Broken Patient Autonomy In Health Care

Words: 2179
Pages: 9
Open Document
To many people, the word “autonomy” simply means the fundamental freedom of choice and independence. Many of us will not go beyond those words and understand how it can be applied in a medical setting. Patient autonomy is the right of a patient to make decisions about their individual medical care without the influence of their health care provider (“Patient Autonomy”). This concept is put in place because it gives an individual the freedom to choose their course of treatment, whether the healthcare professional’s own values conflict with it or not. Without autonomy, patients would be forced to go through procedures, surgeries, and other treatment protocols that do not fit their lifestyle, belief system, or personal situation at that very …show more content…
Hospitals, such as Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center, have implemented programs that are centered on getting patients involved in their treatment arrangements. Patients are asked to participate in a study that evaluates their insight and objectives of consideration before they see their specialist. That way, the specialist recognizes what the patient needs and can fuse it into a treatment arrangement, and the patient is able to ensure his or her voice is heard. I believe every hospital could benefit from programs such as this, as it would improve the experience for both patient and physician in the long …show more content…
There is a case study that illustrates broken patient autonomy. A woman comes to the emergency room complaining of stomach pain. After undergoing a CT scan, she was told she has an abdominal aortic aneurysm and her chance of survival is 50/50. The physicians inform her that her time here on earth is very fragile. This woman is an erotic dancer; her main concern is that the surgery will leave a nasty scar that could potentially affect her work. This concern of hers makes her refuse the surgical treatment. The physicians try to push the surgery, but she does not back down from her choice. Knowing the patient’s decision, the physicians decide to perform the surgery anyway. They feel that she is not in the right state of mind to make the right decision, so they make it for her without her consent. She undergoes the surgery and survives. After recovering, the woman sues the hospital. She feels as if her choice was not taken into consideration and her freedom of choice was robbed from her. There are always a lot of questions that can come along with a case like this. Some examples of such questions are: Do you believe that the physician's actions can be justified in any way? Is there anything else that they could have done? Is it ever right to take away someone's autonomy? What would you do if you were one of the health care workers? These questions can definitely be justified, but only to a certain
Show More

Related Documents: Broken Patient Autonomy In Health Care

Substance Abuse In Nursing

nurses have a substance misuse, abuse, and or addiction problem (Kunyk, 2013). Substance use among health professionals is a problem that threatens professional standards and the delivery of quality patient care. A chemically impaired nurse requires immediate concern and attention. Substance use in nursing impacts professional and personal relationships, put patients at risk and can cause possible health complications. Violation of Ethical Principle by Chemically Dependent Nurses There are many ethical…

Words 1014 - Pages 5

Ethics: Ethics and Health Information Essay

understand why a patient would refuse care or treatment that could potentially save their lives. We are trained to treat, heal and care for our patients; when they refuse care or treatment because of religious, cultural or even unknown reasons we often question what’s best for this patient. Should they be forced to accept the treatment? Should we rally their family to help “convince” them? Is it ok to refuse treatment, knowing they will die if they don’t get it? The bottom line is, patients have a right…

Words 3089 - Pages 13

Gcu Reflective Journal

During my work in the CCU, we had a “young” patient that we knew would evitable die in the hospital. The young man had been a frequent patient in our unit due to congenital heart defects. During this last hospitalization, each and every organ system was slowly shutting down but the family was having difficulty accepting that their loved one was dying. The family refused to make the patient a “DNR” and he was coded multiple times over the month the spent with us. The final code, I wouldn't necessarily…

Words 378 - Pages 2

LAW AND ETHICS 2 Essays

these terms ‘law’ and ‘ethics’ must first be understood. Most times, ethics are not punishable unlike Law; it is punishable by the authority. No real patients name will be used in this essay, only pseudonym This case study will be analysed using the ethical principles (Beauchamp and Childress, 2001). Mr. White (not real name) is a 70yr old patient who has been quite healthy all through his life besides some issues with pneumonia in the previous years. He was driving along the road when he hit a patch…

Words 3319 - Pages 14

Do Not Resuscitate Orders In Pediatric Patients

Do Not Resuscitate Orders in Pediatric Patients Ethical Issues in Healthcare Abstract Children with terminal illnesses frequently have do not resuscitate orders. Dealing with dying children, and letting them die without major intervention can be hard issues for nursing and other health care professionals to cope with, and can cause an internal ethical dilemma. The seven nursing ethical principles are discussed in regards to do not resuscitate orders, and ethical theory is applied. The ethical…

Words 1856 - Pages 8

Ella Miller Final paper

experience for the patient and their family. It is very important that the patient not only knows what they want as far as their right to receive or reject treatment and medications or knowing whether they want to receive palliative care at home or in a hospital setting to include the advantages and disadvantages of each. The main focus of this paper is to give the reader an in depth look on how an end of life crisis affects a patient and their family. Ella is a breast cancer patient who just came out…

Words 3484 - Pages 14

Explain How The Patient Bill Of Rights Applies To This Case

Assignment 5: Assisted Suicide Cassandra Jones HSA 515 Professor Griffin June 10, 2012 1. Explain how the patient Bill of Rights applies to this case. The Patient’s Bill of Rights was established to contribute to more effective patient care, and to ensure that care is considerate and respectful. Mrs. Jones, in our scenario, is a patient evidently suffering from a terminal illness possibly in its latter stage. Mrs. Jones did not choose to get terminal cancer, however; she has also not chosen…

Words 1483 - Pages 6

Importance Of Professionalism In Nursing

knowledge and the skillfulness to practice and organize his or her work correctly while being able to fulfill that work on the highest level. Lack of professionalism while in nursing school can lead to academic misconduct that may translate into unsafe patient care and nursing practices. There are lots of expectations that fall on nurses who seek to be professional in their scope of practice. In the United States, it is expected…

Words 859 - Pages 4

Psychiatry Ethical Issues

ethical dilemmas in the work place. This is even more prominent amongst nurses who dare to venture into the specialty of psychiatric mental health nursing. A psychiatric mental health nurses duties include typical nursing duties you would see in any other medical facility. These include administering medication and treatments, checking vital signs, assisting patients with daily activities, monitoring and assisting…

Words 1127 - Pages 5

Human Genome Project: Purpose And Implications

improve prevention, treatment, and discover cures for various diseases. Known as the Human Genome Project, extraordinary research began throughout the United States, which was coordinated by the U.S Department of Energy and the National Institutes of Health. Completed in 2003, the project identified an estimated 25,000 genes and 3 billion base pairs in the DNA of an entire human genome as well as new tools for genetic data analysis and storage, addressing the inherent ethical legal, and social issues…

Words 1909 - Pages 8