Abortion Is Impermissible

Words: 1324
Pages: 6
Open Document
“Abortion is impermissible as it is on par to killing an adult human being,” this statement is a representation of a conservative viewpoint in relation to foetal killing, however this statement is not well received within modern society. In most cases, common ideals allow for abortion to occur under certain circumstances. Conversely, the conservative opinion cannot be overlooked as it is still held by many individuals, mostly in religious and right wing circles. Yet, this point of view does not consider, the mother’s autonomy nor her right to make her own choices in relation to her future preferences, which may not include motherhood. Further, it allows for many absurdities within the theory; especially if the foetus is not compatible with …show more content…
The conservative argument, is established within the sanctity of life principle, which at first comes across as a compelling argument, from a shallow view point, stating that, “it is impermissible to kill an innocent human being.” Which for most people, sounds valid and intuitively persuasive. A foetus is a member of the human race, and is innocent, therefore according to this theory it is impermissible to kill them. (SORUCE) This would include, within situations where the child is born malformed, possibly terminally ill and would live a life of pain. This theory also implies a right to life; however, it can be seen more as a right not to be killed unjustly. But, if this is the case, then it begs the questions within this theory of if killing the foetus is unjust. Nevertheless, the conservative theorist would most likely hold …show more content…
This is a stronger argument against the conservative theory as it is not based solely on the rights of the foetus and does not disregard the mother’s right as a person her/themselves. J.J. Thomson is a representation of a liberal middling view with her violinist case, in which she draws on two aspects; the first being that we each have a right to control what happens in our own body, the second is that we have an obligation to be, “minimally decent samaritans.” She holds that bringing a child to term is above this baseline of morality and that the foetus (in this case the violinist) is an unwelcome invader in the mother’s body body. (SOURCE) However, this argument does not actually show what women want from an abortion, to be absolved of the responsibility of motherhood. Thomson would have to hold that if exogenesis existed that the mother would have to agree to the foetus being removed from the uterus, as her analogy only allows a woman the right to have a foetus removed from her body. (SOURCE) Yet, this seems morally counterintuitive for both the conservative argument as well as the feminist theorists. It does not do to abandon Thomson completely; however, it must be treated with some caution as it only gives a woman the right not to have the parasitical relationship of pregnancy, not the right to abandon
Show More

Related Documents: Abortion Is Impermissible

Essay on Against Abortion

“A Defense of Abortion” Premise Judith Jarvis Thomson attempts to defend the issues of apportion. She begins by explaining her basic argument that the premise of a human embryo is in fact a person. She defends this statement by stating that by the tenth week of pregnancy, the baby already has its major functions of the body. However, no one can argue accurately that it can be concluded that all abortion is morally wrong. She believes that a clump of cells is "no more a human then an Oak tree". Her…

Words 399 - Pages 2

Thomson's View of Abortion Essay

Thomson's View of Abortion In the article "A Defense of Abortion" Judith Jarvis Thomson argues that abortion is morally permissible even if the fetus is considered a person. In this paper I will give a fairly detailed description of Thomson main arguments for abortion. In particular I will take a close look at her famous "violinist" argument. Following will be objections to the argumentative story focused on the reasoning that one person's right to life outweighs another person's right to autonomy…

Words 1096 - Pages 5

Pro-Abortion Essay

Abortion, defined as the deliberate and voluntary act of terminating a pregnancy by means of removing a foetus from a woman’s uterus, provides many ethical concerns as to whether it may be characterised as morally permissible or impermissible. For this argument, I will support two contentions to suggest that abortion is ethically acceptable; first, that foetuses are not persons and therefore are not morally considerable, and second, that regardless of the moral considerations given to the foetus…

Words 2616 - Pages 11

Analysis Of Don Marquis's Argument That Abortion Is Wrong

Abortion has generated considerable debate with supporters and opponents widely labeled as “pro-choice” and “pro-life” respectively. Despite both sides feverously arguing that their view is better, abortion is a topic that is widely misunderstood and mischaracterized considering how both sides employ similar arguments and thus causes great confusion. In this essay, I set out to support the claim that abortion, except perhaps in rare circumstances, is seriously wrong. In the first section, I will…

Words 1839 - Pages 8

Abortion Canadian Law Essay

Nicole Stumpf Erik King CLN4UI October 9, 2014 Dying Generation Abortion is a topic that is constantly debated worldwide. I believe that is should not be happening anywhere because you are killing innocent babies and it does not benefit anyone. I feel as if the law should change so that abortion is illegal. These three natural law philosophers: St. Thomas Aquinas, R.M Dworkin and Plato would agree with my newly changed law. St. Thomas Aquinas was greatly influenced by Christian…

Words 494 - Pages 2

Morals Abortion Paper

papers. I will read drafts and the earlier you get one to me, the more I can help. 1) When is abortion morally permissible? Explain which elements of your response are consequentialist, deontological or virtue-theoretic. Be sure to address arguments against your view. Permissible There are two cases which are extremely obvious that abortion is absolutely morally acceptable. The first case is that of rape. When a woman becomes pregnant as the result…

Words 2499 - Pages 10

Thomson's Arguments Against Abortion

what the central issue is when it comes to abortion. Thomson is right in her claim that the central issue when it comes to abortion is the pregnant woman’s obligations in the dace of the fetus’s right to life. Thomson explains that it is hard to draw the line when it comes to the development of the fetus- in terms of when an abortion should be performed and when it shouldn’t. When does a fetus become an actual human person? Those who are opposed to abortion explain that a fetus is a person, but fail…

Words 773 - Pages 4

Who Is Don Marquis

1 Don Marquis, in his essay “Why Abortion is Immoral,” argues that abortion is morally impermissible. 2 Marquis is challenging the potential of personhood. This view asserts that abortion is wrong because it prevents a potential person (the fetus) from developing into an actual person. According to this view, the moral status of the fetus depends on its potential to become a person with a valuable future. Marquis argues that if we accept the potential personhood view, we must also consider other…

Words 650 - Pages 3

Street's Argumentative Analysis

give a satisfactory scientific explanation by positing some independent moral truths as an answer (pp.414). Imagine if we are supposed to agree that abortion is impermissible. Clearly, most of us would not be persuaded to agree to form that moral belief simply because it is true by looking at the statistics that most agree abortion is impermissible. Adaptive link account, on the other hand, has a better scientific explanation. Under the adaptive link account, moral beliefs helped in survival and…

Words 898 - Pages 4

Abortion and Person Essay

that Abortion is a denial of a right to life. Attacking this Premise I disagree. Abortion is not a denial of a right to life. There are many circumstances in life where an a Abortion has to be performed. Lets look at a situation with a pregnant woman who’s aware that her unborn child is dead. In this circumstance an abortion most be performed. You may ask why? If an abortion is not performed in this situation, a woman may have more injuries from her body miscarrying then getting an abortion. surprisingly…

Words 1045 - Pages 5