Essay on Assess The Arguments For The Retention

Submitted By issy1996
Words: 1102
Pages: 5
Open Document
Assess the arguments for the retention of the FPTP for the UK general elections

FPTP is a simple plurality system which means that the winner is the candidate who gains the most votes. Some may argue that it should be abolished in favour of Proportional representation because it is will provide the government with more legitimacy. However, I am of the opinion that it should be retained because it produces a strong government. Proportional representation would produce a weak and ineffective government because it will create coalitions.
FPTP should be retained because it produces a strong government. This electoral system ensures that the winning party has a majority in the commons because they must win at least 326 seats out of 650. This will ensure that the government is able to make decisions based around its manifesto without having to make deals or compromise with other parties. For example, Blair’s government of 1997 was successfully able to make education their number one priority by reducing pupil-teacher ratios and class sizes in primary and secondary schools. Moreover, he increased per pupil funding by 48% and the government increased spending on education to £1.2bn every week. Therefore FPTP allows the government to fulfil its mandate as there is little stalemate when it comes to implementing their manifesto.
However, some may argue that FPTP needs to be replaced with proportional representation. This is because although a government elected under FPTP will have a majority in the Commons they rarely achieve this through gaining a majority of the votes. They get less than 50% which means that they are ruling with a minority of the vote. No single party since 1931 has won 50% of the national vote. Consequently, the government lacks legitimacy as more people vote against them than for them. On the other hand, with proportional representation governments are invariably supported by at least 50% of the electorate. Therefore some may argue that FPTP should be replace by proportional representation because it ensures a popular mandate and the government will have more legitimacy than one elected by FPTP.
FPTP should be retained and not replaced by proportional representation because it produces coalition governments. This is because with PR the percentage of votes cast equals the percentage of seats gained and to form a government a party needs over 50%. As this is unlikely the party with the most votes often needs to form a coalition with another party. This creates an unstable government because coalitions collapse easily due to the internal divisions. Therefore they are less likely to return for a full term in office. Whereas, FPTP produces a stable government because the government is not undermined by coalition deals which can create insecurity. Consequently they are able to serve a full term in office. Thus it can be seen that FPTP should be retained because it produces a stable government, unlike PR.
However, proportional representation is a better electoral system than FPTP because it promotes democracy. This is because PR widens effective electoral choice because a larger number of parties have the prospect of winning or sharing power. With FPTP votes for minor parties are ‘wasted’ because their support is not concentrated in enough constituencies for them to gain the seats needed to win. Moreover, the existence of safe seat makes it pointless to vote for other parties within a particular constituency (e.g. Kensington is a conservative safe seat). On the other hand, PR means that votes for a small party are not wasted because all votes are equal (small parties are not underrepresented). Therefore some may argue that FPTP should be replaced by PR because it promotes democracy. FPTP makes votes unequal because votes in a marginal seat are of more value than those in safe seats.
FPTP should be retained because it keeps out extremist parties. It’s unlikely that any extremist groups will win a seat because they
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on Assess The Arguments For The Retention

Negligent Retention Paper

BUS 5511 Human Resource Management Case Study 2 - The Negligent Hiring/Retention Case Introduction Personally Yours, Inc. is a personal assistant firm founded in 1997 that provides services such as housekeeping, companionship, grocery shopping and handyperson work (SHRM, 2009). The company has grown to over 250 employees, with branch offices across Florida. Violet Jennings is the manager of the Tampa East branch, one of the largest branches with over 60 employees. Jennings has been friends…

Words 1323 - Pages 6

Essay on Management: Economics and Study Employee Training

employee motivation, thereby upholding a generation of new knowledge and innovation (Sung et al 2014, p. 394). From the employee’s viewpoint it reinforces the belief that the organisation is interested in their well-being, resulting in increased job retention and reducing the risk of losing highly skilled employees. Research shows that investments in HRD have a positive relationship with employee commitment, market share and profits (Stone 2013, p. 356). Therefore it would be unfavourable for the company…

