Argument Against Manifest Destiny

Words: 1129
Pages: 5
Open Document
As a result of America’s need for more land, the idea of “Manifest Destiny” was conjured. Early America was met with lots of immigration. Manifest Destiny was the idea that it was a God-given right for white men to own all of North America, and some saw it as the fate of American to own all of North America. America felt that it should own the continent Pacific to Atlantic coasts. They would extend American liberty to new territories. Americans would expand North West, and it was mainly fur trappers. This led to new passages through the mountains. As a result, they found more fertile territories. The Americans that took their treks to the West would document their findings. Americans exaggerated their findings of their travels when advertising …show more content…
As a result of the recent Louisiana Purchase, the U.S. embraced Manifest Destiny. The Election of 1844 really defines the U.S. around Manifest Destiny. Henry Clay of Kentucky didn’t want the land, he felt that we didn’t need it. He feared Texas. Texas was trying to break from Mexico and join the U.S. Clay doesn’t want to fight for the land, he only agrees to let Texas join the Union if Mexico agrees. Clay’s opposition was James K. Polk. Polk supports Manifest Destiny. Polk though that Texas was “ours” anyway because he feels that it was acquired under the Louisiana Purchase. He says that the U.S. was basically “re-annexing” Texas. He’s willing to go to war for Texas. He doesn’t care if it’s Mexico or Great Britain. His slogan was “Fifty-four forty or fight.” Polk’s idea was that U.S. was to acquire Texas, California, and the entire Oregon territory. He defined the northern boundary of Oregon as the latitude line of 54 degrees, 40 minutes. Polk would win the Election. Before John Tyler would leave his presidency, he would arrange a “Joint-resolution” with Congress to get Texas in Union. This avoids the rule for Treaty because Tyler knew that the North wouldn’t sign the treaty. As a result, Polk gets Texas before he’s president, so he shifts to a focus on
Show More

Related Documents: Argument Against Manifest Destiny

Manifest Destiny In The 1800's

ideological reasons, such as manifest destiny, along with political ideas like preclusive imperialism and the Monroe Doctrine. First of all, manifest destiny played a large role in the U.S.’s decision to expand internationally during the late 19th century. Manifest destiny is the idea that it is the American’s god-given right to conquer and annex any and all land that they can get their hands on, the creator of the idea, John O’sullivan said himself, “Our manifest destiny to overspread the continent…

Words 865 - Pages 4

Territorial Expansion Argumentative Analysis

The benefits of territorial expansion did not outweigh the costs because of the many lives that were lost and injustices such as the ones against Native Americans. Many Americans were motivated to move west because of the desire for farmland, gold, or a new life. Many Americans also believed in the doctrine of Manifest Destiny, that it was the United States' fate to expand its borders from the east to the west. However, these benefits did not outweigh the costs. The biggest of these costs was the…

Words 384 - Pages 2

Manifest Destiny Research Paper

Finn Mehren, Kaleb Williams, Oscar Anaya 05-17-2024 Hour 3 Negative Justification of Manifest Destiny. Introduction to Case: Manifest Destiny, which was the idea that Americans were destined to expand westward, was a 19th century concept created to cover up the harsh reality that the expansion of American territory was encroaching on native lands and tribes. Americans began to believe expansion was both justified and inevitable. The Declaration of Independence states “We hold these truths to be…

Words 2070 - Pages 9

Territorial Expansion Argumentative Analysis

topic of thorough discussion. Some of the argument was over states that included slavery, and states that outlawed. A great deal of the discussion, however, was much deeper. Although the opponents of expansion were successful at first, the supporters eventually won out. The opponents of expansion brought up many valid points which held back the American dream of manifest destiny for many years. In 1803, the beginning of the desire for manifest destiny, a purchase was made by Thomas Jefferson; the…

Words 316 - Pages 2

Mexican American Imperialism

The ideas for the War with Mexico were born from the ideals of Manifest destiny and in a time when America sought to show her military power. The ideas of both patriotism and nationalism following the war of 1812 spawned a desire within Americans not only to expand westward, but to show of the strength of the Nation’s military. In 1820 James Monroe issued his Monroe Doctrine which stated that United States would no longer be open for colonization or conquest, of course this didn't mean that America…

Words 889 - Pages 4

Comparing Beveridge And William Jennings Bryan

commitment to isolationism. Many of his quotes speak about how it is beneficial to the economy, among many other things. In argument 3 “Manifest Destiny” Albert states “Distance and oceans are no arguments. . . The ocean does not separate us from lands of our duty and desire. . . the oceans join us. . . Steam joins us; electricity joins us—the very elements are in league with our destiny.” This shows…

Words 376 - Pages 2

Summary Of Zinn's Westward Expansion During The 1800s

Howard Zinn argues that the majority of policies and laws during the 1800s were purposefully antagonistic against the Native Americans, as they would be the primary receivers of foreign oppression. Furthermore, Zinn argues that such relations were the result of continual tension between indians and Colonists after many tribes had sided with the British in the Revolutionary War, and still had to deal with American expansionism. Zinn also states that the man responsible for what would eventually become…

Words 576 - Pages 3

American Exceptionalism

In particular, with these continuities, one is better equipped to scrutinize the idea of Manifest Destiny. According to Robert Kaplan, it was not “inevitable that the United States should have an empire in the western part of the continent” (220), and was instead brought about by frontiersmen. This argument against Manifest Destiny is consistent with the continuities that have been observed thus far; in fact, such continuities demonstrate how, beyond the surface…

Words 1493 - Pages 6

Essay on dem notes

______________________________________________________________________________ Chapter 11: Westward Expansion Key Terms/Dates/People: Compromise 1850, Free Soil Party, Fugitive Slave Act, Manifest Destiny, Popular Sovereignty, Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, Wilmot Proviso. Essay Questions: A) Describe America’s manifest destiny and how it led to the expansion of the country in the mid 1800s. B) How did the discovery of gold in…

Words 1008 - Pages 5

What Was Andrew Jackson's Approach To The Strails System

I. POINTS FOR MASTERY (7-10 Sentence Each – 10 Points Each): Student should be able to answer the following points: Describe the growth of America's middle class during the first half of the 1800s and include in your discussion some of the stronger movements toward reform during this time period. (See sections 10-3 thru 10-3d) By 1860, a shoemaker who would make shoes himself, selling them at his own shop, doing all the labor himself transitioned to supervising a group of laborers who completed…

Words 1611 - Pages 7