Blame Paper

Submitted By pjkoscher
Words: 1412
Pages: 6
Open Document
PJ Koscher

An Analysis of the Nature of Blame: Reactive Attitude vs. Assessment

In current philosophical literature on moral responsibility, there have been recent developments on the increased focus on the nature of blame. A theory of the nature of blame claims to understand what it means for one to morally blame another for an act previously performed. An account of the nature of blame is an account of the conditions necessary for the holding of the blame relation to be deemed appropriate. There are three main accounts of the nature of blame currently in play in philosophical literature on moral responsibility: sanction, assessment, and reactive attitude. In this essay, I will provide a thorough explanation of both the reactive attitude and the assessment accounts and will show how the reactive attitude account outperforms the assessment account. Then I will introduce a common objection to the reactive attitude account and sketch how an advocate of the reactive attitude account might respond to the objection.

The assessment account of blame suggests that when we blame a person for an act they performed, we reveal something negative about the person’s character. One way to explain the assessment account is to imagine a moral balance sheet. This moral balance sheet can also be thought as a demerit system. When a person acts out of a norm and is blamed, then something negative is revealed in their character. When something negative is revealed in a person’s character, their moral record is considered negative, suggesting they have lowered their moral worth. This works in the other way as well. When a moral act is performed, something positive is revealed in one’s character. When this happens, a person’s moral record is considered positive, suggesting they have increased their moral worth. In other words, when an act is praised the person has increased their moral worth, while when an act is negative the person has lowered their moral worth. One of the key points to recognize from the assessment account of blame is humans care about what people think of them, meaning they care about their moral evaluations because these moral evaluations are how people judge our moral worth. An advantage to the assessment account of blame is it allows for private blame. Private blame is where one can make an assessment without ever expressing it to the person. In blaming a person, we are not only judging blameworthiness, but also judging the negative bring up of someone’s character.

The reactive attitude account of blame relates to a set of attitudes that hold people responsible for their actions. This account of blame derives from the notable philosopher, P.F. Strawson. These “reactive attitudes” are emotional reactions to the good and bad actions that people perform towards themselves and others. The emotional reactions in reactive attitudes tend to relate to negative emotions such as resentment and guilt. An important note of the reactive attitude account of blame refers to the interpretation of blame. Blame is more than just emotions resulting in a reaction from certain behavior; blame is an emotional response to the ill will that people exhibit towards themselves and others. When we are blaming someone, we are emotionally exercising on what they have done. This emotional exercise carries a negative reaction towards the person whom we are blaming. Therefore, we are holding the blamed person accountable for their actions through exercised emotion. An advantage of the reactive attitude account of blame is it also allows for private blame (see previous paragraph for private blame definition). Not only can the reactive attitude account allow for private blame, but it can also give us a way to communicate our reactive emotions with others. This communication leads to the “basic moral demand,” which consists of our expectation of moral behavior. In other words, we demand a displayed absence of ill will behavior. If moral behavior is
Show More

Related Documents: Blame Paper

Who Is To Blame For The Titanic Research Paper

Some experts say that the Titanic’s design was the cause of the sinking. Others say that it was the captain. Many say that it was the radio operators fault. Who really was the main person to sink the Titanic? Captain Smith is responsible for the sinking of the Titanic because he didn’t pay attention to his surroundings, he was worrying about setting speed records, and he was ignoring the ice warnings. Although, Smith helped save people, Smith was still the main person who is responsible…

Words 320 - Pages 2

Friar Lawrence To Blame For Romeo And Juliet Research Paper

Who’s to Blame for? In Shakespeare's play Romeo and Juliet are star crossed lovers who are from two households, both alike in dignity, who have had a long standing rivalry and hatred for each other. The star crossed lovers fell in love before finding out they were mortal enemies. After a poorly executed plan by the friar Lawrence, the story ends with the lovers dying together side by side. Friar Lawrence is responsible for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet. The first piece of evidence from the text…

