on abortion are reduced, the rate of deaths and morbidity decreases greatly” (Berer 1848). Berer does not advocate making abortion regular practice in all institutes, but believes that the ability for patients to receive safe care is a priority.
In Annals of Internal Medicine the journal by J.R.E “Abortion and the Doctor” seeks to capture the view held by the majority of doctors regarding abortion. He believes that doctors strive to better the health of all their patients both psychologically and physically. J.R.E notes that most doctors view the health of their patients go beyond merely their physical
Show More

Related Documents: Abortion and a Doctors Decision to Choose Essay

Pregnancy and Abortion Essay

Abortion My essay is over abortion. Abortion is the surgical procedure that ends a pregnancy by removing the fetus and placenta from the mother’s womb, which is known as the uterus. There are many different types of abortions. Women sometimes get abortions for health reasons. This is called a therapeutic abortion. But most of the time women choose to get an abortion to end their pregnancy. This is called an elective abortion. A surgical abortion uses a vacuum to remove the fetus and…

Words 943 - Pages 4

How Can Abortion Be Considered A Crime

would ask yourself when abortion pops up.This topic is not an easy one to talk about.The person going through this might ask this question. For instants would you be considered a criminal , what trimester would the procedure happen, and how many other people have had an abortion? For example people think abortion should be considered a crime. The reason of this is because your taking your child's life . “Women are allowed ,but have consequences with this process of abortion”. Then there's other people…

Words 629 - Pages 3

Roe vs Wade Essay

WADE (Legalizing Abortions) One of the noted and controversial cases in the U.S Supreme Court history was that of Roe v. Wade. In the case of Roe v. Wade the final ruling made it legal for women and their doctor to choose the option of abortions without restrictions in earlier months and with restrictions in later months. Many people fear that abortions are just the beginning to the end of the human race that will be self-inflicted. While other feels that the option for abortion is the correct…

Words 638 - Pages 3

Persuasive Essay On Pro Abortion

pro-choice, abortion has been a long running controversial topic even before it became legal in the United States from the time the earliest settlers arrived. At the time Canada’s Constitution was adopted, abortions, before the point at which a pregnant woman could feel the movements of the fetus (approximately the fourth month of pregnancy), were openly advertised and commonly performed. In the mid-to-late 1800s jurisdictions began passing laws that made abortion illegal. Currently in Canada abortion has…

Words 1771 - Pages 8

Norma Leah Mccorvey's Influence On Abortion

traumatized. She talked to a secretary at work who, after hearing her story, recommended an free illegal abortion clinic in Oak Cliff Texas. To her horror she found the clinic raided by the police, deserted, and blood stains on the walls. This was not abnormal for abortions in the early to mid 1900s. The illegal abortion clinic in Oak Cliff was normal for woman who had to seek an underground abortion. Luckily Norma McCorvey was found by Sarah Weddington and Linda Coffee who…

Words 1960 - Pages 8

Legalizing Abortion Research Paper

Each year about 1.2% of all women aged 15-44 have an abortion. Abortions should be legal because foster care may not be the best for children, the woman may have been raped, and the woman might resort to having an illegal abortion. Abortion should be a choice for mothers. It should be legal. Abortions have been done for several centuries and in different cultures. In 1803 Great Britain passed anti-abortion laws because of crude methods, few antiseptics and more. Many say it is because of the…

Words 714 - Pages 3

Abortion: Pregnancy and Society Point Fingers Essay

Abortion Abortion has always been a controversial issue in all aspects and eras. Many may take the easy way out of having a baby others have an abortion because there not prepared to have a child. In our 21st century society point fingers mainly at teenagers and believe they are the ones who choose to have an abortion. Although that is not always the case abortion is open to teenagers and adults. The decision of whether to have an abortion can always be prevented. Sex education is always…

Words 458 - Pages 2

Abortion and Person Essay

that Abortion is a denial of a right to life. Attacking this Premise I disagree. Abortion is not a denial of a right to life. There are many circumstances in life where an a Abortion has to be performed. Lets look at a situation with a pregnant woman who’s aware that her unborn child is dead. In this circumstance an abortion most be performed. You may ask why? If an abortion is not performed in this situation, a woman may have more injuries from her body miscarrying then getting an abortion. surprisingly…

Words 1045 - Pages 5

Roe Vs. Wade: The Court Case Of Abortion

Ever thought about abortion? Even wondered if that law has ever been passed? Roe vs Wade was a court decision on January 22, 1973 over an abortion case. Abortion is a medical procedure that kills the fetus without a chance at life. In other countries abortion is strongly forced on the parent. China would be the most enforced country of them all. It was just passed their that you can have only two children. This legal court case was held in the great state of Texas in 73. The reason why the court…

Words 150 - Pages 1

Essay on A Woman's Right to Choose

A Woman’s Right to Choose Laura Schade Argosy University – Inland Empire ENG 102 – Composition II Instructor Michelle Dalrymple Abstract This paper explores the reproductive rights of women and how the government is intruding upon those rights. Contraception prevents unwanted pregnancies and abortion is a means of terminating a pregnancy. Even though abortion is legal, there are still Pro-life supporters and people in congress who want to ban it altogether. This paper shows how the U.S…

Words 1983 - Pages 8