Antigone vs Creon Essay

Submitted By kayliechristy
Words: 961
Pages: 4
Open Document
Kaylie Christy
Mrs. Yoshiyama
English 2; Period 1
30 October 2013
Loyalty or Morals: Which is More Important?
Being a big part of a kingdom or being part of family forces one to have responsibilities and duties that are needed to be fulfilled. In Sophocles’ Greek tragedy, Antigone, Antigone has the responsibility of being loyal to her brother, Polyneices. However, Creon has the responsibility of being loyal to the people of Thebes. Therefore, both Antigone and Creon have been loyal to whom they have wanted to be loyal to; this is why both are equally correct.
Antigone and Creon were equally loyal. Antigone was loyal to her family and the law of the Gods while Creon was loyal to his people and his word: “And now you can prove what you are: A true sister, or a traitor to your family…” (Prologue). Antigone wasn’t afraid of the danger of Creon’s law, because being a loyal sister was more important to her than death. Antigone didn’t want her brother to be dishonored by Creon and his law for some grudge he may have against Polyneices. However, Creon was just as loyal as Antigone: “But whoever shows by word and deed that he is on the side of the State,---he shall have my respect while he is living and my reverence when he is dead,” (Scene 1). Creon states that he will only be loyal to those who are loyal and respect him. As the King of Thebes, Creon has to be loyal to his people, because he has to gain their trust as a new king; it is only fair that his people be loyal to him. Creon and Antigone both had too much pride in what their choice was. Antigone had a very strong opinion about the consequence of breaking Creon’s law. Antigone states, “this crime is holy: I shall lie down with him in death, and I shall be as dear to him as he to me. It is the dead Not the living, who make the longest demands: we die for ever...” (Prologue). Antigone explains to Ismene that they should bury Polyneices and forget about Creon’s law, because they will eventually going to end up dying anyways so why not take a risk and bury their brother so he isn’t disrespected in front of the kingdom. However, Creon has pride for his decision in not burying Polyneices. He explains to his people that “Polyneices, who broke his exile to come back with fire and sword against his native city and the shrines of his fathers’ gods, whose one idea was to spill the blood of his blood and sell his own people into slavery…” and that he is doing the best for his people by dishonoring Polyneices (Scene 1). He was not going to change the law for anybody, because he was so proud by his decision and thought he was doing the best for his kingdom.
At the same time, Creon and Antigone both did things that were wrong. Antigone doesn’t have many reasons why she is wrong, but there are some reasons. Antigone broke the law to bury her brother. As a princess, she has to set an example for her kingdom, which she isn’t doing by breaking the law of the king. Even though the king is her uncle, she should still have enough respect for him and her kingdom to set a good example and follow the law. Antigone states, “Creon has sworn that no one shall bury him, no one shall mourn for him,” which proves that she knew about Creon’s law before burying her brother (Prologue). Creon also didn’t have many reasons why he was
Show More

Related Documents: Antigone vs Creon Essay

Creon Vs Antigone Essay

Baldwin Literary Tradition III 28 February 2024 Divine Duty vs. Earthly Pride The discussion that I found most exciting during our class lectures was over Sophocles’ Antigone. The question that was mentioned in class was if Antigone or Creon was correct on whether Polynices should receive a burial. In class, Nicholas sided with the intention of Antigone because he believed that it was completely necessary for Polynices to be buried by Antigone due to familial duty to honor her brother, as well as divine…

Words 856 - Pages 4

Essay On Antigone Vs Creon

wrote over 120 tragedies, yet only seven survived. Among these was the play Antigone. The tragedy follows a young woman named Antigone as she fights her newly appointed uncle King Creon for a proper burial of her brother Polyneices. He does not receive a proper burial unlike his brother Eteocles due to the fact that he is viewed as a traitor to Thebes. Creon and Antigone both display the qualities of a tragic hero, but Creon would be more qualified. First off, both characters are born into nobility…

Words 639 - Pages 3

Antigone Vs Creon Analysis

Last week, we read a book called Antigone, which is a Greek tragedy written by Sophocles. The story mainly based on the conflict between Antigone and Creon on whether to bury Antigone's brother or not. Her brothers, Eteocles and Polynices both died in the same day in a war against each other. I found it interesting in how the tragedy formed by a conflict. They had a totally opposite view: Antigone believed that both her brothers should be buried equally, while Creon only gave Eteocles a properly funeral…

Words 749 - Pages 3

Antigone Vs Creon Essay

In the play, Antigone, Creon, and Antigone have different views on the rules and the law. Yet they both have contrasting traits that are seen as traits that the tragic hero has in play. At the play's beginning, Antigone expresses her heroic side by failing to comply with the law set for her country and sticking to her belief til the end. Creon expresses his traits by trying to restore order in Thebes and doing almost anything to keep it in order. In the play's climax, Sophocles makes it obvious that…

Words 862 - Pages 4

Antigone Vs Creon Essay

portrayed in the play Antigone, a Greek tragedy written by Sophocles. King Creon makes a very public decision about not burying Polyneices, so when he finds out someone disobeyed him and buried him anyway, he thinks he has to punish whoever disobeyed him. King Creon feels as if he has to show his power, especially since he is a new king. As a result, he sends soldiers all over Athens to search for the person who disobeyed him. In this scene from the film adaptation of Antigone, where the soldiers…

Words 612 - Pages 3

Antigone Vs Creon Analysis

Sophocles contrasts the characters Antigone and Creon in order to question if authority or family should be more valued. Creon puts more importance on his rule and the law, while Antigone emphasizes the devotion to her bloodline and the gods. Antigone, although depicting that authority and the king’s rule is important, puts more importance on how not being true to one’s family and morals leads to devastation—as seen in Creon’s tragic ending. Sophocles depicts that family is superior to authority…

Words 922 - Pages 4

Antigone Vs Creon Essay

Antigone by Sophocles is an absolute classic and a great example of a tragic hero. The play has maintained popularity throughout history and is still relevant today. The clash between Antigone and Creon is essential to the story. Their different motives, actions, and beliefs lead to a prolonged tragedy. By analyzing how the characters speak, behave, and think, in contrast to Creon's personality, we can observe how these interactions shape Creon's journey as a tragic hero and steer the story toward…

Words 949 - Pages 4

Power Of Women In Antigone Vs Creon

the repressing power of man. Antigone is an exemplary piece of work depicting this desire for privilege of power. To commence, as a character with a rough heritage, Antigone has less power in society than that of other women. A feminine protagonist, who was the daughter/sister of Oedipus, the former Theban King, Antigone was the…

Words 962 - Pages 4

Antigone Vs Creon Character Analysis

Although Antigone may appear to be a play about a clash of wills between a heroine and villain, it contains a larger significance. Antigone, the heroine, who buries her brother despite the horrid consequences does not see anything wrong with her actions. Similarly, Creon, the villain in the play, views his decree as also just in the situation. As a result, this difference in morals produces a struggle between the two characters. Antigone centers all of her actions on the belief that the Gods are…

Words 216 - Pages 1

Antigone Vs Creon Character Analysis

greek play Antigone, by Sophocles, Antigone and her sister return to Thebes hoping to avoid a prophecy that predicts Eteocles and Polynices will kill each other in a battle for the throne of Thebes. But when she arrives in Thebes, Antigone learns that both of her brothers are dead. Creon misunderstands many things from that point and things start to go downhill. The chorus, a group of common elder men who follow the actions of the play, change in their support of either Antigone or Creon, depending…

Words 666 - Pages 3