An Analysis Of Collier And Fuentes

Submitted By kailamohr

Words: 353

Pages: 2

Open Document

I. Introduction (150 words)
• • •

give background of Collier and Fuentes briefly summarize their texts and why they are important present thesis: In addition to using personal experience to connect with her audience, Collier uses sound reasoning, clear statistics, and her personal authority as a judge to convince her audience.

II. Personal Experience -- Collier's personal experience connects with audience.(200 words)
• • • •

example of Collier's use of guardian experience why personal experience is rhetorically strong (speaks to lay audience) counterarguments to accusations of personal exp. being a hasty generalization Fuentes' lack of personal experience in j. crime weakens her persuasiveness

III. Good Reasoning--Collier's argument rests on good reasoning overall (200 words)
• • •

Collier's "different juveniles need different system"--explain why this is sound. Collier's "adult crime deserves adult time"--explain why this is sound. examples of Fuentes' poor causal reasoning o adults don't necessarily reject youth due to having social security o adults don't necessarily resent youth because of job competition o zero tolerance policy is result, not cause, of increased j. violence o that adults think poorly of youth is not cause of increased j. violence

IV. Statistics -- Collier uses statistics in straightforward, easy to understand way (200 words)
• • • •

examples of Colliers' straightforward use of statistics examples of Fuentes' unclear, contradictory use of statistics (making issue fuzzy) why manipulation of statistics endangers truth comparison of statistics with actual Dept of Justice source

V. Authority -- Collier has authority from working in legal

General Allotment Act

For the past four hundred years the United States government has done everything in its’ power to undermine the rights of Native American people. Until the mid-twentieth century the U.S government gradually stripped away Indigenous peoples’ rights to the land that their ancestors had once lived. Tribal sovereignty is a tribe’s right to govern themselves geographically, economically, and judicially all while in the agreed upon parameters of the dominant government. Throughout history the U.S government…

Words 1151 - Pages 5

Constitution: United States Constitution and Eminent Domain Clause Essay

the United States is the supreme law of the United States of America. The Constitution was adopted on September 17, 1787, by the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, and ratified by conventions in eleven states. It went into effect on March 4, 1789. When the First Congress met in 1789, James Madison, a congressman from Virginia, took upon himself the task of drafting a proposed Bill of Rights. The first ten constitutional amendments ratified by three-fourths of the states in…

Words 4799 - Pages 20

Segregation In Schools: Supreme Court Case, 1952-1954

Introduction: Brown v. Board was a Supreme Court case that took place in 1952-1954. This case was one case comprised of four other cases. The four other cases were Briggs v. Elliot, Belton v. Gebhart, Bolling v. Sharpe, and Davis v. Prince Edward County. These four cases differed in some ways but they all involved the inequality in the segregation of public schools. Though not all of the cases individually were a victory, when they were brought together and used to attack racial segregation in…

Words 1121 - Pages 5

Illegal Immigration Research Paper

the United States Why do people enter the United States illegally? Although many people believe that illegal immigration is bad for the United States, the truth is that illegal immigration can be good too. While reading this essay, you should gain knowledge of a few things about illegal immigration. One of the items that you will learn by the end of the essay is general knowledge of what immigration is. You will also learn about the pros and cons that immigration causes in the United States. Knowing…

Words 1257 - Pages 6

Future: Franklin d. Roosevelt and Social Security Act Essay

political helpmate. She gained knowledge of Washington and its ways while Franklin served as Assistant Secretary of the Navy. She became active in the women’s division of the State Democratic Committee to keep his interest in politics alive. After the presidents death in 1945 she began her service as American spokesman in the United States. She continued a vigorous career until her strength began to wane in 1962. 2) Works Progress Administration (WPA) – an agency, established as part of the Second New Deal…

Words 1021 - Pages 5

Book Banning in Libraries Essay

Books of Knowledge A Discussion about the Freedom Censorship of Books in Public School Libraries Collier Wimmer High Point University Introduction Book-banning in school libraries is only the latest battleground in a centuries-old war over the censorship of ideas. Twenty years after Johann Gutenberg’s invention, the first popular books were printed and sold in Germany; within another 20 years, Germany’s first official censorship office was established…

Words 3576 - Pages 15

Vocab Apush Essay

1. General Court: Massachusetts Bay legislature that tried Anne Hutchinson for heresy; banished leading Antinomians after trial. 2. John Winthrop: First governor and founder of Massachusetts Bay Colony (~1630). Envisioned a “city upon a hill” that would cause Anglicans in England to reform 3. Restoration Colonies: Colonies given to pay off royal debts in return for loyal citizens’ support of Charles II during the restoration. First was Carolina. 4. Leisler's Rebellion: America's response…

Words 5758 - Pages 24

Indian Removal Act Of 1830 Analysis

In summarizing nearly two hundred years of American Indian history, the main focus is broken into three main time periods. Firstly, land dispossession and treaty violations, that ultimately become the catalyst for Indian resistance towards the United States. Secondly, cultural assimilation and the process of boarding schools that threaten to brainwash generations of children and the control of their socio-economic status. Lastly, the ongoing issue of tribal autonomy,…

Words 2341 - Pages 10