Words 274 - Pages 2

Rhetorical Analysis Of Flint Water Crisis In Flint By Morckel

passive-aggressive manner. She blames the Flint water crisis on the city’s government and society itself, putting blame on large groups of people and institutions. This makes the reader feel guilty for the occurrences in Flint, as well as other crises mentioned later in the article, and ultimately angry at those who failed to recognize or prevent the problem beforehand. Although this gets her point across, it is very hostile and relatively unsophisticated. Morckel also referred to her own paper throughout her…

Words 299 - Pages 2

Personal Responsibility Research Paper

make strenuous personal efforts to live by those standards. But personal responsibility also means that when individuals fail to meet expected standards, they do not look around for some factor outside themselves to blame. The demise of personal responsibility occurs when individuals blame their family, their peers, their economic circumstances, or their society for their own failure to meet standards" (Haskins). We all need stability in our lives. Just ask the single mother of two who works full-time…

Words 1104 - Pages 5

Meg Wiviott's Paper Hearts Essay

Scapegoating is present in Meg Wiviott’s novel, Paper Hearts in order to emphasize the horrendous conditions which Fania and Zlatka lived in; Wiviott successfully argues that even in a world that is corrupt, it is necessary to find a reason to stay alive through the recurrence of scapegoats. Paper hearts takes place in World War II, the late 1930s until the mid 1940s. World War I was resolved with the Treaty of Versailles which blamed Germany for all aspects of the war. As a result Germany had a…

Words 548 - Pages 3

Ethical: Academic Journal and Term Paper

pick one of the topics listed below. Please follow APA format (if you are not familiar with APA, Purdue OWL has an excellent website on APA format). You must submit your paper to blackboard via safe assign and to live text. The term paper is a requirement for this course. Write a 5 – 7 page (body of the paper) APA term paper from the list of ethics topics below. Ethics Topics (Please select one) 1. Politicians often say that President Bush’s tax cuts were for the rich. In 2005, the top…

Words 627 - Pages 3

Domestic Violence Against Women Research Paper

Domestic abuse against women In her news article, the spokesperson for amnesty international describes domestic violence as a worldwide phenomenon that violates the human rights of female victims (Mite, 2005). In addition, the United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) described violence against women as “a global epidemic that kills, tortures, and maims – physically, psychologically, sexually and economically. It is one of the most pervasive of human rights violations, denying women and girls…

Words 981 - Pages 4

Bribery In The 1960's

positive or negative progress, and one must question the legitimacy of the scientific claims that are continually being presented. The case being especially true for nutrition. In the 1960’s, the sugar industry paid accredited scientists to shift blame to the fat industry, specifically saturated fats and cholesterol, to mask the discovery that sugar plays a major role in heart disease. while this trend started through the 1960’s, we can see how even to this day, a majority of our population believes…

Words 1461 - Pages 6

Social Issues In America

Nicholas Crisafulle Professor Greg Lukasik SYG 2010-001 Section 002 October 8, 2017 What’s to Blame? [Social Problems Paper 1] There are numerous social issues that can occur in a society. Some of these issues are so common that they occur on a global scale. From hunger, to poverty, or even domestic terrorism; all issues have a negative impact on our lives, regardless of how affective. The problem of attempting to find a solution to issues such as hunger, is finding the origin in which it derives…

Words 790 - Pages 4

Myth Buster Research Paper

Research Paper Kemper Martin ASU SPE521 Professor Paul November 21, 2017 Myth Buster Research Paper Introduction There are many myths regarding the cause of Autism. One myth will be discussed in this paper. The myth is “Autism is caused by poor parenting, “refrigerator mothers”. The origin of this myth started in 1943 by Dr. Leo Kanner. He made it now that a lack of parental nurturing and connection with their autist child was attributed to the child’s ASD. In 1949 he wrote a paper coining…

Words 800 - Pages 4