Articles of Confederation Essay

Submitted By Laura-Noble
Words: 851
Pages: 4
Open Document
Laura Noble
U.S. History Essay
A Stronger Government for a New Country
The Articles of Confederation were successful in unifying the independent colonies during the American Revolution but did not adequately provide a strong central government, so were therefore nearly completely replaced by the Constitution, which more specifically outlined powers of the government. The weak and ineffective Articles resulted in the Constitutional Convention meeting in Philadelphia on May 25, 1787 to create a new form of government. A total of 55 delegates from 12 of the 13 states, with the exception of Rhode Island, worked to create the Constitution. The Constitution changed the structure of the government, stabilized the economy and reformed the social and cultural attitudes of the citizens of the United States. The transition from the Articles of Confederation to the Constitution drastically changed the structure and power of the government. The Articles of Confederation was a document that loosely linked the thirteen states for united action to deal with common problems. Such as, Shays Rebellion and the Whiskey Rebellion. It was designed with Congress as the chief agency with no executive, or judicial branches and without a single leader. Each state, regardless of size or population had a single vote. Hardly any bills or amendments were passed since bills required 2/3 vote and amendments required unanimous consent. The Articles were designed to have a weak central government and allowed the states too much power. The Constitution, on the other hand, produced a completely different government. The executive branch was created and the Electoral College was used to elect a president rather than a direct vote in order to prevent mobocracy. The Commerce Compromise allowed Congress to tax imported goods but not exported ones. Checks and balances were put into place for the different branches of government to help prevent one branch from gaining too much power over the others. The executive branch enforces laws, the legislative branch makes the laws and passes laws, and the judicial branch interprets the laws. The Judiciary Act of 1789 created the Supreme Court with a chief of justice and five associates, a federal district and circuit courts, and an established office of attorney general. The Constitution’s radical changes from the decentralized government outlined in the Articles of Confederation created a new, centralized government for the United States. The economy of the United States benefited from the ratification of the Constitution. The Articles of Confederation were weak and ineffective. Some states abused the power and declared embargos and taxes on other states who wanted to trade. There was no authority from the central government to enforce a tax collection; therefore, paying off the national debt was a growing, problem. The “Father of the National Debt,” Alexander Hamilton, designed a tariff to pay off the large debt. The first tariff law placed close to an 8% tax on dutiable imports; it was passed by Congress 1789, before Hamilton swore in as president. Later in 1791, Congress passed an excise tax on whiskey, which Hamilton created for internal revenue. This not only led to the Whiskey Rebellion in western Pennsylvania in 1794, but it also challenged the new government. As a result, the government got involved and President Washington ended the rebellion. The new government gained new respect from the states. Hamilton also proposed the idea of having a National Bank. The bank would stimulate business
Show More

Related Documents: Articles of Confederation Essay

Articles Of Confederation

To Amend or Not to Amend The Articles of Confederation is the first governing mechanism devised for the United States. As the precedent, many Americans, especially the Foundering Fathers, knew that it had many weaknesses, but that’s precisely what they intended: a Confederacy. Out of fear of replicating another British monarchy, the colonists attempted to construct an extremely weak government and avoid concentrating powers in the hands of a few individuals. However to assess the effectiveness…

Words 1288 - Pages 6

The Articles Of Confederation

Marianna Lucich Mr. Verde SUPA US History 27 October 2014 The Articles of Confederation is an agreement between the thirteen original states; it provided a slacking federal government before the current Constitution went into effect. The Articles of Confederation was created to find a solution to common problem. It was the first official government of the United States, it had many weaknesses . One of the main weaknesses was the failure to regulate trade (Class Notes). The states would…

Words 794 - Pages 4

Articles Of Confederation

Articles of Confederation A. National government weak with little real authoriity. 1. Executive selected by members of Congress, one year term, only a figurehead with no real power. 2. No judiciary. 3. Congress given broad powers; set quotas for men and money which could be asked for from the states; make commercial and other Treaties; conduct war and foreign affairs, including negotiation with Indians; manage public lands in the west, limit state boundaries, and admit new states; borrow money…

Words 1105 - Pages 5

Effects Of The Articles Of Confederation

own government where dictatorship did not exist. The Articles of Confederation is how separate states came together. However, this made the government basically a dictatorship, which is what they were trying to avoid in the first place. The Articles of Confederation sparked conflict and there were many problems with freedom, respect for other countries and international politics. There was to much conflict with The Articles of Confederation so this caused people to start wondering what could work…

Words 361 - Pages 2

Articles Of Confederation Dbq

The Articles of Confederation were an agreement amidst the thirteen states in that essentially served as the first constitution. The Articles were first drafted by a committee appointed by the Second Continental Congress and were then ratified by all of the thirteen states in the year 1781. The government was then replaced by a new constitution and federal form of government in 1789. Under the Articles of Confederation, the United States was a formal union of sovereign states, and although individual…

Words 382 - Pages 2

Article Of Confederation Dbq

for the people and by the people. After some time, they created the Article of Confederation, which gave the states too much power and things quickly took a wrong turn. After some time, many state delegates came together to revise the Article, and decided to create the Constitution. George Washington and John Adams became two of the first federalist administrations to exist under the new Constitution after the Article of Confederation failed. However, because both men had very different views on how…

Words 378 - Pages 2

Essay On The Articles Of Confederation

Although the Articles of Confederation were the building blocks of America, it had many downfalls such as the failure to impose taxes, having the control over the interstate commerce, and amending documents. These faults needed to be changed as soon as possible to make create a better government, also giving some rights to the people and being able to control the trade between states. The Articles of Confederation had many faults and one of the main ones was levying taxes. The congress could request…

Words 468 - Pages 2

Articles Of Confederation Federalism

Before we had the government system that we all know today, the Articles of Confederation constructed a weak federal government. State governments used to have more power and delegates from each state, having one vote, had to agree on an action before the federal level could proceed. When the United States Constitution came along, it changed the function of federalism. The federal system present in the United States now has two levels of government. Each of these governments “[possesses] the capacity…

Words 304 - Pages 2

Essay on Articles of Confederation

There are nine major factors that Articles of Confederation changed to the U.S. Constitution. Although the change created a weak central government, a unicameral, no executive branch and no federal court system it achieved peace treaty with Great Britain, develop territories for statehood and made department that became president’s cabinet. There were two major groups at that time: federalists and antifederalists. Federalists were loose constructionists and wealthy merchants who supported the constitution…

Words 309 - Pages 2

Articles Of Confederation Failure

the revolutionary war that led to the formation of the first government of the United States, the Articles of Confederation was used as the source of government constitution. By it, the first governmental structure was established. However, the Articles of Confederation never last longer before it failed. There were a number of reasons behind its failure. First of those reasons was because the Articles itself created a very weak national government right from onset. The national government it created…

Words 373 - Pages 2