Articles Of Confederation Vs Constitution

Words: 1166
Pages: 5
Open Document
The Articles of Confederation and the Constitution are the two constituents that

United States worked under. Both the documents are similar in many ways. They were
Documents formed by the same people. However, these documents are much more dissimilar than they resemble each other. Below are a few comparison points between the two documents.
The formal name of the nation in the Articles was- “The United States of America”; and

the Constitution name was “the United States of America”.

In the Articles the Legislature was one-sided and was called Congress; whereas in the

Constitution it was bicameral and was called Congress, but was divided into the House of

Representatives, and the Senate.

In the Articles there were two …show more content…
Some of the Weaknesses were: the national government had the ability to pass laws, however they could not enforce them, sturdy and fixed leadership was absent, inability to impose taxes, etc. When the Revolutionary war ended, the United States owed huge debts, but it also had in it’s possession large areas of land in the West between the Appalachian Mountains and the Mississippi river which were sold in order to be valuable. The Congress divided these areas into townships six miles square.The Federalists supported the Constitution and the anti Federalists opposed it. It was a sharp fight over ratification of the Constitution. Anti-Federalists and Federalists each believed in republican government, but they contradicted how to form such a government to protect freedom.Federalists support strong federal government whereas anti Federalists were against it. Federalists opposed the bill of rights and thought it might do more harm than good, whereas the anti-Federalists supported it. Republicanism can exist only in a small Republic, on the other hand the anti Federalists thought that it would survive in a large and manifold republic. Roger Sherman was a supreme court judge and the only person to sign all four documents of the American Revolution: the Continental Association of 1774, the Declaration of Independence, the Articles of Confederation, and the Constitution of the United States. He is remembered as the Architect of the Connecticut Compromise. The Constitution was announced to be the supreme Law of the Land. Based on the Compromise, the House of
Show More

Related Documents: Articles Of Confederation Vs Constitution

Compare And Contrast The Articles Of Confederation Vs The Constitution

The Articles of Confederation vs. The Constitution The Articles of Confederation; the original document outlining government in the newly freed United States of America, was quickly replaced by the well know Constitution, but why? If the Articles were so ineffective why where they adopted in the first place? The Articles were rather weak and had many problems, problems that were addressed in the newly formed Constitution. The main problems stemmed from the time in which the Articles of Confederation…

Words 523 - Pages 3

Articles Of Confederation Vs. Anti-Constitution: Foreign Policy

Anti-Constitution: Foreign Policy The Articles of Confederation. This is the government that led us through the revolution that ultimately gave us our independence. Why should we alter it so drastically that it becomes an entirely different document? As a newly budding nation, we need consistency in our government. If anything, developing a new system of government would only cause chaos. A chaos this young nation cannot afford. This proposed constitution would not only cause chaos at home, but…

Words 351 - Pages 2

June: United States and Constitution Essay

Articles vs. Constitution The Articles of Confederation and the Constitution both are similar to one another, but have some differences. I have recently just been asked to cast my vote for either the Articles of Confederation or the Constitution of 1787. Being a New York merchant and a trader that is engaged in trade, I have to come to a decision on which form of government would best suit my needs. Looking at both the Articles and the Constitution, I have decided to cast my vote for the Constitution…

Words 652 - Pages 3

Constitution Amendment Essay

The Articles of Confederation were endorsed in November, 1777. There were, obviously, inadequacies in the document, and getting the representatives to concur in kind to pass any kind of report was very difficult even from an optimistic standpoint. The Articles did permit a similarity of solidarity, the further stimulus to stay at war with the British, and the conclusion that there might be a Federal government. The Articles, on the other hand, neglected to require distinctive States to help reserve…

Words 1222 - Pages 5

Constitution Guard Against Tyranny Dbq Analysis

How Does the Constitution Guard Against Tyranny? How Does the Constitution Guard Against Tyranny? The United States Constitution was developed on September 17, 1787. After months of disagreements and heated debates, and arguing, ideas ended up being settled through compromise and thoughtful reconsideration. The original problem that the group of men making the constitution were facing was that the Article of Confederation (the existing constitution) was not made with knowledgeable rules. There was…

Words 518 - Pages 3

Nahir Cramer HIST 101 Assignment 1 Essay

Drafting and Adoption of the US Constitution Nahir Cramer Timeline • 3 September 1783: End of Revolutionary War • Articles of Confederation: Governmental document until Constitution ratified • 25 May 1787: First Constitutional Convention; Independence Hall, Philadelphia, PA • 17 September 1787: Constitution Signed & Distributed to states • 7 December 1787 – 29 May 1790: All original 13 States ratify Constitution Drafting Problems • Division of power • States’ rights vs. federal powers • Procedure…

Words 322 - Pages 2

United States Constitution and Rep Votes Way Essay

Study guide – PSC 201 exam one 1) What were the weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation? No executive branch no national courts unicameral Congress required 9/13ths vote no power to levy taxes 2) Discuss the 3/5ths and Great compromises in detail. 3/5ths Each slave count as 3/5 of vote Used as a tool to get slave states to ratify Great compromise Aka Connecticut Compromise Created bicameral Congress House = population Senate = equal Compromise between Virginia and…

Words 553 - Pages 3

Shay s Rebellion Essay

Lee Penniman! A.P Politics and Government! March 10, 2014! Select either Shays' Rebellion or ADA, 1990. Discuss how your chosen event/legislation is either an example of Freedom vs. Order or Freedom vs. Equality.! ! I chose to read Shay’s Rebellion. I chose this event because I am interested in the Articles of Confederation. Shay’s Rebellion is an example of Freedom v.s Order. Shay’s Rebellion is an example of Freedom v.s Order because it shows the American Government at a time were states were given…

Words 701 - Pages 3

United States Constitution and Political Parties Essay

“We the People…” The Constitution in Review What is Government?  We need government to protect the rights of the people.  In America we have a Republican form of government – The people elect leaders to make laws and vote on decisions for them  In America we also have a Constitutional government – A Constitutional government has limits to its power. Opposite of a dictatorial government. Separation of Powers  To avoid the abuse of power, we separate powers into three branches. – Legislative…

Words 762 - Pages 4

The Articles Of Confederation Of The United States

Continental congress formed a fed government and adopted the articles of confederation Articles of confederation created a federal congress composed of representation of the 13 new states 1787 Constitutional convention was convened in Philly in May 1787 Primary purpose to strengthen the fed government Constitution was reported to Congress in September 1787 State ratification of the Constitution completed in 1788 US Constitution Article 1, Section 2 Representatives and direct taxes Plessy…

Words 581 - Pages 3