Arguments Against Asylum Seekers

Words: 532

Pages: 3

Open Document

What is an Asylum Seeker?
An asylum seeker is someone who is seeking international protection but whose claim for refugee status has not yet been determined (Phillips 2011).
Political Context of Children in Detention
Section 4AA of the Migration Act explicitly states that a ‘minor shall only be detained as a measure of last resort”
In March of 2014, there were 584 children in detention centres on mainland Australia while 305 other children were held on Christmas Island. An additional 179 children were detained on Nauru. Under the Rudd government of 2013, all asylum seekers who arrived by boat on or after 19th of July 2013, were to be transferred to Nauru or Manus Island detention centres unless the Minister determines otherwise. Under Australian law, there is no prescribed limit to the time a child can be detained. The approximate days that children spend in these detention centres is one year and two months. Evidence shows that 85% of children in detention have significant impact on mental health and wellbeing. In this same time period, children have been assaulted more than 233 times, while there have been a reported 33 incidents of sexual assault. Australia’s current detention law, policy and practice does not address the particular vulnerabilities of asylum seeker children, nor does it afford them special assistance and protection. Mandatory detention does not consider the individual circumstances of children nor does it address the best interests of the child as a primary consideration. This is contrary to Australia’s obligations under article 3(1) of the Convention on the Rights of the Children …show more content…
The issue of children asylum seekers is topical and very important because the attitudes of individuals and the policies of the government in relation to the children in detention, has a profound effect on the lives of many. Prejudiced and uninformed attitudes towards asylum seekers can cause emotional harm and promote

Arguments Against Securitization

Evaluate critically the arguments for and against the ‘securitisation’ of immigration policy. With current discussions concerning, what has been labelled as the “immigration problem” in the West, the issue of security and policies regarding border control have taken centre stage in international security. Focusing, mainly on the Europe Union and the United States, immigration has always been a factor of concern with people moving to and from states for various reasons. However, fear of foreigners…

Words 1832 - Pages 8

Asylum Seekers Research Paper

again. The fact that the term ‘asylum-seekers’ is being put forth for this argument is creating fundamental terminology. The distinction that states strike here is that one who lawfully pleads entry is an asylum-seeker while one, by whatever means, has somehow found his/her presence in the territory of another state becomes a refugee. According the research of the University of Sydney the UN International Refugee Convention requires host countries to treat asylum seekers with dignity and respect while…

Words 1319 - Pages 6

Implications For Offshore Processing In Australia

government to pursue its revised offshore processing regime. KEYWORDS Immigration, refugees, asylum seekers, offshore processing, Pacific Solution, Migration Act 1958 (Cth), human rights, jurisdictional facts Stephanie Constand 2 IMPLICATIONS FOR OFFSHORE PROCESSING IN AUSTRALIA: THE CASE OF PLAINTIFF M70/2011 Stephanie Constand * I BACKGROUND TO THE MIGRATION AMENDMENT ACT 2012 Although the majority of asylum seekers arrive in Australia by air and hold valid visas, it is the small proportion of irregular…

Words 7625 - Pages 31

Essay on War And Conflict

Conflict By Simon & Chelsie What causes War and Conflict? War- “A state of armed conflict between different countries or different groups within a country” http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/english/war Conflict- “A serious disagreement or argument, typically a protracted one” http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/english/conflict War and conflict is said to be caused by contrasting interests and capabilities (specific sociocultural differences and connections between the parties);…

Words 592 - Pages 3

Policy Goals In America

Contradictory Policy Goals in America On September 11th, 2001 a terrorist act was committed on U.S. soil. This event has shaped our country in more ways than one, but the often-overlooked consequence is how it has changed the lives of people in countries thousands of miles away. The global climate about national security has changed in such a massive way that it now reaches into nearly every part of our government as well seemingly unrelated parts of foreign nations policy. One can…

Words 3438 - Pages 14

Essay on Student

Explain the linkages between the business case and moral case for diversity in organisations. Support your key arguments by sourcing ‘diversity statements disseminated/ publicised by Australian organisations to justify their claims for managing diversity. Diversity itself remains an unclear concept. It is contextually specific and linked to demographic and socio-political features of the population and the workforce. Diversity is a selective concept in that some, but not all physical characteristics…

Words 1837 - Pages 8

Human Trafficking In Nigeria

some obscure power (Bovenkerk et al, 2003). Consequently, all parties involved in the trafficking investigations started to embrace the term “voodoo”. To the police, voodoo became a central element in the fight against traffickers and pimps. To the lawyers, voodoo provided an important argument to back the powerlessness of these women and justify their return back to the prostitution industry under the own free will. Further, the social welfare structures based their work on the idea that girl were…

Words 3250 - Pages 13

Australian Criminal Appeal Law

1) Appeals laws precedent set by SA 22 Mar 2013, 11:10 am - Source: Karen Ashford, SBS The most significant changes to Australia's criminal appeal laws in a century have been passed in South Australia, setting a precedent for reform which could flow all the way to the High Court. South Australia has passed reforms to allow prisoners a second chance to appeal their convictions in the case of compelling new evidence. Until now, people convicted of an offence have had a single right of appeal…

Words 3101 - Pages 13

Separation of Powers Essay

Politics and Law Study Notes Constitution Constitution: a written document outlining the process, principles and procedures of government Federal constitution: a written document that defines the official powers and regulations involving state and central governments Key Features (generally) * Codification: USA = codified (written in a single document), Saudi Arabia = un-codified (fully written, multiple documents), UK = un-codified (some unwritten conventions) * Entrenchment: if entrenched…

Words 5525 - Pages 23

Essay on Understanding Children and Young Person Development

CWDC Standards Work Pack Standard 1: Understand the principles and values essential for fostering children and young people Standard 2: Understand your role as a foster carer Standard 3: Understand health and safety and safer caring Standard 4: Know how to communicate effectively Standard 5: Understand the development of children and young people Standard 6: Keep children and young people safe from harm Standard 7: Develop yourself Standard 1: Understand…

Words 13939 - Pages 56