Book Bans

Words: 2294
Pages: 10
Open Document
Perspectives on Book Bans in Schools

Meagan Tran West Delaware High School ENG 105: Composition I Mrs. Gelwicks February 28, 2024.

Perspectives on Book Bans in Schools Book banning in schools is a topic that elicits diverse perspectives among educators, parents, and policymakers. Stemming from historical instances of censorship and moral concerns, the practice of restricting certain books from educational settings continues to provoke discussion about intellectual freedom, educational value, and the well-being of students. Supporters argue for the necessity of shielding students from potentially harmful or inappropriate content, while critics contend that such measures may restrict critical thinking, limit exposure to diverse perspectives, …show more content…
They advocate for the inclusion of a wide range of literature, even if controversial or challenging, to enrich students' learning experiences. According to Timothy Patrick McCarthy, an educator, he perceives book bans as rooted in racism. Drawing from his background as a historian, he contends that those who advocate for book bans are historically situated on the wrong side of history (Ross, 2023). Additionally, opponents of the book ban emphasize the need to respect students' autonomy and their right to access information without undue restriction. They contend that instead of banning books, educators should engage in open discussions and provide guidance to help students navigate sensitive topics responsibly. While collecting a survey of educators, they revealed that at least a quarter of teachers reported …show more content…
As well as, an interview with Erika Long where she stated, "I was not surprised.but I was very frustrated. Parents have the right to monitor and select—or disagree with—certain materials for their children, but it’s highly inappropriate for them to do that for other people’s kids" (lvarez, 2022). Ultimately, these educators believe that maintaining a diverse and inclusive literary environment is essential for fostering a well-rounded education and preparing students to become informed and critical members of society. Conclusion The topic of book banning in schools presents a complex and continuous issue. While some argue for the protection of students from potentially harmful content, others advocate for intellectual freedom and the exploration of diverse perspectives. Additional research could further increase the impact of book banning on educational outcomes and student development. However, it is important to acknowledge the limitations of censorship in addressing broader societal concerns. Moving forward, it is likely that discussions surrounding book banning will continue to
Show More

Related Documents: Book Bans

Why Ban Books Should Be Banned Essay

People may see this and have multiple questions on their mind. For example “Why ban books anyway?”, “Who are these poor authors, and what books of theirs are banned?”, “So are banned books a good thing or a bad thing?” Not to worry now dear person, the answers shall provided. So why ban books anyway? In Natalie DiBlasio’s article “Schools Once Again Face Bind Over Censorship vs. Book Lists” a Library Association spokeswoman states, “The top reasons for challenges are sexually explicit content, offensive…

Words 859 - Pages 4

Annotated Bibliography: Common Reasons For Banning Books

Book Banning The American Association of School Administrators and the American Library Association define censorship as: “The removal, suppression, or restricted circulation of literary, artistic, or educational materials – of images, ideas, and information – on the grounds that these are morally or otherwise objectionable in light of standards applied by the censor.” This essay discusses why Public Libraries should ban books, Public libraries should ban books because it could improperly influence…

Words 479 - Pages 2

Rudolfo Anaya's Bless Me Ultima

Since 1972 the book Bless Me Ultima has been banned from California all the way to New York. The book had been causing so much controversy because some people claim it has too much profanity. The book is about a woman named Ultima, she was in the birth of Antonio, the main character, and only she knows what he will become in the future. Despite its popularity with some students and teachers, Rudolfo Anaya’s novel continues to be controversial and has been banned by numerous school districts due…

Words 331 - Pages 2

Banning Books In Schools Research Paper

Association tracks book challenges and has reported that from 2019 to 2022 the number of challenges has increased drastically, attempting to ban almost 1,597 books. In August of 2023, the A.L.A. reported 695 challenges, a 20% increase from 2022. The problem with book banning is getting worse and something needs to be done. People should not be able to ban books in libraries because parents control what their kids read, other people's stories shouldn't be suppressed, and reading books kids actually want…

Words 607 - Pages 3

Argumentative Essay: Banned Books

People ban books it for the sole reason that they think that this book is inappropriate for other people to read. So, people who make these choices take away our freedom to choose what we want. Banned books like Harry Potter by J.K Rowling was banned in some areas because it encourages witchcraft. Charlie and the Chocolate Factory ‘ by Roald Dahl was banned because it encourage racism. Other books were banned because of its…

Words 1002 - Pages 5

Why Is Banning Books Banned

Books being Banned: A Problem of the 21st Century. Book banning has been occurring since the 1600’s. A few hundred years later things have begun to get out of hand, with some school districts and libraries going as far as banning books such as Charlotte's Web and The Lorax. There are over 1,000 books banned in the United States; at least 300 of those titles are children's picture books. Through the act of banning books, children and teens are virtually stripped of the right to choose what they want…

Words 734 - Pages 3

Argumentative Essay Of Banning Books

other option is to read about it.Most people would choose to read it. Some people want to ban books,and we should never ban books.Books change the way we think,the support religions and the they support freedom of speech. Books change the way we think. According to a debate I read on Sirs Issues Researcher it said"Books can influence events long after they have been written." For example,there are many books about World War II and many people have read about the War and learned about the pain innocent…

Words 684 - Pages 3

Argumentative Essay On Banning Books

should be able to write a book without the worries of someone trying to ban it. For decades, Americans have gotten books banned due to them finding the material outrages. So many books are removed from schools and libraries because society found it offensive. Books are banned for the smallest reasons, “Sometimes books are banned not because of what they say but because of something the author said or did” (“Library Censorship Is Not Justified” 2). The reader can ban a book if they did not like what…

Words 1104 - Pages 5

To Ban Or Not To Ban Essay

February 26, 2015 To Ban or not to Ban? Should Huck Finn be taught in schools? This question has been widely debated over the past years and it still is till this day. Many say that the book should be banned from schools because of the racial comments in the book; people claim that it could offend the youth, but all the book does is enlighten the youth about the American history of slavery. The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn remains as one of the most controversial books taught in high school today…

Words 898 - Pages 4

Banning Books Is Limiting Education

Some believe that banning books is a profitable idea, however, some critics argue that banning books is limiting education. on the authority of Siby Shaji, “These challenged and controversial texts often delve unflinchingly into the complexities and challenges of life, addressing issues such as bullying, abuse, discrimination, and societal injustices that young individuals may inevitably encounter as they navigate their path to adulthood. Shielding children from these uncomfortable realities can…

Words 144 - Pages 1