Words 646 - Pages 3

Gender Pay Gap

In the realm of contemporary society, the gender pay gap is a persistent inequality and systemic bias. Across various industries, disparities in earnings between men and women persist, creating debates surrounding gender equity and workplace fairness. Therefore, this paper seeks to investigate the complexities of the gender pay gap. Principally, it will accomplish this by offering an analysis of its historical basis. In addition, an examination of divergent perspectives will be conducted. Lastly…

Words 1253 - Pages 6

Essay about Rosewood Hotels

CONTENTS I. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1 II. SITUATION ANALYSIS 2 a) Economic Environment & Industry Trends 2 b) Organizational & Political Environment 3 c) SWOT analysis for Rosewood 5 III. PROBLEMS FOUND IN SITUATION ANALYSIS 6 IV. STRATEGIC ALTERNATIVES 9 a) Corporate Branding 9 b) Individual Branding 11 c) Selective Corporate Branding 12 PROPOSED BRANDING STRATEGY - SELECTIVE CORPORATE BRANDING STRATEGY 13 SUMMARY 15 APPENDICES 16 I. EXECUTIVE…

Words 1850 - Pages 8

Essay on Management Skills Ass1

deliver the two objectives. Introduction Translink’s ‘Corporate Plan’ is an aggregation of the 4 transport company business plans (NI Railways, Metro, Ulsterbus and Ulsterbus Tours), that together form the Translink brand. It provides the data and argument in support of the group’s current three-year strategy. The Plan identifies the group’s vision, values and objectives as well as the programmes of work that shall deliver the objectives. The Plan also publishes performance and expenditure statistics…

Words 1009 - Pages 5

What Is Diversity Management

effectiveness are considered. The findings demonstrate a few variations based on level of government, region, and size of agency. In addition, the majority of respondents believed that the organization's diversity strategy was effective at recruitment, retention, development, and promotion; however, there was uncertainty about the effectiveness of the diversity strategy on organizational performance. Introduction The subject of diversity has become salient to employers, as demographics have changed within…

Words 6757 - Pages 28

Intro to Human Resources Essay

you can train Skill and Knowledge * Tools for job analysis * Types of tools (for example, Job Element Inventory) * Job element inventory, position analysis questionnaire, Fleishman system, O*Net * Which KSAOs does each tool assess (if applicable) * JEI: none * PAQ: skills, knowledge * Fleishman: abilities * O*Net: skills, knowledge, abilities, other * Rating scales each tool uses (if applicable) * JEI: barely acceptable, superior, trouble *…

Words 1559 - Pages 7

HR Contextual Factors That Will Shape The Business Competitive Strategy

The Organizational Environment Identifying the HR Contextual Factors that will shape the business competitive strategy. SWOT analysis The New Competitive Context No Sustainable Competitive Advantage: HYPERCOMPETITION- all competitive advantages are short-term and temporary Due to: Iconoclastic market rivals- competition we didn’t expect “reject the past way of doing things” Transitory customer tastes- less brand identity, people change Ineffective barriers to entry- new ways of thinking Rapid…

Words 1347 - Pages 6

Essay Maslow ' s Hierarchy of Needs and Occupational Psychology

Type (i.e. Journal Review/Essay) Marking 1 st 2 Marker(s) nd (Initials) Provisional Mark(s) Late (days) Penalty Marks Deducted Overall Mark Feedback Excellent Good Adequate Poor Very Poor Answers the Question and /or Develops an Argument Structure Theoretical and/or Factual Clarity Analytical Content Literature and Use of Sources Appropriate Referencing Comments: 1 Critically evaluate the contribution of occupational psychology theories in the formation and management of innovative…

Words 1992 - Pages 8

Essay about Assess the usefulness of the Hypodermic Syringe model of the mass media

Mass Media (Q) Assess the usefulness of the Hypodermic Syringe model of the mass media. The hypodermic Syringe Model (HSM) is an early theory model, which believes that there is a direct correlation between the violence and anti-social behaviour portrayed in different media types (e.g. Television, computer games and films). Sociologists found that the most venerable audience to the HSM are children and teenagers. this is because they are still in the early stages of socialization so are therefore…

Words 1853 - Pages 8