Benefits Of Immigration

Words: 1886
Pages: 8
Open Document
The Necessity and Benefit of Immigration to the United States
A controversial topic in today’s politics is the state of immigration in America. While public opinion is generally positive, politicians continue to disagree over the necessity of immigration, and the approaches which can be taken to create a successful body of immigration policies. Thomas Jefferson, however, was certain that immigration would allow the United States to grow and thrive if handled in a way that made the system beneficial to the United States as a whole.
The DREAM Act and Immigration in America
A survey conducted by the Pew Research Center shows that 75% of the 1,504 American adults surveyed believe that Immigration Policy needs ‘major changes’ or to be ‘completely …show more content…
Even though he was born and raised in America, Thomas Jefferson consistently supported immigrants' rights to relocate to nations where they felt they would have the lives they wanted. He wrote numerous letters to immigrants and other politicians on the topic, maintaining that it was a right that could not be revoked. In a letter to the Secretary of the Treasury, Albert Gallatin, in 1806 Thomas Jefferson stated:
I hold the right of expatriation to be inherent in every man by the laws of nature, and incapable of being rightfully taken from him even by the united will of every other person in the nation. If the laws have provided no particular mode by which the right of expatriation may be exercised, the individual may do it by any effectual and unequivocal act or declaration. [...] The general government has nothing to do with this question. Congress may by the Constitution "establish an uniform rule of naturalization," that is, by what rule an alien may become a citizen. But they cannot take from a citizen his natural right of divesting himself of the character of a citizen by expatriation (Jefferson, 1904, pp. …show more content…
This requires permanent residency of 3-5 years and a naturalization test that covers English and civics (U.S. Citizens and Immigration Services, 2013). Jefferson clearly stated that the laws regulating immigration should “be as equal as prudential considerations will admit [...] to unequal privileges among members of the same society the spirit of our nation is, with one accord, adverse” (Jefferson, 1853, p. 395) and for this reason it is unlikely he would approve of the necessity for immigrants to take tests which require ‘general knowledge’ on American history. A study by the McCormick Tribune Freedom Museum showed that only 28% of Americans are able to name more than one of the five freedoms provided by the First Amendment, while 52% can name at least two members of “The Simpsons” characters (McCormick Tribune Freedom Museum, 2006, p. 1), yet immigrants being nationalized are expected to know the answer to the same question in addition to anything from how many amendments the Constitution has to who the current Speaker of the House of Representatives is (U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, 2011, pp. 1 & 5). By Jefferson’s standards, it would be unreasonable to expect immigrants to know more about America than Americans do. Jefferson would more likely be interested in the aspirations of immigrants as Americans; taking into consideration their social and professional goals would not only
Show More

Related Documents: Benefits Of Immigration

The Benefits Of Immigration

Immigration serves many purposes in society. The US benefits from the cultures of immigrants. As people immigrate, they bring over their customs, traditions, and foods, and that serves in bringing diversity to the United States. Another great benefit in allowing immigration is the fact that immigrants come and are allowed to work. With the growing population, we need people in the US who will willingly A few dysfunctions of immigration are namely: job shortages for Americans, disease transfers…

Words 386 - Pages 2

Summary: The Benefits Of Immigration

Immigration is a topic U.S. citizens has been arguing about for the past decades. Many people wonder if it's beneficial to have so many foreign people to come into the country, or whether it hurts us more than it helps. Supporters say immigration boosts the economy, helps the U.S. workers, and holds the key to innovation. Others not in support of it say it takes U.S. jobs and causes the nation to not be secure. The answer is not clear, but one thing is certain, it's been part of our culture for centuries…

Words 412 - Pages 2

Immigration: Benefit Immigration Workforces Essay

Summary: In this article, the author-Gordon H. Hanson is trying to point out the good influences that immigrant workers have on America economy between short and long-term. First, he talks about how benefit immigration workforces can contribute their innovation can help to increase the nation’s welfare. In fact, according to National Science Foundation’s survey of Earned Doctorates show that “the share of PhDs awarded to foreign students rose from one fifth to three fourths in mathematics, computer…

Words 541 - Pages 3

Illegal Immigration Benefits

In addition to the economy and crime rates, illegal immigration also affects the financial aspect of America. There is some evidence that illegal immigrants help save employers money: “Their collective work effort generates an estimated $64 billion in savings” (Haugen 36). Because illegals accept lower wages, employers save money because they are paying less for labor. However, other evidence shows that illegal immigrants actually cost more money than they bring in: “In 1996, a study by the National…

Words 306 - Pages 2

Illegal Immigration Benefits

because they feel it is a great place to live, because of the benefits, protection, and freedom. Benefits like welfare, having one of the greatest militaries for protection, and a government that grates freedom to its’ citizen’s. These are the reasons America has received millions of immigrants throughout the countries lifetime. This number is hurting…

Words 1487 - Pages 6

Summary Of The Costs And Benefits Of Immigration

Despite the longevity of immigration in the United States, the effects that come from it continue to be an area of discussion to this day. Immigration can be defined as the process of living permanently in another country, in this case, the United States. Since earlier centuries, there have been groups of people with a strong sense of nativism who argue immigration has negative impacts on the U.S., while other groups of people argue in favor of immigration. One of the most highly debated issues within…

Words 1632 - Pages 7

Macro Paper on Immigration

October 2014 Immigration What is immigration? Immigration is the action of coming to live permanently in a foreign country. There have been immigrants for just about as long as there has been the country of the United States. Arguably even longer since the first people to settle the United States had been immigrants from England. This is to show how long immigration has been going on in the world. Immigration is connected to the economy in many ways. As seen in article one, “Immigration both creates…

Words 720 - Pages 3

Immigration Reform Research Paper

Immigration Reform The United States has emerged as an economic superpower in recent decades marked by a heightened openness, which began with increasing trade and migration. Immigration helped pave the way for the superpower status of the US and continued to play a key role in securing the country’s economic future. Immigrants accounted for over half of the labor force growth in the US during the past decade, and by 2008 census, the foreign born comprised over 16 percent of the labor force of the…

Words 892 - Pages 4

Essay about Here are some facts about immigration

Here are some facts about immigration. Approximately ¾ of people in Britain favor reducing immigration. Large majorities in Britain have been opposed to immigration since at least the 1960s. Immigration is currently highly popular. Over the past 15 years it has become one of the most commonly chosen 'most important issues'. But what do you think? In the past two decades, the UK has experienced a steady flow of net migrants into the economy. Net migration is a significant factor in the growth of the…

Words 394 - Pages 2

What Are The Pros And Cons Of Illegal Immigration

Immigration, as any other issue has its pros and cons. The United States has been known as the land of opportunities, so millions of immigrants decided to come here and start a new life, either legally or illegally. One of the pros of the immigration issue is that, overall, America benefits from illegal immigration because illegal immigrants are down to do jobs that Americans wouldn’t. They are willing to accept any kind of job and sometimes they are very skilled so the companies who would hire them…

Words 254 - Pages 2