Forest City Ratner Company in June 2009 revised the MTA payment on the Vanderbilt rail yards. This new payment consists of a payment of $20 million upfront and $80 million in payments and interests for the next 21 years. This revision also reduced funds for the construction of the new rail yards for the Long Island Rail Road. The officials of the MTA board approved the revisions made by the FCRC. When the developer overcame one hurdle, another one opposing the beginning of the development was the home and property owners, and the people that lived in the area. People were refusing to leave and vacate the property. Goldstein represented the community of those who didn’t want to leave and filed a law suit in 2006 suing New York State officials, New York City officials, and Forest City Ratner developer. They were claiming an improper use of eminent domain under the United States Constitution and New York State Law. A District Court dismissed Goldstein’s and the other property owner’s claims. The courts dismissed Mr. Goldstein’s claim and others supporting him because the property around the Atlantic Yards was labeled by the state to be a blighted community. When the state labels a neighborhood into this condition it is best to vacate the property set for demolition. Many of the developers know what neighborhoods to attack being that its best to build everything from scratch to meet the newer state and city standards. Many consider this a tactic to obtain the property of those against major developmental projects. The officials supporting the project want to get this completed with no further opposition. The official’s only way out is using the backdoor exit of the eminent domain law to consider the property as a blighted neighborhood. This forces owners that are against the development to vacate the property as the government seizes their land. Goldstein and the opposing property owners started to